Guantanamo Bay Case Study Essay

During the BBC documentary, that shed light to what truly takes place behind the walls of the facility, an American citizen’s heartfelt message to President Obama to continue with the commission hearing to seek justice she stated “you must purse justice for the 3000 victims of September 11th and I ask this in my son Justin’s memory”(Portillo). Justin’s mother’s heartfelt outcry, shown in the documentary, to the President and to the United States government that justice has still not been reached for the deceased or their loved ones. This is a reminder to those that even for a second consider closing this facility that these three thousand people that lost their lives not only were robbed of the opportunity to live fulfilled lives, but also to take part in the lives of their loved ones. The pain that the nation went through during this time has ran deep throughout the nations core and this pain has been reflected in countless efforts to avenge the death of the ones lost during this attack and to prevent others like it. If we were to take the approach of releasing the prisoners we would not only be releasing criminals back into the worlds’ society, but we would also be neglecting the feelings of many Americans.

Speier writes, “brutal actions have fueled hatred abroad and provided potent imagery for terrorist propaganda” (3). Following this assertion, Speier did not fully justify how these “brutal actions,” which she only mentioned to be the force feeding of detainees that were on hunger strike, have created such emotions abroad (2). She also left the readers wondering how these actions are propaganda for terrorist. Although Speier does mention that dressing the journalist in the orange jumpsuit evokes Guantanamo’s imagery of the detainees, she does not develop the argument thoroughly (3). The lack of support impedes her purpose of making the readers appeal to fear, and instead makes them question in depth why she made such statement to begin with. Furthermore, Speier manages to poorly back up a quote from the former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Adm. Mike Mullen, which states, “[Guantanamo is] a ‘recruiting symbol’ for terrorist and jihadist,” which he saw as “the heart of the concern for Guantanamo’s continued existence” (3). Although Adm. Mullen has credibility on the topic because of his position, providing an underdeveloped example on how Guantanamo is actually used as a symbol to recruit terrorist makes her source’s credibility crumble as well as her whole

When the news of torture at Abu Ghraib prison broke in early 2004 during the “global war on terror,” much of the public was outraged and did not know how to react. Heavy debate began over the issue and media reporters on the issues took sides. Many books were written about the subject. The conservatives attempted to downsize the issues and take the side that it was simply ‘bored’ and ‘tense’ soldiers trying to blow off a little steam with horseplay. However, the photographs that surface said quite differently. Naked photographs of prisoners engaged in simulated sexual acts, deceased prisoners in sexual poses and prisoners tied up and left for dead tell the chilling story of the terror and torture behind the prison walls. Did the US do

No, I do not agree that more money should be spent on capital improvements to Gitmo. Ordinarily, I would agree to improvements towards a prison that needs the recommended alterations. However, in this case, I do not think that funds should be disbursed to the Gitmo facility. The inmates there should be treated the same as the prisoners in a regular holding facility. Regardless of the time spent, the resources are too expensive and should not be in the federal budget.

The Guantanamo Bay seems to be a very interesting but historical place. For years it has changed and became what it is today. It is used as a military base, and it's one of the oldest ones. The base has been open since 1903 and was used as multiple things throughout the years. Guantanamo bay is the oldest historical military base located in Cuba.

The author Allen S. Keller, M.D., is the director of the Bellevue Hospital Center and belongs to the member’s advisory council on human rights. (p.558) He is well known for his advocacy on the various use of torture tactics used on Iraqi prisoners and other refuges. During a Congressional meeting Mr. Keller stated "To think that abusive methods, including the enhanced interrogation techniques [in which Keller included waterboarding], are harmless psychological ploys is contradictory to well established medical knowledge and clinical experience." (“CNN”, 2007)

“Never again will you be capable of ordinary human feeling. Everything will be dead inside of you. Never again will you be capable of love, or friendship, or joy of living, or laughter, or curiosity, or courage, or integrity. You will be hollow. We shall squeeze you empty and than we shall fill you with ourselves.” A major part of the process of breaking one’s will down is attacking their mental state. Psychological warfare plays a huge part in the torture being done at Guantanamo. The lights are kept on all day and night, confusing the detainees. This can confuse them and allows them to loose track

Throughout the last 15 years of operation, Guantanamo Bay has faced endless criticism from both international countries and the US. The biggest issue is the legal “black hole” that exists at Guantanamo Bay and the concern over interrogation techniques and torture. We are able to torture prisoners because of how George W Bush described the war. “Bush thought it was a new kind of war and that this meant the Americans didn’t need adhere the rules of the Geneva Convention,” explains Professor Honigsberg from the University of San Francisco. The convention says prisoners of war must be treated humanely during a war. “But Bush didn’t call them ‘prisoners of war’ but ‘enemy combatants’. This was how a

