preview

How Does Agatha Christie Use Vigilante Justice

Decent Essays
Open Document

Vigilante justice has fascinated readers for years. The idea of committing crimes for what the character believes to be a worthy cause brings up arguments about whether the character is justified in doing so. Stephen R. Lawhead’s Hood, and Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None, present the reader with the same idea of characters using vigilante justice to sort out cases that can not be touched by the law. In And Then There Were None, Lawrence Wargrave acts as a judge and sets up an elaborate trap to punish people who committed crimes that the law would not be able to deal with. He lures them on to Soldier Island under the pretense that they are going there to do certain jobs for the “owner” of the property U.N. Owen, and then kills them …show more content…

At the beginning of Hood Bran does not care about his people and is only focused on not becoming a king like his father. Because of this, Bran runs away from his kingdom, Elfael, to escape his responsibility. However, after becoming injured Bran realizes that he needs to go save his kingdom. Bran sees that his people are suffering and he realizes that he’s not just saving his kingdom but also his people’s home. Soon after Bran heals he goes to Cel Craidd where he “... spent most of the day getting to know the people of Cel Craidd, the hidden heart of the greenwood. A few folk of Elfael, but many were from other cantrefs - chiefly Morgannwg and Gwent, which had also fallen under Norman sway. All, for one reason or another, had been forced to abandon their homes and seek refuge of the wood. He talked to them and listened to their stories of loss and woe, and his heart went out to them” (Lawhead 292). Since Bran cares so much about his people, he has a legitimate reason to use vigilante justice to take back the money from the people who wronged him to save Elfael. Not only does Bran want to save Elfael for his people, but also for his mother. Bran’s mother passed away when he was young, and his father was a harsh king that took away most of the joy that his mother had brought to the kingdom. When Bran is thinking about why he want’s to save Elfael …show more content…

Ever since Lawrence Wargrave was a child he has had a want to kill. However, his wish to kill was combatted by the idea that the innocent must not suffer. In his old age, Wargrave becomes restless, and his job as a judge does not satisfy his desire for murder and justice. In order to punish people whose crimes the law is not able to deal, with he says, “I must-I must-I must-commit a murder! And what is more, it must be no ordinary murder! It must be a fantastical crime-something stupendous-out of the common! In that one respect, I have still, I think, an adolescent’s imagination. I wanted something theatrical, impossible!” (Christie 287). When Lawrence Wargrave kills the ten people on Soldier Island, he does so by stepping outside of the law and taking matters into his own hands, but as one can see in the quote above, he only does so in order to satisfy a selfish desire that he wishes to fulfilled before he dies. Not only does Lawrence Wargrave kill ten people, but he leaves the public not knowing what happened on soldier island and not knowing why ten people who are supposedly innocent are found dead. A quote from the epilogue in And Then There Were None reads, “When the sea goes down, there will come from the mainland boats and men. And they will find ten dead bodies and an unsolved problem

Get Access