preview

How Is Antonio An Inhumane Persuasive Letter

Decent Essays
Open Document

I apologise for interrupting, wise Duke, and honourable members of the Venetian Court. I am Gratiano, a close friend of Antonio's. My relationship with Antonio has allowed me to observe Shylock over the years and never have I seen even a streak of kindness and forgiveness emerge from his blackened heart. He is the most sinister man that I have ever encountered in my life. His thoughts are full of greed for money and plans for revenge against his never ending hatred for Christians. Thus, I believe you are mistaken in thinking that Shylock should receive the penalty for the breach of a contract. I am indeed well aware of the contract between Antonio and Shylock and believe the terms of this bond were nowhere near fair; they are inhumane, and even Jessica, Shylock's runaway daughter, agrees that this is so; in fact, she betrayed him due to his brutishness! And in any case, what kind of a person would want a pound of flesh from an innocent Christian? To add to my point, who in their right mind would want a pound of Antonio's flesh? He is the purest, most loyal friend …show more content…

Our dear Antonio, he has not committed any sinful acts to receive this punishment. The money that was lost in the shipwreck that was unavoidable, it was an accident! The loan wasn't even for himself but for his dear friend Bassanio. Don't you realise that his overflowing kindness has led to his sacrificing his life for a friend? The loyalty he has shown in front of us all is undeniable, "good Bassanio, wise Duke, fellow Christians", we've all heard these words from him. Even in his language, we see his respect towards us. I understand that the contract has been broken but consider all the acts of kindness Antonio has shown, he is a respected man by all means who undeserving of the Jews

Get Access