Home Schooling vs. Public Schools: Which One is Better?
Thesis Statement: Many parents question what is best for their child’s education, home schooling or public school. Home schooling can sometimes provide a more direct and focused education than public schools, Public School is better in many ways including the child’s social development.
I. Home Schooling vs. Public Schooling
II. The Pros and Cons of Home Schooling
A. Home schooling can benefit both students and parents by providing individual attention.
B. Home schooling gives parents a sense of security.
C. Home schooling puts financial strain on parents.
D. Home schooling can cause slower social development.
III. The Pros and Cons of Public Schooling
…show more content…
Students that attend home school are less likely to be stressed out because of school work, and less likely to be a victim of peer pressure. Though there are a lot of benefits and advantages to being home schooled, there are also many disadvantages. Home schooling takes a lot of time to plan, and it can be hard on the parents to balance schooling with other home duties. Though home schooling allows parents to pick the time that the schooling will take place, it is a full-time job for one parent. One major disadvantage of home schooling is that it requires the parents to pay for everything with their own finances, this can cause financial pressure on the family. Only one parent would be able to have a full time job and they will have to pay for books and other reading material with their own money. Even if they choose to have a teacher come into their home to do the schooling, it would still require them to pay him/her for their services. Another major disadvantage that home schooling has on children is that it can cause slower social development for the children. Many children that are home schooled have a hard time working with teams and being in a large group of people because they are used to being the only, or one of just a few students in a class. Children that are home schooled may have a hard time dealing with peer pressure because they will try harder
In the article “Why I Homeschool: The Answers Change Almost as Fast as My Kids Do. But My Commitment to At-Home Learning Remains Strong.” Amy Thornton-Kelly initially home schooled her three children in order to spend more time with them. This was her only reason, or so she thought. Amy Thornton–Kelly explains the many reasons why homeschooling is the best decision she has made. First, she explains that once her husband and her considered homeschooling “the floodgates opened” to the many benefits of homeschooling. It alleviates stress, allows her kids to learn in a healthier environment and allows her to teach her kids in a more profound way. Second, Thornton-Kelly states that homeschooling allows her kids to better master subjects,
Not attending school deprives students of the opportunity to develop these skills. Not going to school drastically limits their social interaction. They do not learn the social cues that others acquire as they walk the hallways in conventional schools or as they sit in classrooms with other students and instructors. One of the big focuses in schools right now has to do with cooperative learning because later in life the majority of people, at some point, will have to work with others. This skill can be hard to master for many people because of the differences in each individual. Students in schools are often forced to work with those they may normally have little interaction with on a daily basis. This is a great lesson in tolerance and teamwork. With limited interaction, homeschooled students have to learn this lesson later in life or never at
Who's to say kids are really that different being homeschooled? “Homeschooled students tend to have higher college GPAs than other students” (Source D). Learning on your own free time will make you more interested in the subject at hand and be able to comprehend it easily. “Several studies found no significant difference or social skills of home schooled and non-homeschooled students” (Source E). Being homeschooled you have a more adventurous imagination. You run on your own time being able to make room for things you can't when being on a tight public school schedule like vacations or professional sports/ careers.
For years flocks of children have gotten up at the crack of dawn and gone to the brick building to sit at their desks for eight hours straight, but now a very effective style of school called homeschooling has emerged. Most of todays parents have gone to a public school because homeschooling was not very well known back when they were school aged. Since then, homeschooling has become much more popular and has been proven to be effective. Parents should consider homeschooling their kids as an alternative to sending them to a public school.
Thesis: Homeschooling environment is an effective approach in education due to evidence of higher achievement on placement tests, success through college, engaged socially with activities outside homes, and students becoming active members of society.
However, what are the drawbacks? For one thing, there is a clear lack of interaction with others, and therefore socialization. My example of a homeschooled person from earlier, Henley is a great example of this. Throughout the show, she had difficulty connecting and talking with the other contestants, being far happier when she was able to speak with her mother. The socialization the family provides and the kind the school provides have some overlaps, but there are clear differences. Learning how to interact with others outside of your family is the basis of school, interacting with both students and teachers, peers and authority figures
Acording to the reading the main disadvantages are the lacks of: knowledge, social interaction and curriculum. Children learn less in homeschool because there is less requierements to procede to a further level. Also they have a more limited group of people to interact with. And the curriculum that parents can offer is too narrow.
