preview

How To Legalize Physician Assisted Suicide

Decent Essays

Physician assisted suicide has become a rising state issue in Colorado. Recently, Proposition 106 was passed legalizing physician assisted suicide in Colorado. Physician assisted suicide, however, should be prevented because it is not ethical, breaks the physician relationship with the patient and the trust needed to maintain it, and violates the inalienable right to life. Because physician assisted suicide is unethical, it should be prevented. Physician assisted suicide is essentially putting someone to their death. This in and of itself is unethical. Ideas of physician assisted suicide lead to ideas of eugenics, the science of improving a human population by controlled breeding to increase the occurrence of desirable heritable characteristics …show more content…

While many believe that science sanctions physician assisted suicide, it is necessary to recognize the limits of science’s influence in our lives. “The notion that science should dictate our entire worldview, including our morality, has a long pedigree and remains prominent today” (Weikart 6). Despite science apparently telling us that physician assisted suicide is principled, it is important to realize that science should not direct our morality and view of ethics. Weikart explains, “We should firmly reject the idea that science has anything to say to us about what we should do, how we should live, or when we should die” (6). Utilizing science as a justification for physician assisted suicide is immoral. We must use the values of science to improve the quality of life, not take a life. Furthermore, many notable health organizations have come forward in opposition to physician assisted death, stating that physician assisted death contradicts their code of ethics. “The American Medical Association (1996) ethics code advises that PAD is inconsistent with the primary role of physicians to heal: ‘Instead of participating in assisted suicide, physicians must aggressively respond to the needs of patients at the end of life.’ …show more content…

As United States citizens, we are guaranteed certain rights. One of these rights is the right to life. A human has a right to live, and a right to not be killed by another human being or themself. This right is established by our forefathers, who developed the Declaration of Independence around this principle. Physician assisted suicide clearly contradicts this right. James Thunder states, “The right at issue is the right of an individual to be treated and valued as a human being up to the moment of natural death, the right of the individual to not have her life denigrated to the point of her doctor, sworn to protect life, administering a lethal injection” (440). This shows that physician assisted suicide devalues life and the means to preserve it. “The Declaration of Independence recognizes that there is a right to life and that it is an inalienable one, meaning it is a right that a person can never give up. It is not a right depended on the largesse of the government or the people. It is not a right dependent on an individual’s mental competence or willingness to give it up. It is inalienable” (Thunder 441). Because the right to life is inalienable, it can not be taken away. Physician assisted suicide takes life, clearly denying the right to life. As physician assisted suicide contradicts the inalienable right to life, it is necessary that it be stopped

Get Access