Great Wall Of China Dbq Essay

The first reason why the Great Wall was not worth the cost was because the wall was not very effective . The chin and Han dynasty's built the Great Wall to keep out invaders. People would walk around the spots where there wanot a wall built yet or a spot where guards were not on duty. ( Doc B ) The purpose was so that not as many guards would have to be on duty, but just as many guards were then as there were when the wall was not yet built. There were not guards protecting all spots of the wall, leaving it a blank opening for other enemies to enter. The wall was not just

The Great Wall of China was built to protect China from invaders and to keep out raiding parties of nomadic tribes, such as the Mongol, Turic and Xiongnu, from modern-day Mongolia and Manchuria. The Mongols were a tribal group that would regularly raid China. The wall was successful in keeping the Mongols out of China for a while but eventually, the Mongols conquered China. The Wall also kept Chinese citizens from leaving China.

The Great Wall was first build by Qin and Han.The reason why they build the wall is because to keep the enemies away like The Mongols.However, the benefits of the Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs.

How many people do you know who would gladly sacrifice their life to protect a dirt wall? Probably no one. The Great Wall of China was built by the Qin (221-206 BCE) and the Han (206 BCE-220 CE) to keep out the Xiongnu, their rivals in the north. It is estimated that the Qin built approximately 1,500 - 2,500 miles of the wall and the Han built 4,000 miles of it.  There is no query that building the wall provided people with jobs, but did the benefits truly outweigh these human costs? Of course not! The price was too costly to pay. The Great Wall wasn’t worth all the struggle. There were three main costs paid by the people of China: forced labor, death from starvation/hunger, and the loss of valuable resources.

In order to fend off the Xiongnu, Qin Shi Huang ordered the construction of an enormous defensive wall. The work was carried out by hundreds of thousands of slaves and criminals between 220 and 206 BCE; untold thousands of them died at the task.

This gave a sense of security to incoming traders from across the land. They felt safe to go beyond these walls and to trade inside. It also helped to increase the economy of China because of the increase of productivity and trade. The main purpose of the road was to protect trade on the silk road. This was the main location of where trade took place in China. The emperor even extended the wall to protect it far enough on the silk road. A China highlights website states that “In the Han Dynasty, the emperor's extended the Great Wall far into western’s China to protect the Silk Road trade” (Pkl). This proves how important it was for China to have these walls even it was at such a heavy

The Great Wall probably remains his most famous contribution to Chinese civilization. The wall scaled off walls originally built for defense against nomads and served as protection as well as a punishment for those who broke Qin laws. Due to the strict nature of the law code and the efficiency of the Qin government, many Chinese were sentenced to construction labor. The new infrastructure, including highways, canals, and irrigation systems, connected distant regions together and allowed the central government to more effectively carry out duties (53). The new routes undoubtedly facilitated travel and

In Document A, the map shows the wall surrounding north china and created a barrier from the Xiongnu people. This shows the wall protected the Chinese people from the Xiongnu by preventing them from invading the land inhabited by the Chinese people. Also in Document A, it says watch towers estimated in the thousand, were placed 2 bow shots apart, stating that soldiers were constantly watching and staying alert for possible attacks. Document B discussed moving people to settle along the northern border, which would discourage invaders from the North. They would be less likely to invade, knowing there were people and troops in the area. Document D says Wu Di assigned thousands of soldiers to wall outpost and watchtowers to protect the merchant and caravans traveling along the trade routes. This allowed the merchants to travel with no fear because the wall protected them from being ambushed by invaders. Providing protection, is a huge benefit and was worth the

The Great Wall was built by The Qin and the Han Dynasty. They built The Great Wall to keep out and protect China from the Mongols. The benefits of building The Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs. In Document B, it showed that tribute was being paid by The Han. The Han was one of the the dynasties who first built The Great Wall. This shows that the benefits did not outweigh the costs because The Han still had tribute to pay to the Xiongnu Mongols and The Han dynasty still had to build and protect The Wall from the Mongols. In Document C, the text indicated that The Qin and The Han dynasties were peasants, and worked on The Great Wall while they got feed a little bit of food and suffered. The Qin and The Han were not treated well

One of the wonders of the world today is the Great Wall of China which was inspired by none other than the Qin Dynasty. Other dynasties put in dedication to having the Great Wall constructed but the Qin Dynasty played a significant role in coming up with the idea for it. The Great Wall of China would benefit China greatly because it would serve as defense against nomadic tribes. Apart from being protected by nomadic tribes, the Great Wall would be a benefit for China’s forever. Other countries

The Great Wall helped a  lot of trading happen but most of the goods were for the rich and wealthy.   You wouldn’t see a peasant wearing ermine fur or eating fancy cold melons, but you would see  a wealthy man with fancy glassware, iced melons, and ermine fur.  “Wu di assigned thousands of soldiers to Wall outposts and watchtowers to protect the merchants and Caravans traveling along the trade routes.”  (Doc D)   This showed how Han made the soldiers and poor do the work and protect the trade but they didn't receive anything in return.

There could have been a choice between building the wall and putting people to guard the frontier and if done correctly the 400,000 that died in the making would not have died. They would have also not taken that much time to be prepared and would not have had to be on the look out for the Xiongnu. Also in document c it says that the Han paid a tribute to the Xiongnu Mongols 5 separate years and it was silk that the Han paid to them. It was not worth the cost to build the wall because they worked things out and the Xiongnu would not attack them

This is a quote from a soldier guarding the walls perspective. “ We fight south of the wall, we die north of the wall” (Document F). The Great wall was constructed to keep out the invaders from north of China. The Great Wall of China was built in Asia, north of China. The chinese built it during the dynasties era. Was the Great wall worth building? The Great Wall of china was not worth building. It was not worth building, because it caused many deaths, tore families apart, and was not well constructed.

One of China’s most recognizable symbols is the Great Wall of China. Standing at 25-feet tall and 4,000 miles long, it was made to fend off attackers from reaching the city. However, the building of such a structure raised many ethical issues, which contained a bit of significance to them. Why cost that many lives, and did the wall even work? In the end, the rebuilding of the Great Wall by the Ming Dynasty during the 14th to 17th century remains maybe one of the most questionable acts during the medieval period, as it resulted in many consequences.

Between 220 B.C. and 206 B.C., the Great Wall of China was built. It was built to be used as defense against the nomadic tribes into the Chinese Empire. Although this barrier was not physically successful, it psychologically separates their civilization from the world. This wall separated two lands and two races. To the north, there are lands that tempted miners in search of gold, breeders that want large prairies for his animals to roam, and the white race. To the south, there are sunnier lands with rich soil and the black-haired race that are considered yellow (Geil 5-6). While there are causes for the building of the wall, there are many effects. These kinds of effects include military effects, environmental wear, and human wear.