In the story "The Adventure of the Speckled Band" Sherlock Holmes believed that "doctor's make the greatest criminals." Holmes said "When a doctor does go wrong he is the first of criminals, He has nerve and he has knowledge." This is true because doctors are trained to know how the human body works. They know what can kill a person and what can keep them alive. Knowingly, one with this type of knowledge can be very dangerous. Doctors know everything when it comes to medications and what is considered poison to the body. Back then, a doctor could possibly have access to poisons that was undetectable in the human body. Certain poisons could not be found in the blood of a corpse even if that was the source of death. Doctors have a knowledge of the human body more superior then the average person, if a doctor wanted to kill someone they know exactly where to attack and or how much lethal injection it would take to kill that person. Another reason is that it is much unexpected for a person whose job is to save people’s lives to go and do such a devious act, it’s like hiding in plain sight. …show more content…
Most of them would think of a crime and go straight to action without thinking about every small detail that could help them succeed. However, when Sherlock Holmes investigated a crime committed by a Doctor there were few, if not any clues at all. There is nothing worse than an educated criminal, but Holmes managed to find the smallest of details and gather valuable information. Doctors get their name from earning the highest level of education there is, with years of study, learning to be patient and gaining intelligence. Having this advantage during Holmes time was a key to being a successful
Since the 70s medical dramas have continuously been huge on TV. really a number of the foremost winning series of all time area unit regarding medical doctors. Quincy, General Hospital, E.R., M.A.S.H., Scrubs, Grey's Anatomy, House, Dougie Houser, MD, Chicago Hope, and therefore the list goes on. The doctors area unit humourous, beautiful, sensible and typically manage to supply a life saving conclusion at intervals 30-60 minutes. You and that i we have a tendency tore raised learning that we may trust the doctor, particularly if he or she had a white coat, medical instrument, surgical knife and a prescription pad.
Being a doctor requires a lot of hard work and commitment to help others and look for the patient’s well being, but has it always been this way? In “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks” by Rebecca Skloot, she claims in paragraph 4 on page 130 that doctors used to withhold information from patients just so they won’t deny the test being made, and this way obtain their wanted benefit. The author’s claim is supported by the events of the patients from jail, Henrietta’s autopsy, and Henrietta’s cells overall.
He might could have said that because doctors would know of all sorts of medications and poisons that could be used to kill someone discretely without arousing suspicion. If they were using a knife, they would know all the vital areas of the human body that would cause death quickly and quietly. It was suspected that Jack the Ripper had medical training because of the precision with which some of the organs were removed from his victims. Today though, doctors would have a much harder time because of forensics being able to detect poisons. So though Holmes would be right back in the old days, I'd say a forensic scientist or a police detective would have the advantage in modern times over a doctor. They could cover their trail better. Also Holmes
The Greeks made many influences to their medical practices as well as ours today. Hippocrates was one of the many doctors at the time and he made many new discoveries in medicines which really helped people live longer and made his procedures a lot easier. He was a very trustworthy doctor. He made an oath stating that he wouldn't do anything to put his patients in harm by giving them bad medicines. Instead, he swore to do everything possible to cures patients and help make them feel better. This was known as the Hippocrates Oath (Doc 4). Even to this day, doctors must swear to not do anything that can cause harm to their patients. It's part of their training while in medical school. The only time a doctor can "harm" his or her patients is when the patient signs a
They could treat patients with herbs and surgical procedures and help patients eliminate, or at least alleviate, their pain and live more productive lives in general. In addition to physical relief of pain, medical specialists could also provide relief their patients’ anxiety through prognostication, which was an important part of medical tradition that relied on various methods, including astrology, astronomy, and hepatoscopy. Mini Citation (The History of Medicine: Early Civilizations— Prehistoric Times to 500 CE, pg 24) 3. Physical Proof The earliest know medical records found were in Mesopotamia, dating to 7th century BCE.
Sherlock Holmes came to the conclusion that “doctors make the best criminals”. Holmes statement is conclusive. As a detective, Sherlock Holmes gathers many clues to make a nearly perfect and accurate determination. Based on his findings, it is only possible that he is correct. There are instances in the story that help me agree with Holmes. Physicians are trustworthy, intelligent and need to be part of an upper social status.
