preview

Immanuel Kant On Morally Right

Decent Essays
Open Document

Aradhya Kunwar
1002375627
James Langlois
TUT0015
1. A) In the principle of humanity Immanuel Kant states, “Always treat human being (yourself included) as an end, and never as a mere means” (Shafer-Landau, 147). Here by human beings or humanity Kant is referring to “rational and autonomous beings” (Shafer-Landau, 147). Those beings that can distinguish between morally right and wrong, and have the ability to use this knowledge (do what they know to be morally right) to achieve their goals (rational) and those who can use their intellect to make independent decisions (autonomous). This includes mammals and possibly aliens some other planets who fit under the aforementioned definition of Humanity, but excludes children, mentally challenged …show more content…

Being a rational and autonomous being the janitor has same moral status as any other human being. According to the principle of humanity everyone should treat him/her with the respect s/he rightfully deserves. Which could be done by not interrupting him/her while they are working and helping them achieve their goal (here it would be to clean a place). Those people who treat a janitor disrespectfully are doing something that is morally wrong. Furthermore, one must not treat think that janitors are only there to clean something or make some place dirty and refuse to clean it because they think it is the janitors duty to do so (treat as mere means). This according the principle of humanity is not morally justified. This is the best aspect of the principle of humanity, which demands the moral treatment of every human being. It entitles him/her with a special moral …show more content…

It also requires one to make it possible for that person to be able to live his/her life independently. Thus, to treat someone as an end it is necessary to help them become a part of humanity.Using children as labours is clearly treating them as mere means. But the principle of humanity does not find anything wrong with this because children are not autonomous thus are not a part of humanity as defined by Kant. So, children should be treated as non-human. In order to treat them as an end one must help them become autonomous. Using them as labours will never make that possible but it has chancing of worsening the chance of them becoming autonomous one day. Thus, child labour should be considered morally

Get Access