preview

Immigration Essay

Decent Essays

Immigration Paper-Compare/Contrast
Immigration is a topic that has been argued many times in the United States. Many people support it while others believe that immigrants are criminals who commit the crime of entering the U.S. illegally. Roberto Rodriguez and Star Parker both use different styles of writing in “Border on our Backs” and “Se Habla Entitlement” respectively. Although Roberto Rodriguez uses a personal approach to convey his message, Star Parker’s method of using real life facts and details to support her opinion really pulls through and is therefore more convincing. Roberto Rodriguez tries to use emotion to motivate and capture the reader’s attention to support his feelings for immigration but fails to back up any of his …show more content…

He asks “Why is all the hate and vilification directed at brown peoples and the southern border?....why are these politicians also not bothered by the millions of Canadians, Europeans, or Russians who overstay their visas?”(Rodriguez 560). Questioning is not considered to be very skillful in writing. By putting these statements in question form, Rodriguez is almost making them a fact, when the reality is that immigration laws and problems are aimed toward all illegal immigrants not just South Americans. The main objective of the author is to answer the reader’s questions not create more questions which may confuse the reader and derail them from the main topic. Not only is this confusing but Rodriguez continues to try to influence the reader without any proper validation. On the contrary Star Parker uses research and real life statistics to influence the reader’s opinion. “Se Habla Entitlement” is filled with facts and research. She reports “Last year the Pew Hispanic Center surveyed adults in Mexico and asked them if they would come to the United States…Forty-six percent responded yes…When asked if they would do it illegally more than 20 percent said yes”(Parker 565). She continues “…almost half of Mexican adults say they would rather live in the United States, presumably because of the opportunities our free society affords”(Parker 565). First she shows the facts about immigration then goes on to

Get Access