preview

Hester Prynne Analysis

Decent Essays

The Temptress: A Face of Sin Nathaniel Hawthorne is a perfect example that great success comes with great amounts of criticism. Particularly, in his piece, The Scarlet Letter, where the main character has committed adultery. Critic D.H. Lawrence doesn’t agree with Hawthorne’s portrayal of Hester Prynne, and writes his essay “On The Scarlet Letter” in hopes to make the reader see why Prynne should not be pitied. Lawrence makes use of satirical tone, ironic allusions, and choppy syntax in order to provide evidence of Prynne’s lack of innocence. Lawrence demonstrates Prynne’s sin primarily through his satirical tone. Unlike Hawthorne’s sympathetic description of Prynne, Lawrence depicts her in the complete opposite light. In fact, Lawrence goes as far as to say that “[t]he greatest triumph a woman can have, especially an American woman, is the triumph of seducing a man; especially if he is pure” (Lawrence). His tone compromises Prynne’s character, which, in turn, deteriorates any ounce of integrity she has. By doing so, he hints towards the idea that her sleeping with Dimmesdale is not out of love, but rather because it is rewarding to have seduced such a seemingly pure man. Lawrence further undermines her by addressing her as “a demon…the great nemesis of woman” (Lawrence). By comparing her the adversary of all that is good, he not only portrays Prynne as selfish, but now evil. Additionally, he points out that she is the nemesis of females, which advises the reader to

Get Access