The Starving of the Shrew When training a falcon, the bird is often put on a diet so it will pay attention to a lure. Though this process may be uncomfortable for the falcon, a regular diet is restored when training is completed and a mutual relationship is formed between bird and falconer. Petruchio in Shakespeare’s comedy The Taming of the Shrew uses a similar method in the taming of Kate. Petruchio deprives her of food until she shows signs of being tamed and ready for life together. Upon finishing this jarring process, she is ready to live happily with Petruchio. Food signifies comfort and happiness and is used to contrast Kate’s life as a shrew and her life as a devoted wife. It shows that life is happier for those who make themselves likable to the people around them. …show more content…
After denying Kate dinner back at his place, Petruchio explains, “She eat no meat today, nor none shall eat.”1 Petruchio plans to keep Kate from eating substantial food until she loses her shrewish ways. He will not allow her to eat good food until she becomes the wife he would like. The taming process is very uncomfortable for Kate, nearly starving her to death. However, she still holds on to her shrewish ways, beating servants and disagreeing with whatever Petruchio says. Petruchio forbids her from eating meat as long as her shrewish behavior continues. He eventually offers Kate meat, but has Hortensio eat it all saying, “The poorest service is repaid with thanks and so shall mine before you touch the meat” (4.3.45-46). Even though Kate eventually thanked him, Petruchio didn’t feel that the thanks was swift enough or truly felt. Petruchio uses starvation to get Kate to fall under his control. Kate’s lack of food makes her uncomfortable and miserable in her new life with Petruchio. This torturous lifestyle continues until she gives up her shrewish ways and obeys
The relationship between Kate and Petruchio is completely different from the love of Bianca and Lucentio. "Kate is a neglected, hurt, and humiliated daughter who disguises her grief from herself as well as others with a noisy shrewish temper" (Craig 342). She has a fiery disposition and a reputation for reacting violently to people. The challenge of capturing her is Petruchio's real attraction to her. He can be seen as a rough, unfeeling, greedy, "swash-buckler" who cares nothing for Kate's feelings (so long as she has money). "
Although, she knows her family is not exactly financially stable, she still helps a stranger out. In this sense, a small gesture like to offer a hungry boy a sandwich can change their life and can help them learn from their mistakes in a less harsh but positive experience. Secondly, the knife the boy threats Kate with is a symbol of violence, but also represents the difference between right and wrong. Earlier in the story, the boy wants to use the knife as a way of obtaining some money. Kate figures that his actions were not right and wants to help him genuinely and not just for her safety because she did not believe he had a knife.
(Montgomery, 31). Anne’s rejection of food to show power is a method that is repeated throughout the book, once again when she refuses to apologize to Rachel Lynde, “… Anne still remained obdurate… Marilla carried a well-filled tray… and brought it down later on not noticeably depleted” (Montgomery, 83). Marilla’s providing of food and Anne’s rejection of it describes the power relationship between the adult and the child (a prevalent concept in children’s literature), in which the adult controlling the food maintains the upper hand, and the child can only cross over into adulthood once they are capable of fully controlling their
Petruchio may have been mean to her in order to tame her but by the end; he shows how he truly loves her. “Come, my sweet Kate/Better once than never, for never too late” (Shakespeare Vi 149-150). Kat’s sonnet about her feelings towards Patrick show that she has accepted that she can be in love. This is her version of being “tamed” because she can rely on someone other than herself. Patrick uses the money he made dating her to buy her a guitar and beg for her forgiveness. He has fallen for her though that was no his original intention. “I thought you could use it. You know, when you start your band. Besides, I had some extra cash, you know. Some asshole paid me to take out a really great girl but I screwed up. I fell for her” (10 Things I Hate About You). Besides the story, the filmmakers have used several exact lines from the play in the movie. Cameron echoes Lucentio’s line, “I burn, I pine, I perish”(Shakespeare Ii 155) when he sees Bianca for the first time. Kat, like Kate, tells her sister “You don't always have to be who they want you to be” (10 Things I Hate About You). The filmmakers kept Shakespeare’s story of love and deceit intact in the modernization.
