How Significant Was The New Deal

The United States encountered many ordeals during the Great Depression (1929-1939). Poverty, unemployment and despair clouded the “American Dream” and intensified the urgency for solutions to address and control the nationwide damage. President Franklin Roosevelt proposed the New Deal to detoxify the nation of its suffering. It can be argued that the New Deal was ineffective due to the inability to end the Great Depression with its short-term solutions and created more problems, however; it was successful in regards to providing direct relief for the needy, economic recovery and some structural reform for the majority of the general public in the severity of the Great Depression.

This helped people survive the difficulties and tragedies that were happening before them and it made life a little bit easier than it already was. Before the New Deal people who didn’t have a job couldn’t make money, which then meant that they wouldn’t be able to provide food and other resources for their families. Now that people are being provided with jobs they are able to make money and were now able to provide and were able to begin reconstructing their lives. The more people who have jobs, the more people survive and the more our society grows in the right direction(Source G). This connects to the claim because without The New Deal then the unemployed wouldn’t have jobs. If The New Deal wasn’t created, then there would so many people on the streets dying of no food, no shelter, and other reasons. If this happened then our society would only decrease and it would soon enough hit rock

The New Deal was good because it provided Americans with hope, jobs, and government assistance during a time when American citizens could not help themselves. The Great Depression caused the US to fall apart economically, and the New Deal was put in place to try to fix the economy. President Roosevelt thought this was the best way to fix the economy, and it was. But that doesn’t mean it was perfect. It also doesn’t mean it worked. While many good things came from the New Deal, many bad things came out as well. But the good outweighed the bad, and the New Deal began the journey out of the Great Depression.

The book “Taking Sides: Clashing Views in United States History” by Madaras, Larry and James SoRelle draws attention on controversial issues. James and Madaras wrote the book in a debate-style format, which intrigues many students, hence supporting them in enhancing their critical thinking skills. James and Madaras ensured that every issue in the book has a summary, introduction, challenge question and postscript. Therefore, the paper will focus on issue 10, which debates on whether the new deal prolonged the great depression. The great depression refers to an era in US history, which happened from 1929 to 1941 during president Franklin Delano Roosevelt era, and it made the US citizens face economic hard times. The great depression era had much overproduction, inequality in wealth distribution and over borrowing. Consequently, the president implemented the new deal with the aim of saving American citizens from the great depression. However, people had different feelings regarding the effectiveness of the new deal, which brought up the debate in the book. For example, Burton Folsom believed that the new deal was not effective because he thought that it prolonged the great depression. On the contrary, Roger Biles alleged that the new deal was effective, and it did not prolong the great depression (Madaras and James 227).

The New Deal was a necessary program out in place which helped the nation and expanded the role of the government in a positive way. The nation was struggling in effect of the Great Depression and going through a hard time, and the New Deal helped the country out of it. Alone, the citizens of the United States would have never been able to pull themselves out of this mess, but the government stepped in and helped to fix the nation. The benefits of the New Deal can best be summed up with the three R’s: relief, recovery, and reform.

In his work The Achievement of the New Deal, author William E Leuchtenburg argues that when the great depression was shaking the stability of the American life, the new deal which is the policy of Franklin Delano Roosevelt led America towards the light. He shows us the drastic change that the deal brought which was very controversial and brought positive socioeconomic changes. It shows how the American life changes and the economy flourished in America. Leuchtenburg was a history professor at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and is a brilliant scholar of the life of Roosevelt.

Thesis: The New deals legislation has played a very integral part in helping recovery effort during the great depression because it led to a greater employment, and restored the security in the American economy. Although not perfect, the new deal success ultimately set the precedent for future progressive reform during times of economic depression and recession.

As historians look back into the past today, the question arises about the controversial topic of the success of the New Deal. Conservatives tended to believe it did too much in giving the federal government too much power, while liberals repealed this idea saying Franklin Roosevelt did not go far enough into the roots of the Great Depression. The New Deal tended to become sidetracked, focusing on one subject then jumping to another, never fully developing FDR’s ideas. As a whole, it is best said that historians can all agree the New Deal did not do its job in pulling the nation out of the depression. The New Deal seemed as if it was made to help the middle and lower class just below the poverty line, but ended up hurting them the most.