Home schooling is a very controversial subject among many people. Some parents say that they would love to home school their children if they had the time, while other parents say that they would never home school because home schooled children lack socialization skills. There are many statistics that support that homeschooled children do just as well with their education and socialization as public schooled children do. Home schooling your children definitely requires a great deal of time and patience, but if you are willing to try it out it could be very beneficial to your child’s education and the relationship you have with your child. When public and home schooling are compared there are many benefits to each, but home schooling is more flexible with your time and your child can get a personalized education just for their needs.
B. Preview – Traditional homeschooling can be problematic to a student’s life skills and overall development. The social learning aspect of school, which is lacking in homeschool, directly transfers into college and the workplace. Most teenagers and kids need to be supervised at every moment or else they will not do their work and, while at home, it is hard to find the motivation to do schoolwork.
Public schooling establishes a diverse atmosphere and stimulation for students to succeed. Student’s need more stimulation than any one parent can provide for their child. “Home schooling does not encourage and facilitate children to make peer relationships. In both public and private schools, children have the benefit of being grouped together in classes and activities, and in turn, they have an opportunity to get to know one another. Home school lacks this type of environment and can retard a child’s social growth” (Home Schooling – The Benefits of Learning at
According to http://a2zhomeschooling.com/ thirty four percent of teenagers in the United States are home schooled. Some people believe that homeschooling is better for their children, in that they have more family time, better protected from bad examples, etc. As a retort parents have the ability to argue that being homeschooled is unfair to the children. Seeing that they are not exposed to real life situations that they could experience in public school, they will not be able to deal with difficult situations. Homeschooling is not the route to take if a child is expected to perform in real life situations.
In the other hand parents who choose to home school their kids are faced with a great deal of advantages. Home schooling a child means that a parent has to give 100 percent dedication into teaching there child. One great asset to home schooling is that children are often way ahead in their grade work as compared with their peers in public school. They learn to read much earlier and advance through their subjects much faster and in a more thorough manner, due to more individualized attention and subject-specific attention. By being taught at home, the student has immediate access to the "teacher", and can ask questions at just about any time without having to worry about other students and their learning habits. Parents don’t have to worry about the safety of their child when it comes to home schooling. The child is in the home and always being watched if something where to happen it would be the parents’ responsibility and the parent would know what to do
Homeschooling, not very well known, presents a new and affordable way to educate children. “Home school is a term used to refer to the education of children by their parents or guardians in a setting other than a public or private school” (Anderman & Anderman, p. 467). It has never been a new thing; it just has not been as popular as it used to be (Lines, p. 76). With this topic meaning so much to groups for and against the right for homeschooling and what should be legalized or not, the debate still rages on from local to even national government entities. Both sides of the argument have valid points, but ultimately it is the choice of the parents. There are many types of ways to educate children and that decision is difficult for both
Homeschooling a child can drastically affect their lives in the future, and put them in a clouded state of mind for seeing what the world is. Schooling your child from home will hold them back from learning a wide variety of basic skills that can be easily provided in public or private school systems. Although some see homeschooling as a good way to shelter their children from the world they view as harsh, it is not giving them any chance to gain common social skills. Social skills cannot be taught to a child, they are something the child must learn from interaction with his or her peers. Furthermore, homeschool teachers are not required the level of training and experience that a teacher at a public school are required (Hudak). Diversity is something widely portrayed in school systems; however, homeschooling doesn't allow students to bear witness to the diverse nature found in school systems.
Homeschool is a way for some kids to stay focused on their subjects and not have any distractions. Some kids have trouble with classroom settings, so the best option is for them to get away from others and focus on what is in front of them. Some kids have been bullied to the point where there is no other option but to be homeschooled. The effects of being homeschooled can be both good and bad and it can take a toll on what the child is feeling and also how they react to people and situations they encounter.A child that is being homeschooled can only so many social skills from their parents and the internet to the point that it will not be able to handle other people in the real world but that is false because most kids that I have met are actually very sociable. One effect being homeschooled can have is that the child has to learn everything from their parents or their tutor. This effect is a good one because a child that is learning from the same teacher will not be afraid to ask questions and voice their concerns about anything. Another effect of being homeschooled is that the child is focusing so much on the work they are assigned that can learn at their own speed and they do not have to slow down or speed up their learning from the others around them. A final effect of being homeschooled is that a child might always be stuck in their house and not get enough exercise.