preview

Hills Like White Elephants Literary Analysis

Good Essays

"Hills Like White Elephants" by Ernest Hemingway is a short story that takes place at a

train station in Madrid, where a couple is having a discussion over the consideration of a vague

procedure that the man has proposed. The couple sits alone outside the station at the only shaded

table on a hot day drinking beers as a disagreement between the two unfolds. The man wants her

to have the procedure and subtly tries to convince her but as the story progresses, it becomes

clear she strongly disagrees with him. The exchange between the two ends when the girl, known

as Jig, refuses to listen to his persuasion any further, and asks him to stop talking, threatening to

scream when he doesn't comply. He finally listens and he takes their …show more content…

Hemingway uses the element of symbolism several times in the story. The story is centralized between two different options for two different people. The train station is in the country between two sets of rails running in opposite directions. Using a train station for the setting is interesting and symbolic because it's the perfect source for infinite destinations, but with only two directions. The station is also "between two contrasting landscapes that symbolize the couple's options" (Wyche). The two sitting outside in the shade is also symbolic. At one point in the story, Jig is making her argument while she is standing out in the sun and the man asks her to come back where he is, in the shade, sheltered from the hot sun, or symbolically, the pressures of being a parent. "Come on back in the shade.. ..You mustn't feel that way" (Hemingway, 231). He is almost hiding in the shade while she is expressing her choice on the situation, out in the open. "The man's response is predictable as it works against her connection with the natural …show more content…

"I don't want you to do it if you don't really want to" (Hemingway, 230) is repeated by the man in various ways all starting with "I don't want you to do it if." The repetition is used to clearly demonstrate to the reader of his gradual persuasion for her to really do it. "The repetitions, as well as the addition of this phrase, emphasize the man's persistence and power to change the conditions of agreement, as well as Jig's reluctance or inability to want or feel as he directs" (Link). The most eye-catching repetition is when the argument comes to an end as she asks him to stop talking in a desperate, demanding way. "Would you please please please please please please please stop talking?" (Hemingway, 231). "Its placement at the argument's end, and the fact that it is articulated as a request rather than a command, makes the sentence a central and prominent illustration of Jig's powerlessness, as well as her ardor" (Link). The man also repeats the words "perfect" and "simple" to Jig several times, even referring to the operation as "awfully simple" (Hemingway, 229). This is an interesting play on words since the procedure itself isn't simple to Jig, but actually awful. Hemingway's word choice is also strong using the word "reasonable." When the man leaves Jig after the argument is over, he has another beer inside the station with the other "reasonable" people. "They were all waiting

Get Access