preview

Ideologies Of Transcendentalism : Ralph Waldo Emerson And Henry David Thoreau

Good Essays

Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau wrote essays on their ideologies of transcendentalism. Thoreau’s belief in intellectualism, spirituality, and naturalism comes from him reading Emerson’s essays and being close friends with him. Thoreau lived in the woods and wrote Walden around Emerson’s ideals. Together they make up classical transcendentalists who changed the perspective of the world. Emerson seems to be the Thoreau’s ideology stems from Emerson work directly, but while Emerson wrote theories, Thoreau implemented his beliefs into his life. Emerson also speaks mainly of scholars and academic people while Thoreau acknowledges the full scope of humanity. Emerson also views nature as laws and Thoreau view nature as poetic. Thoreau’s work means more than Emerson’s various essays. Emerson never fully implemented his ideals he wrote about, making his work seem less legitimate than Thoreau, who lived in a cabin in the woods to write his book. In “Nature,” Emerson states, “I am not solitary whilst I read and write, though nobody is with me. But if a man would be alone, let him look at the stars” (Emerson 17). Emerson speaks of himself as “not solitary,” while referring to his readers. The implementation of his constant with people seemed like a noble cause, but he seems to not implement it in his personal life. In “Circles,” Emerson claims, “I am God in nature; I am a weed by the wall” (Emerson 196). This, along with the piece from “Nature,” shows that Emerson contradicts himself and says he is both above everyone, like “God,” or surrounded by peers, fellow readers and writers. Emerson never shows that he believes what he writes because his writing is constantly contradicting himself. He writes of surrounded while alone, and then equates himself to the all powerful being that he very well believes in, being the son of a reverend. By saying that he is “God in nature,” he is showing his egotistical view on the world and how he has control over the uncontrollable, something Thoreau understands the world to be. Emerson can not prove that he has this control, though Thoreau lived at Walden Pond in nature and never claims to be in control, rather, he seems to be at the mercy of nature and understands that. He

Get Access