Having finished the novel, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, I felt contented knowing Francie was able to make it to college, due to her ambitious and committed nature, like I had predicted in my previous journal entry. As a result of this, the Nolans are able to escape the vicious cycle of poverty. In my opinion, the ending of the novel was very contrasting to the ending of Things Fall Apart, as Okonkwo, who at the beginning of the book was very ambitious, failed to live up to his character’s trait(s) and resorted to committing a “womanly” action. Furthermore, Francie, after her father’s death, remembers the good times she spent with him, yet she vows to herself to never drink and steers herself in a completely different direction to that of her fathers. However, during the first of the novel, Francie wanted to be similar to her even though, during the first half of the novel, she wanted to be like her father. This reminded me of Okonkwo, who refused to be characterized by his father’s deeds, yet at the end of the novel he commits a “womanly” action and is deemed weak, much like his father. This shows the diverging natures of Francie and Okonkwo, who started off as similar characters (aspiring and committed), yet, one of them is able to …show more content…
In which one novel considered men to be stronger than woman, while the other novel illustrated a totally opposite view. However, after finishing the second half of my novel, I’ve realized that despite the contrasting views on whom is the strongest amongst the two genders, both novels were quite similar regarding the rights of women. Both books give more importance to men when it comes to gaining success, even though they may be less deserving and incompetent for this opportunity. Due to this reason, the women, who are more capable and have a greater potential for gaining success, are abstained from being given this
Medical care is critical in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. Francie Nolan’s mother, Katie, and her Aunt Sissy experience two different pregnancies with the medical care provided for them. They both lack proper healthy guidelines during the time of pregnancy. Sissy encounters hardships whereas Katie takes them for granted. Betty Smith assimilates twentieth century medical care in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn and its portrayal of pregnancy, delivery and infant mortality impact the characters’ lives.
Reading literature, at first, might seem like simple stories. However, in works like William Faulkner's “A Rose for Emily,” Katherine Mansfield's “Miss Brill,” and Kate Chopin's “The Storm,” the female protagonists are examples of how society has oppressive expectations of women simply because of their gender.
In fact, she even references A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, saying "I thought Francie Nolan and I were practically identical, except that she had lived 50 years earlier in Brooklyn and her mother always kept the house clean." (168) What makes Walls' story unique is the deep look we get into her thoughts. The reader watches as young, naive, innocent Walls talks about her life of poverty in a startlingly positive way. "The next time they visited, Brian's head was wrapped in a dirty white bandage with dried bloodstains. Mom said he had fallen off the back of the couch and cracked his head open on the floor, but she and dad had decided not to bring him to the hospital." (13) Throughout the story it is seen how with age, she becomes more aware of how badly she is actually living. Her optimism goes sour as she loses faith in her father. By seeing into her thoughts, the readers feel sympathy for Walls and keep reading in hope that she will fulfill her
Mary Frances Nolan, more commonly known as Francie, is the main character in “A Tree Grows in Brooklyn” by Betty Smith. Throughout the book Francie grows and matures as done any person. The book jumps around and allows you to see Francie at different ages as if the book were in chronological order. In the beginning of the book, Francie is young and observant. As she grows up Francie continuous to be curious but also takes an interest in writing and discovers that she has a talent for it. Francie goes through many rough patches and these experiences teacher to be stronger and more confident.
The female is represented in the primary source as being inferior to men. They’re also known to have less energy, patience, and less physical courage than man. According to Gamble, “women have powers of intuition, finer and more rapid perceptions, and a greater degree of endurance”. Both men and women have mental qualities and equal perfection. Furthermore, she states “women can successfully compete with men in all walks of life”; this is proven because women are now working in occupations that have been regarded as belonging exclusively to men. Female’s choice in sexual selection is also superior. According to Gamble, this is evidence of a higher mental capacity and intelligence in females.