Despite Burton W. Folsom Jr.’s beliefs, Professor Roger Biles says that the New Deal utilized a minimal welfare state and economic stabilizers to steer away from another depression. He believes that very little of the New Deal was actually a new theory. Many of the policies put in place during the New Deal were actually ideas from previous Presidents and political leaders. For example, Woodrow Wilson’s farm credit acts sparked governmental aid to increase farmers’ income. This was not a brand new idea, yet Roosevelt gets quite a bit of credit for it. Whether the New Deal was new and fresh or not, it still failed to restore prosperity in America. However; Biles believes that the economic policies that failed in the 1930s have created many “stabilizers” to help avoid another similar depression.

The New Deal policies were created by Franklin D. Roosevelt and his people who are known as the “New Dealers”. They were created in hopes that they would bring relief, recovery, and reform to America and help bring America out of the depression. This flawed plan that many historians believe was largely a success brought America another rescission and caused the unemployment rate to rise. To believe that the New Deal was largely a success is to overlook its many failures and negative impact on America. From the failure of the NRA to the hostile reactions of many critics to the fact that unemployment rose, and the discrimination towards women and blacks it is clear that this New Deal was far from a success and was indeed very flawed.

The implementation of the New Deal was a necessary, yet highly criticized, and controversial time in our nation's history. Its creation, by President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, helped to resurrect a crumbling economy and put Americans back to work. However, like most things in life, there are always two sides to every story. This paper will explore both the pros and cons of FDR's, brainchild, the New Deal. In addition, it will argue that regardless of a positive or negative public opinion, there is no negating the fact that the New Deal was a pivotal movement and progressive step forward in our nation's history.

One reason the new deal was successful was that it created more jobs. In the depression many people were unemployed. The unemployment rate was around 25%. (Source B) The new deal greatly decreased this rate. It did this by giving jobs to make clothes, building hospitals, schools, and other things. (Sources E, F, and G) According to The American Nation

The legacies of the New Deal long out live the creators of it. At the time the idea that government would step in and make economic national policies was very much new and a scare to many Americans. The New Deal brought about a change in the role that government plays in the nation’s economy that would never reverse back to the way it was. The government took on a stronger "role as problem solver, economic stimulator, and economic regulator."

The New Deal’s impact on our American economy.The great depression of 1933-1938 our president FDR as he was called, known as Teddy to others, instrumented a plan of action shortly after his election changing the course of history forever and leaving a lasting impression forever imprinted on the hearts of the American people.The era of the great depression. When the stock market crash it disabled ordinary everyday life for a majority of the working middle class. Thousands of families were forced into poverty, grief-stricken and unemployed business owners, flat broke turned to their government for assistance. Immediate plans of action had to occur thus changing the way we look at our constitution, and the supreme court forever. Definition of American Politics? Conflicts between one nation under god and elected states, and society itself. Turning my attention from the legacy of political action and our constitutional some key focal points that have led up to change and reform between the federal government and state lawmakers.

“One if four Americans was out of work by 1933” (Livingnewdeal.org). A huge amount of the US population was unemployed and to change that President Roosevelt had to do something. In his new deal president Roosevelt created many jobs. What the new deal did was it created many different agencies to provide work for millions of unemployed workers and paid wages which saved many families. There were many agencies such as the American Federation of Labor (AFL) and The Public Works Administration (PWA), and Work Progress Administration (WPA) which gave work to 3 million people. The new deal also helped recover the economy by stabilizing the banks and cleaning up the mess from the stock market crash of 1929. “Roosevelt sought to reform the financial system, creating the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) to protect depositors accounts and the securities and exchange commission (SEC) to regulate the stock market and prevent abuse of the kind that led to the 1929 crash” (History.com). Not only did Roosevelt make agencies to help create jobs there was also many agencies created to help the financial system and to regulate the stock market so that something like the great depression does not happen again. This shows that the new deal was successful because it was able to give many jobs to unemployed Americans and fix the stock market and the financial system and many