preview

Impact-Based Warnings

Decent Essays

This study examined the effectiveness of the new impact based warnings (IBW) on tornado warning and risk communication which is an important topic and would contribute to future policy making on warning response area. Overall, the author did a thorough literature review, conducted quantitative experiments which represented a fair attempt at tackling the topic, and employed adequate analysis approaches to test the hypotheses. However, there are some moderate issues to the manuscript that prevent me from recommending the editor accept this manuscript in its present form. Experimental Design: First of all, the author did not specify whether the participants received audible or readable warning messages. Why did author select one but not the other? …show more content…

Specifically, it seems that the author pooled data from different sequences together without testing the homogeneity. Does the author take any considerations to avoid the impacts from those effects? Analyses and results: First of all, even though the author reported that students had different level of knowledge on tornado with adults, the author still pooled student samples together with adult samples. Why? Next, the author mentioned that each scenario has two versions (instate vs. outstate), but the author only process a two-dimension MANOVA without any tests on location effect. Why? If the author agreed that the decision point one can be an anchor setup point for each participant, it would be more meaningful to test behavioral changes between each pair of decision point than to test the central tendency of shelter in place decision on each individual decision point. Of course, McNemar test then would be a possible method that the author would adopt (because we are more interested in people convinced by enhanced wording

Get Access