Not only are the prisoners abused and neglected but they are also isolated for most of the time they serve. Along with the abuses already listed, they deny medical and family visits, food, and pay for prisoners (“Background Note: Cuba” 6). The people of the United States may find out about these horrid interrogations, they have much more to learn. Many people are shocked to find out the Pentagon has denied claims of any abuse in Guantanamo, although the people at the Pentagon admit to finding cases of the torture (Ardiente 2). To authorities this scheme acts as a minor problem, and it’s apparent they aren’t making it as much of a concern as they should. Techniques for interrogation were considered to be life threatening conditions that should not be tolerated by any presidential administration (Woodward 1). Detainees’ had no trial and no charges to bring to court so they went on many hunger strikes to protest (“Guantanamo Bay” 3). As a response to the prisoners’ hunger strikes, the American officials made the detainees undress completely, and they force fed them (Greenberg 5).

The issues that have had cause a lot of controversy since 2002.The closing of Guantanamo Bay has led to be the most reported prison that’s held prisoners against their own will. Due to against war on terror, but has yet most detainees havn’t been charged. We wonder in the closing of Guantanamo Bay who will it affect, what will happen, when will the closing of Guantanamo Bay takes place, and how will this play a role in the world today.

The Supreme Court ruled that if someone is detained by the American government, then they are entitled to basic constitutional rights, which does not allow the detainment of a person before bringing them before a court or a judge. Since this injustice is taking place in Guantanamo, innocent men are being placed there. Everyone being taken to GTMO is also protected from cruel and unusual punishment regardless of what they have been accused of. Therefore, the CIA’s use of various torture methods and brutal interrogations are not acceptable by law. Lakhdar Boumediene was one of many men who were taken away from their family and punished for a crime they did not commit. He will forever be affected by the seven years of mental and physical abuse that he endured at Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp. After 14 years, why is the U.S. still forcing faultless men to go to a place that makes them want to end their

Guantanamo Bay a prison for terrorist located in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba in the United States Navy base. It has been open for hundred and thirteen years as a naval base since 1903 after the Spanish-American war. While the detention camp came into being in 2002 as a result of the September 11th terrorist attacks in the United States. There are two sides to argument those that wants it closed and those that want it to remain open to house the terrorist or enemy combatants that belong to no nation that will claim them, but some nations may or may not support them. I am going to talk about some of the points brought up in the CQ researcher article I read written by Patrick Marshall, gathered from a multitude of sources.

Keeping Guantanamo Bay open there would be less psychological assaults in this world. A few people may believe that by shutting Guantanamo Bay jail there would be less dangers in this world. The Washington Post expresses says that "considered, the detainment office at Guantanamo Bay has assumed a part in the war against fear mongers by keeping them off the front line and taking into consideration cross examinations." However, there are accusations of abusive treatment at Guantanamo Bay Detention Center, this individuals are dangerous, and yet, still are permitted recreational services and facilities. Americans need to realize the situation and the danger that these individuals could put harm on the nation.

Guantanamo Bay, though started with good intentions, only highlights America’s negative side. Marine Major General Michael Lehnert, who played a significant role in the opening of Guantanamo, has drastically changed his opinion and said that it, “Validates every negative perception of the U.S.” (Sutton 1). One example of this occurred in 2006, when President Bush justified the use of “physical coercion” (torture) during interrogations (Fetini 1). Some of these torture methods include isolation, beatings, sleep deprivation, and general abuse. Other tactics such as disrespect for Islamic symbols or sexual provocation are used to encourage stress in detainees (Bloche 1). These immoral methods led to an international outcry. It was later remarked that the Cuban territory upon which Guantanamo is located is being used as a “concentration camp” of sorts (Fetini 1). Guantanamo and its unethical values are being recognized by nations around the world, displaying America in a bad light.

Guantanamo Bay is a US military prison that’s located within Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Caimanera, Cuba. Guantanamo Bay has been used to interrogate and house alleged terrorists. Guantanamo Bay has been called many names, like GITMO, G-Bay, and just plain Guantanamo. Guantanamo Bay as a prison, began in November 1991. This base has served has a safe-haven for hundreds of detainees, as well as Al Qaeda terrorists. Closing Guantanamo would be a disheartening decision for the US in the eyes of the Military Armed Forces.