preview

Historical Inaccuracies In Le Amistad

Decent Essays
Open Document

Since the beginning of its time, race has been an extremely controversial topic of American history. The case of the ship, Le Amistad, in 1839 perfectly exemplified the superiority that whites felt to blacks and the injustice of the system of slavery. Steven Spielberg’s Amistad details the journey taken by African slaves to gain freedom from their devastating situation. Although the film sheds light on slavery and evokes interest from the public to sympathize with the seemingly helpless African, there are also historical inaccuracies that may mislead the audience into forming thoughts about the subject that are not true. Despite these inaccuracies, the film is able to convey the main messages to be learned from the significant historical event: …show more content…

The leader of the slave rebellion, Cinque, allowed these Spanish men to live in the hopes that they would direct the rest of the slaves back home to Africa. Unfortunately, the two Spanish men deceived Cinque and the rest of his rebellers by directing them towards America where the Spanish had the advantage of the Americans’ prejudice against Africans. The slaves faced a legal battle because of their rebellion and were initially charged with piracy and murder. However, since they did not speak English they were not able to defend themselves. Roger Sherman Baldwin, a lawyer, came to the defense of the Africans and faced many obstacles in preparing the case because Americans looked at him scornfully for taking up the case, which eventually went to the United States Supreme Court. He had to face the issue of ownership and property, but the case did not only encompass this; he also had to overcome the fact that the Americans were adamant about the Africans remaining in their position as slaves. The case of the Amistad was not about the issue of property; it was about morality and the justice system, and as a result the issue expanded into something of national and international consequence that surrounded the system of slavery, a dividing factor in the country that ultimately led to the Civil War. Furthermore, the rights of the Africans becomes a topic of interest, and as Tappan says, “These are people, Mr. Baldwin, not livestock.” Evidently, those who side with the slaves see a major problem with considering the slaves as property since they are also human beings and deserve the treatment that humans receive. Regarding the issue of property, it was decided that the Africans had been shipped to Cuba unlawfully and thus this violated Spanish law. Consequently, the Africans were determined to be free. President

Get Access