How Successful Was The New Deal Dbq

The United States encountered many ordeals during the Great Depression (1929-1939). Poverty, unemployment and despair clouded the “American Dream” and intensified the urgency for solutions to address and control the nationwide damage. President Franklin Roosevelt proposed the New Deal to detoxify the nation of its suffering. It can be argued that the New Deal was ineffective due to the inability to end the Great Depression with its short-term solutions and created more problems, however; it was successful in regards to providing direct relief for the needy, economic recovery and some structural reform for the majority of the general public in the severity of the Great Depression.

based off of how the New Deal affected Native Americans discusses how African Americans had lower pay scales and last pick for jobs. (Doc B, African Americans and the New Deal). Along with low pay grades discussed in the article, there was also a group of authorities called The Federal Housing Authorities (FHA) whose job it was to refuse giving guaranteed mortgages for blacks trying to buy a house in a white neighborhood. However, the Working Progress Administration's (WPA) created a school lunch program helping many poor families get hot lunch meals for their kids at school (Doc D, Hot Lunches for a Million School Children). This shows that many people were helped by the New Deal. Therefore, the negatives of discrimination in that time frame was not helpful, in the end it is clear that the New Deal was helpful for

Ultimately the New deal programs did solve the issues that caused the great depression and it hoisted the U.S. out of the great depression and it gets millions back in employment. Many were happy with the effects of the great depression and it helped many live a better life. Just to show that it was successful is the fact that many of the New Deal programs still exist today including the FDIC, Social Security, and many

In his presidential acceptance speech in 1932, Franklin D. Roosevelt addressed to the citizens of the United States, “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people.” The New Deal, beginning in 1933, was a series of federal programs designed to provide relief, recovery, and reform to the fragile nation. The U.S. had been both economically and psychologically buffeted by the Great Depression. Many citizens looked up to FDR and his New Deal for help. However, there is much skepticism and controversy on whether these work projects significantly abated the dangerously high employment rates and pulled the U.S. out of the Great Depression. The New Deal was a bad deal

Document C illustrates that the New Deal represents change, but not revolutionary change. This caused the role of the government to expand. While Document D states that some New Deal acts were at odds with others. One example of a program in the second new deal is the Social Security Act, which created a retirement fund for citizen, but this act failed to help farmers, and domestic workers. The Tennessee Valley Act was part of the new deal, which helped with creating jobs, by building dams. Document I stated “The most important [The] most important contribution of the Roosevelt administration to the age-old color line problem in America has been its doctrine that Negroes are a part of the country and must ·be considered in any program for the country as a whole.” The New Deal acts were somewhat effective, as they did help some. In the end it wasn 't the New Deals that got America out of the depression it was their involvement in World War 2. World War 2 caused the unemployment rate to drop, since the whole country’s economy transformed to benefit war effort.

The Great Depression was a strenuous and devastating time for the United States; with millions of Americans losing their jobs, homes, and money. The banking industry and stock market are to blame for their irresponsible practices. Fortunately, when President Roosevelt was inaugurated into presidency, he had one mission: to end the Great Depression. He created a series of programs called the New Deal. Although the New Deal was somewhat successful, numerous Americans responded negatively to the New Deal. They saw it as unlawful and waste of national fund. Subsequently, these adverse reviews proved effective in the removable of certain agencies from the New Deal.

FDR’s New Deal responses to the Great Depression were very effective in that they improved the conditions of workers, they decreased the unemployment, and increased overall income of families. At the beginning of the depression, many people were out on the streets, unemployed, and hopeless. This is embodied in Document A, which describes the abundance of men on the street in contrast to women. The main focus of the document is that everyone was out of work and hungry and the idea was to explore the reasons why some people might be more obvious about it. It really emphasizes the low quality of life at the beginning of FDR’s presidency. Some people had different opinions about the idea that government involvement was necessary, which is shown

President Roosevelt Responds to The Great Depression President Roosevelt during his time as President had to deal with one of the darkest times in American history: The Great Depression. The stock market crashed and the whole country went to shambles. So, how did President Roosevelt respond? President Roosevelt responded by enacting the New Deal, which helped millions of poor Americans, while also expanding the role of Government in the United States citizens lives. (Thesis) To begin, Document A is Meridel Lesueur asking what will happen to the women during this time period.

Franklin D Roosevelt jumped into action to save the economy the 1930s. In Doc A, he said “we are giving opportunity of employment to one-quarter of a million of the unemployed, especially the young men…” (Doc A). This shows that the New Deal created jobs so people could get paid and ended the Depression. In Doc E, it shows that in 1937, the unemployment rate had increased down to 9.1% compared to the 22.5% it was before FDR took office (Doc E). This shows that the New Deal succeeded in providing work. Besides providing jobs, the New Deal gave Americans faith in their government.

Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal programs were a weak response for severe consequences that resulted from the Great Depression, and other conflicts that were occurring in the 1930’s. Although the New Deal programs positively revamped the political system and helped unemployed citizens get jobs, it challenged the order of the Executive Branch of the Federal government, gave false hope to the unemployed, and crushed the spirits of people of color and immigrants with its discriminatory views.

As historians look back into the past today, the question arises about the controversial topic of the success of the New Deal. Conservatives tended to believe it did too much in giving the federal government too much power, while liberals repealed this idea saying Franklin Roosevelt did not go far enough into the roots of the Great Depression. The New Deal tended to become sidetracked, focusing on one subject then jumping to another, never fully developing FDR’s ideas. As a whole, it is best said that historians can all agree the New Deal did not do its job in pulling the nation out of the depression. The New Deal seemed as if it was made to help the middle and lower class just below the poverty line, but ended up hurting them the most.

After the Stock Market Crash of 1929, life for Americans changed dramatically as the nation’s economy came to a halt. With unemployment rates reaching historic levels, politicians scrambled to find a fix for the Great Depression; but President Hoover’s attempts to mediate the issue with charity and negotiation were unsuccessful at best. In the end, what had the greatest impact at the time was President Roosevelt’s New Deal. Roosevelt’s New Deal, focusing on the goals of direct relief, economic recovery, and financial form, had limited effectiveness in its time, but expanded the long-term role of the federal government profoundly. Roosevelt’s primary concern was to provide direct relief to the poor by providing jobs and financial assistance.

After the New Deal unemployment dropped very low to 6% unemployed. This is mainly because The New Deal created lots of jobs to help people get money and helped banks get back on their feet by reassuring people that their money is safe in the bank and The New Deal insured everyone’s money up to $200,000. The New Deal also addressed many of the Native American problems pushing “congress to create the Indian Emergency Conservation Program (IECP).” This program created jobs for more than 85,000 Indians. This work was all done because of John Collier, someone Roosevelt appointed as “Commissioner of Indian Affairs.”

The great depression hit everyone, crippling the economy and killing the working class. While President Herbert Hoover inherited much of his predecessors failing policies, he also took on most of the blame. Most saw him as insensitive to the millions of suffering Americans which led to his defeat in the following election to President Franklin Delano Roosevelt. President Roosevelt came up with the plan the new deal to help the economy recover, reform it, and relieve it and in the new deal there was the Agriculture Adjustment Act, Securities and Exchange Commission, and the Social Securities Act.

The expansion of the government during the New Deal was not particularly beneficial for all Americans. The New Deal did not address social prejudice among African Americans. For example, in the South, there was still racial segregation. Although prejudice was a common practice, this was not what the New Deal was put into effect for. FDR’s main goal was getting people back to work, which was achieved. The Congress of Industrial Organizations started to accept African Americans. Overall, there were problems that America had yet to solve, but for what the New Deal’s goal was, I believe it benefited Americans.