Great Wall Dbq Essay

The first reason why the Great Wall was not worth the cost was because the wall was not very effective . The chin and Han dynasty's built the Great Wall to keep out invaders. People would walk around the spots where there wanot a wall built yet or a spot where guards were not on duty. ( Doc B ) The purpose was so that not as many guards would have to be on duty, but just as many guards were then as there were when the wall was not yet built. There were not guards protecting all spots of the wall, leaving it a blank opening for other enemies to enter. The wall was not just

The Great Wall of China was built to protect China from invaders and to keep out raiding parties of nomadic tribes, such as the Mongol, Turic and Xiongnu, from modern-day Mongolia and Manchuria. The Mongols were a tribal group that would regularly raid China. The wall was successful in keeping the Mongols out of China for a while but eventually, the Mongols conquered China. The Wall also kept Chinese citizens from leaving China.

The Great Wall of China is said to be one of the greatest accomplishments done by the Chinese. The wall was first built by the people in the Han and Ming dynasty over a period of 2,500 years, but continued much later by the Ming dynasty. The entire wall measures 4,000 miles. Its purpose was to increase security from their enemy, the Mongols, who were known as barbarians to them. However, the Chinese had to sacrifice a lot to build the wall. So, was building the wall worth all the sacrifice the Chinese had to go through? I think that the Great Wall of China was not worth the cost because of high casualties, harsh conditions, and it still did not stop the Mongols.

How many people do you know who would gladly sacrifice their life to protect a dirt wall? Probably no one. The Great Wall of China was built by the Qin (221-206 BCE) and the Han (206 BCE-220 CE) to keep out the Xiongnu, their rivals in the north. It is estimated that the Qin built approximately 1,500 - 2,500 miles of the wall and the Han built 4,000 miles of it.  There is no query that building the wall provided people with jobs, but did the benefits truly outweigh these human costs? Of course not! The price was too costly to pay. The Great Wall wasn’t worth all the struggle. There were three main costs paid by the people of China: forced labor, death from starvation/hunger, and the loss of valuable resources.

For thousands years, the Mongols have been a big threat to the Chinese civilization. The Great Wall of China took about 2000 years to build and finish. It has been measured to be over 5,488 miles long. Due to the many threats and enemies of Chinese, the wall was built. In my opinion, the benefits of building the wall do outweigh the costs for many reasons surrounding the topic.

The lives ruined or lost in the building of the wall was the greatest cost. According to one ancient chinese scripture “During a ten year period of Qin Dynasty wall building, there was a heavy use of peasant laborers who worked seven days a week with little food.” And another scripture, “One campaign in 104 B.C. Reported 80% of Han Dynasty casualties.” (from attacks by the Xiongnu). The great wall of china was needed to protect the people of china from the northern nomads who wanted to pillage villages, but the great wall of china was actually very weak and the Xiongnu could even bribe their way in if they wanted. Any advantage of the wall do not justify any of the cost associated with building it. In all it is clear that the great wall of china should not have been built.

The Great Wall was built by The Qin and the Han Dynasty. They built The Great Wall to keep out and protect China from the Mongols. The benefits of building The Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs. In Document B, it showed that tribute was being paid by The Han. The Han was one of the the dynasties who first built The Great Wall. This shows that the benefits did not outweigh the costs because The Han still had tribute to pay to the Xiongnu Mongols and The Han dynasty still had to build and protect The Wall from the Mongols. In Document C, the text indicated that The Qin and The Han dynasties were peasants, and worked on The Great Wall while they got feed a little bit of food and suffered. The Qin and The Han were not treated well

The Great Wall of China is often regarded as one of the man-made wonders of the world. The Great Wall of China was constructed by two early Chinese dynasties; the Qin Dynasty (221 BCE-206 BCE) and the Han Dynasty (206 BCE-220 CE). Emperor Qin was considered to be cruel and brutal. Cruel rulers invite rebellion and in 206 BCE, his successors were overthrown by the Han Dynasty. Both dynasties shared a common concern, border security. The wall was constructed over a period of 2,500 years and stretch to be 5,488 miles long. The wall was built to increase security, impress visitors and enhance the glory of china. However the wall also required much sacrifice on the part of the Chinese people. Overall did the benefits outweigh the costs? There were both costs and benefits into building the Great Wall of China, but the benefits outweigh the cost. The great walls benefits outweighed the costs by providing protection, create new towns

Did you know before the Qin and Han built the Great Wall, the chinese had to build walls around individual cities to protect them. The Great wall of China was built by the Shang and Han Dynasties of ancient china to protect the nation from the Xiongnu. The great wall of china: did the benefit outweigh the cost? The construction of the wall was worth the cost because, he security it provides increased trade and in turn, increased openness to new ideas transferred along the silk road.

The Great Wall of China was originally built during the Qin and Han Dynasties to protect China from the Xiongnu. It took the people of ancient China nearly 2,000 years to build and spans nearly 6,000 miles. However, building the wall was extremely costly in terms of men and supplies. Despite the cost of the wall, it proved to be immensely beneficial to the Chinese people. This is a result of the wall providing protection for merchants, the people within the wall and preventing the Xiongnu from invading.

One reason why the Great Wall was not worth building, is because it caused many deaths. In a chart it says “According to poetry and legends, tens of thousands of soldiers died from hunger, sickness, and extreme heat or cold. No exact number of deaths are available.” (Document E). This source shows that many people died from defending the wall and cruel temperatures, hunger and sickness. For doing this you earn nothing in return. That the wall couldn’t even defend it self. In a poem it says “ The cavalry fight to the death,... If rice isn’t harvested, how will you eat? Although we are willing to serve loyalty, how can we live this way”. (Document F) This source shows

To begin, the benefits did outweigh the costs since the Great Wall allowed protection and security. The text explicitly states in the DBQ packet, “Chinese had built walls to protect individual towns and cities.” The quote suggests that the Great Wall was used for protection which kept invaders from China.

The Great Wall of China was built by the Qin and the Han Dynasty. The reason they built it was so that they could keep out the Mongols from invading. However, the benefit does not outweigh the costs. In the source "The Human Cost of the Great Wall", the article points out that that many soldiers died due to the building of the wall and the bad conditions. This shows that the benefits do not outweigh the cost because if many soldiers died, the population would decrease and there would be less protection against attackers. Another reason for why the benefits of the Great Wall do not outweigh the cost is because peasants died in the process as well. This demonstrates why the wall was not worth the cost. In Document D, the poem stated "If rice

The Great Wall of China is the world’s longest wall and biggest ancient architecture. The Great Wall was finished/opened in 206 BC which meant that the Great Wall took approximately 20 years to build.. There are several reasons why the benefits outweighed the costs, such as, the Great Wall protected China, there would be no more Xiongnu invasions, and the Great Wall follows the famed Silk Road. So, the benefits outweighed the costs in my opinion.

To begin, the Great Wall of China's benefits outweigh pet the cost by protecting China. To explain, the Great Wall of China increased security in China as stated in the background essay, so without it the mongols who especially bothersome ,also stated in the background essay, could have invaded China depriving us the their culture