As mentioned above, Katherine was the elderly daughter of a wealthy merchant, who was known throughout the city of Padua for her scolding tongue and her fiery tempered attitude. Most men had excluded her when suggestions arrived in terms of marriage. Due to this situation, Katherine had set her mind to not getting married at all. “Good, Morning Kate, said Petruchio, as the haughty lady swept in. ‘my name is Katherine’, she pouted. ‘No is isn’t, you are called plain Kate and Bonny Kate and sometimes Kate the wild cat . . . . But I think you are the prettiest Kate in Christendom- gentle, beautiful, modest and kind. Yes I’ve heard all about you, and I’ve come to ask you to be my wife’. She slapped his face” (page 3) .This quote gives details in how arrogant Kate is towards Petruchio. It is known to be very disrespectful manners to answer back to an opposite gender, but slapping someone who has come to ask for your hand is revolting. But poor Katherine doesn’t remain in this high position throughout the novel. As soon as she and Petruchio are wedded she experiences many changes within her and around her.” All her life she had had everything she wanted. Now,
Kate and Arthur were encouraged to send her to a foundation, yet they couldn't stand to send Helen to such a constrained life. A much greater issue for Helen and the whole family, be that as it may, was the matter of Helen's social graces. Helen ate with her fingers and periodically took anything she needed off other individuals' plates. Anne Sullivan
how she's treated worse than those who begged for food at her father's door. Kate is treated like a
In addition, Kate’s final monologue, also in Act 5, scene 2, tells the audience a lot; about the play itself, as well as the society in Shakespeare’s era. On face value, Kate’s final monologue seems to be a long lecture about serving your husband, no questions asked. “Then vail your stomachs, for it is no boot, / And place your hands below your husband’s foot” (v, ii, lines 92-3, page 221). However, Shakespeare gave Kate the last word in the play, a sign of her consistent power and control. As well, her monologue can be perceived as quite ironic. Kate is aware of the beliefs about how women in the household should act and, as clearly portrayed throughout the entire play, the role Petruchio has been trying to get her to fill. By playing along fullheartedly with society’s expectations, in front of the large audience of guests, Kate becomes “truly tamed” - or just incredibly
in your dumps?"Call you me daughter? Now, I promise you , You have showed a tender fatherly regard To wish me wed to one half lunatic ,A mad-cup ruffian and a swearing Jack, That thinks with oaths to face the matter out". In her despite of love she decides to meet and hang with Petruchio a little more. "I’ll see thee hanged on Sunday first." its midpoint in the story and Kate begins her transformation, moving from ego misery to a decidedly more mature happiness in the through marriage. Petruchio’s forcible treatment on Katherine in every way designed to show her that she has no real choice but to adapt to her social role as a wife. Her adaptation must be attractive to Katherine on some level, since she dislikes the role of a wife, playing it at least means she can command respect and consideration from others rather than suffer what she receives as a shrew. When Petruchio refuses to let Kate choose her own clothing and tells her to pipe down about it, Kate objects to his attempts to shut her down. Kate suggests the act of speech can alleviate one's pain and suffering. She also says that her heart "will break" if she is silenced and unable to express her frustration about her lack of power and control over even her own wardrobe. As she get tried of playing with Petruchio she decide to go along on what Petruchio wanted
Kate shows change in a way where she is innocent but obedient, before Petruchio enter the wedding party for Bianca, and right as they are about to enter Petruchio asks for a kiss. Kate denies him this because she has become modest and innocent which is a major change from the start, but shows obedience when she gives in and kisses him,”Nay, I will give thee a kiss. (kisses him) Now pray thee, love, stay,”(V.i.228).
In essence, all Petruchio did was teach Kate not to be so brash and rebellious. He showed her how awful her actions looked, and on her own, she made the decision to change her demeanor. She could have remained bitter and feisty, but it would have been in vain, and I believe that she realized that her actions had been no worse than the vanity and shallowness she witnessed in the people of Padua.
Katherine continues to tell them that any women who does not obey and follow their husbands then they are 'foul contending rebels'. Katherine’s speech is full of love and respect for Petruchio. Right from the moment she met Petruchio, it is unmistakable that she was intrigued by him, it could even have been love at first sight. They are very similar characters and they express their emotions by arguing and insulting each other but deep down they are in love. There are two explanations for Katherine’s final speech. One explanation is that Kate could be filled with so much love and affection for Petruchio that she will withstand his harsh treatments and cruel tests just to be with him. Another explanation is that Kate has admitted defeat by Petruchio and that she respects him and understands that he is now master. Kate always wanted to be married and at last she has, she is no longer the controller but has a strong husband to look after her and keep her in a her place. Finally the shrew has been tamed and at last she is married, and so it is a happy ending for
Ironically, they prove to be perfect for one another. Though Katharina seems heartless and unemotional, her one true fear is losing Petruchio. " It is surely worth remarking that Kate has only one true moment of agony, when Petruchio's deliberately tardy arrival for their wedding makes her feel jilted" (Bloom 30-31). Their mutual roughness seems to be their way of flirtation. Though Katharina feels that Petruchio is "a mad rudesby full of spleen," she realizes that she is truly in love and is lucky to have any husband at all, and will not, as the villagers say, "lead apes to hell" (Draper 95). The ironic counterpoint of their relationship is that while Katharina is easily tamed, Bianca, who needs no taming, is difficult for Lucentio to tolerate.
In contrast to this, Kate is very angry and frustrated by the Petruchio, and immediately becomes "shrewish," resorting to insults, 'A joint stool,' and violence. This gives the effect of Kate being much less in control of what is going on, and perhaps reflects the direction their relationship is going to take, that Petruchio will be the one in charge, and Kate will not have any control. This could however also demonstrate Kate's intelligence and wit, that she is able to keep up and match Petruchio's wordplay. However Kate feels the need to resort to violence, again demonstrating Petruchio's intelligent wordplay and calm attitude, as he does not react violently towards Kate, but simply
As the play continues, we learn even more about Kate. For example, when Kate and Petruchio go back to Baptista’s, Kate begins to see how Petruchio operates. She learns that if she does what Petruchio says, even if she knows it is not true, she will get something she wants out of it, like going back to her father’s house. Petruchio test Kate when they meet the real Vincentio on the road and he asks Kate if she has ever seen a finer young women. Knowing what he is up to, Kate shows her amazing wit and decides to play his game. She has figured out that Petruchio has a method to his madness and if she plays her cards right, their relationship can be a partnership with a series of actions and rewards.