Sherlock holmes more or likely said that doctor make the greatest criminals because doctors know all about medicine. They know how the body works. If the doctor wants to kill you he can make it look like it was either suicide or an accident. A doctor can easily put poison inside of the medicine or he can “accidentally” give you the wrong type of medicine. A doctor could have a knife, but a doctor known
Expanding upon this Doctors must undergo at least five years of schooling according to U.S. patents that require a 4 year minimal before a PHd is awarded and that's not including primary school.(according to google/search) When someone is intelligent they tend not to make mistakes or at least not make the same mistake twice when committing a crime, because they often meticulous hours planning and going over even the most minuscule of details. Intelligent criminals are also very perceptive and are aware of the aspects of the crime they commit. Another perk of intelligence is the adaptability to the scenarios which may occur during the committing of the crime, like the Doctor who planned out killing one sister after the other to take their family fortune. These are reasons that doctors make some of the greatest
Another key reason why doctors were the best criminals back then is due to their extensive knowledge on human anatomy. In order to be a doctor, one has to go through years of training and medical school. The vast amount of knowledge doctors have on human anatomy gives them an extraordinary advantage over the common man. They know which parts of the body will kill someone to easiest, and how to target those areas. This is another vital point on why doctors are the best
They know what to do and how to react to get the case to look a certain way. Doctors can also decide weither or not to partake in a case. In a murder, suicide, or any type of case. A doctor could be called to the scene and decide not to help or to have a certain medication handy to kill
Throughout it, we are introduced to police, forensic officers, morticians and the world's greatest detective Sherlock Holmes. The fact
Sherlock Holmes’s intelligence is demonstrated in both “The Red-Headed League” and “A Scandal in Bohemia”. During “A Scandal in Bohemia” he first demonstrates his intuitive thinking by figuring out that Count Kramm, the man introducing him on the case, is actually the King of Bohemia himself. This shows that he is able to make a quick determination about people’s lives just by having a brief conversation with them. This allows Holmes to solve mysteries that others cannot by simply looking at a suspect or location associated with the scenario. He uses this ability later in the story to find where the incriminating photo of the king with Adler is. He does this by creating a situation for himself where he will be able to get into Adler’s home. He then fakes a fire to see where Adler goes first so he can see where she keeps her most valuable possession, the photo. Holmes states “When a woman thinks that her house is on fire, her instinct is at once to rush to the thing which she values the most… Now it was clear to me that our lady of to-day had nothing in the house more precious to her then what we are questing for” (Doyle 19). This line of thinking shows that Holmes knows how to get people to inadvertently give him the information that he needs by putting them in the right situation and observing what they do. This skill
In the words of Sherlock Holmes, "doctors make the greatest criminals". I believe that this is true when it comes to the people who have degrees in medicine because of their study of the human body. With specialized skill in areas such as neurology, immunology, and anatomy doctors are able to understand what makes the body work and also, what can destroy it. Doctors have the doctor/patient confidentiality that deems them trustworthy with personal information. They also have access to all kinds of medicines and poisons that could potentially be used to kill someone. Doctors make the best criminals because they have the knowledge and power to commit a crime and not get caught.
Imagine you are injured or sick and have sought a doctor’s help. Although you trusted your doctor, something, something seemingly very in control of the doctor, went wrong. You are angry and confused, but also think of the commonality of medical malpractice. So, why do doctors, who are supposed to help, harm? Though many flaws influence it, malpractice can be, and often is unintentional. Most doctors aren’t trained to harm their patients. Inexperience and lack of medical discovery led to unintentional suffering of the patient. Personal flaws, like lack of willingness to abandon previous medical methods and shortcomings in communication also harm patients. Further reasons why doctors harm are socio-medical understandings that breed hate, prejudices stemming from a society’s belief about certain people, such as the medical practice under the Nazi regime. Additionally, displayed in the case of Ignác Semmelweis, judgement of one to oneself can be detrimental to any progress one’s ideas could make. We will examine these concepts through Jerome Groopman’s “Flesh-and-Blood Decision Making”, Sherwin Nuland’s The Doctors’ Plague and Barbara Bachrach’s “In the Name of Public Health”. Those who practice medicine are, unfortunately, unfree from the imperfections that plague all of humanity. Through these intimate and varied faults, doctors do harm.
It is likely to be believed that all medical professionals are filled with traits of fairness, honesty, empathy, trust, integrity, generosity, respect, practice good behavior, and have the ability to admit their wrongs. Unfortunately, due to the many law suits surrounding medical professional this must say something about what many believe and the standard that we hold medical professional too.