preview

Greek Critique

Decent Essays

Critique of the Greeks
Every year, thousands of new college freshmen join on-campus groups, in search of their “home away from home.” Some students chose jobs, while others join Newman groups and sports clubs. A popular choice for an on-campus “home” is the Greek community. College sororities and fraternities are often the subjects of hot debates: what can students gain by going Greek? Do they really do more, than just hold socials? Asel, Seifert and Pascerella wrote an article to answer these questions. While Asel, Seifert, and Pascarella wrote a high-quality article about Greek Life that provides an ample amount of evidence to support their opinions and a logical flow of ideas, the article falls short by having a bias favoring these …show more content…

The article opened with a brief description of the stigmas surrounding Greek life, including the exclusion of those not in Greek life, the excessive se of alcohol, and the practice of hazing, (Asel, Seifert, Pascarella 1). The authors also discuss many of the aspects of Greek Life that people are attracted to: community service, a brother/sisterhood, and opportunities to grow as a leader. After describing these conflicting views, the authors moved into the study they conducted about Greek membership. The authors begin by describing the school where the study was completed, then moved into the students they studied. Next, the variables of the study were addressed, and finally the method of completion. The conclusion, findings, and implications of the findings were put at the end of the article. By organizing the information in a logical manner, the authors made it easy to understand the conflicting opinions that surround fraternity and sorority life, what the data from the study says about these myths, and lastly, the implications the data had on these myths. Authors Asel, Seifert, and Pascarella did an excellent job in providing a host of credible sources for their ideas and organizing them in a reasonable manner. However, they did fall short in a few …show more content…

Because the article was written in response to a study about Greek life, one would think that the article would have next to no bias. This was not the case. The authors hinted their favor for Greek life by describing how “fraternity/sorority members may be natural partners for serving in leadership roles,” (Asel, Seifert, Pascarella 6). In addition, it was also mentioned that following college, those involved in Greek life had stronger personal/interpersonal skills, skills that are exceptionally useful in today’s work place (Asel, Seifert, Pascarella 7). While the authors never directly come out and offer their supports for fraternities and sororities, they show their bias towards these organizations with their word choices. Words like “natural-born leaders” and “leadership roles,” and highlighting the strong social skills gained from Greek life is what makes the reader feel like a bias is present in the

Get Access