Francie Nolan is an 11-year-old girl with a vivid imagination and dreams of someday becoming an author. However, she is limited by her surroundings, for she lives in one of the poorest neighborhoods of Brooklyn. Her family has barely enough money to buy food and other necessities of life. Her mother is Katie Nolan, a strong, steely woman who meets every challenge that comes her way head-first, and her father is Johnny Nolan, an idealistic father whom Francie loves very much, but is an alcoholic. Francie is sure that Katie loves her brother, Neeley, more than herself, and she attaches herself to her father.
“Oh, magic hour, when a child first knows she can read printed words.”~ A Tree Grows In Brooklyn.
Both novels characterize men as the hard workers, but it is clear the women also have many difficult tasks expected of them.
The role of women in works of literature as well as in life has changed significantly. Previously, women were seen as needy and dependent on the men in their lives. Women were only important for raising children and doing work around the house, while men were off
Betty Smith’s classic tale A Tree Grows in Brooklyn utilizes an assortment of intriguing, relatable characters to tell the emotional tale of a young girl, born into the depths of poverty, and to detail the traumatic life events that occur that shape her into her future self. Set in impoverished Williamsburg, Brooklyn, 1912, this story centers around the Nolan family: hardworking, tough mother Katie, impractical and romantic father Johnny, momma’s boy Cornelius “Neeley”, and the protagonist, eleven-year old Mary Frances “Francie”, a sharp-witted, loyal daydreamer through whom the reader sees life occur throughout the book. Francie’s ability to daydream about a greater life for her and her family help her to escape
The role of women in Western literature is constantly changing. In the span of less than a hundred years, it has evolved and changed into a completely different set of ideals and expectations for a female lead. In the repressed Victorian era of Bram Stoker’s Dracula, women are kept in the roles of the idealized proper woman or portrayed as sex-crazed temptresses. In Italo Calvino’s If on a Winter’s Night a Traveler, women are given a more dynamic role—one that drives the narrative, as opposed to reacting to it.
To quote author Chimamanda Adichie, “Imagine how much happier we would be, how much freer to be our true individual selves, if we didn 't have the weight of gender expectations.” However, the influence of gender is pervasive from jobs to the military, even extending to education. Men are generally characterized as strong and independent. Women, on the other hand, are supposed to be more feeble and domestic by societal standards. These distinctions have always been the case in the United States, from the moment people first crossed the Bering Strait into North America. It should come as no surprise, then, that the societal expectations placed on gender affect literary works. Gender often conflicts with the hopes and dreams of the characters and makes it harder for them to achieve success. The flawed societal gender constructions found in American literature are adversarial to characters in their search for fulfillment. The concept of gender roles obstructing success is ubiquitous in the many works, including The Great Gatsby, The Mystery of Heroism, The Scarlet Letter, A Raisin In The Sun, and The Death of A Salesman.
American Literature has always been about men and for men. In this essay, we are going to analyze the women’s role in the book, as inferior and weaker gender.
Carol Tavris’s The Mismeasure of Women offers the reader insight into the inequality and problems women face in society. I approached this book with the assumption that it would glorify women and belittle men. I figured that the author would blame all the problems women face on men. After completing the book I had a very different opinion. The author looked to society for the actual source of women’s inequality and never placed the blame on any one group of people. The book explains that although there are differences in the behavior of men and women in certain situations both types of behavior are equal and for the most part influenced by society. It is for that reason I recommend The Mismeasure of Women for both
This topic is extremely important as it revolves around the subject of feminism and sexualism, two topics that need to be taken more into consideration when reading a novel. The portrayal of female characters in novels that are read around the world are very impactful towards the female portion of the world as it places them in a spectrum of what they should act and look like to meet the standards of society. Focusing specifically on the development of the female characters and how they are just as powerful as men is an interesting idea to navigate around, focusing on the feminist portion of the novel. In current academic studies there has been substantial amount of works that are about women empowerment, with authors that believe the exact same, such as Purple Hibiscus and The Help.