Before I begin to answer all the questions involved in this discussion, I must note that if watching this documentary once made me upset, watching it twice made it worse. It makes me sick to see how women are treated in the fields of my beautiful, America. It made me even sicker to see that many times the men doing the assaults were Hispanic themselves. The entire time I would think, “How could they being doing such a thing when they should be helping!”
Awful, just awful!
(1) When we talked about the official definition of sexual harassment, we noted the difference between "unwelcome" and "involuntary" actions. How is this illustrated in the documentary?
Unwelcomed sexual harassment was well noted by all the women who were grabbed,
touched,
…show more content…
They did actions against their will because they were really scared. Scared because they were here illegally. Scared for their families, their loved ones and all their responsibilities.
These women, unfortunately sometimes had to face both unwelcomed and involuntary sexual harassments from these men against their will and the worse part with no one to tell the tale to…
(2) Discuss the ways in which power/powerlessness comes into play in the situation of women farmworkers who are undocumented immigrants. (Here, you can talk about the power of the farm owners relative to the workers.)
This entire documentary demonstrated the power the foremen had against the powerless women. The foremen used their power, their position and their ability to manipulate where and how the women worked to use and abuse them…to rape them and grope them against their will and the women took all the abuse because like I stated earlier, they were scared. And any of us who have felt fear at any time in our lives understand that fear is an awful thing.
(3) Along with the issue of relative power between the farmworkers and farm owners comes
…show more content…
Because if you are a decent person, who owns a farm and you find out that your foremen are abusing of your undocumented or documented women, IMMEDIATELY, you should report or fire them yourself! To act as if you see nothing, hear nothing or know nothing, as an owner of a farm, when you know exactly what is going on makes you just as guilty.
What’s wrong with people?! These women are human beings. They are human beings; human being who are being exploited, raped, groped, touched, and even murdered all because they wanted to come to America, this great country to make a better life for themselves and their families. They live simple lives, work jobs no one else wants to do, and for what? To be violated while the owners, the authorities and those in the higher ups have a blind eye? Why or how can they do that? With all the cases that were brought to the attention of the EEOC, not one of the foremen, owners, or others were actually brought to justice or really charged. Yes, they paid
“fines” as if money could change what had happened, but no crime charges were actually brought to them. It was horrible to
In “A Peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carries a Gun” by Linda Hasselstrom, the author illustrates the difficulties women face in today’s society (354-358). Sadly, Hasselstrom writes about many times when men harassed her sexually, physically, and mentally (354). She describes one situation in which she and a friend were staying at a campground, sleeping fifteen feet away from two young men at an adjacent campsite (355). The men were drinking alcohol and discussing what they would do to the women after dark (Hasselstrom 355). Scared for their safety, the women approached the park rangers and described the scenario, but the park rangers excused the young men’s behavior, saying, “Don’t worry girls. They’re just kidding” (Hasselstrom 355). The park rangers demonstrated how insincerely men’s threats towards women are taken in our society. Also, Hasselstrom describes how other nearby campers were ignoring the men’s threats as well (355). Therefore, since no one seemed to be concerned about their safety, Hasselstrom and her friend left their campsite and illegally proceeded to another place in the woods to camp (Hasselstrom 355). Hasselstrom also recounts another instance in which she approached several men who had littered beer bottles, and were going to the bathroom, on her property(357). Hasselstrom politely asked the men to stop what they were doing
not speak out against the violence they suffered. Getting sexually assaulted and harassed was the
they come forward and confront their attacker. Women in this situation are left with no voice or
As the empowerment and the unceasing push for equal status for women has become widely popular and successful only in recent history. Women have stepped out of their traditional roles of the housewife, the mother and the complying doormat to more assertive natures. Many contentious issues surround women’s
there life in Mexico was awful they worked all day for a little bit of money and couldn't support their families with food or money so they came to the U.S because honestly they make more money here then they probably ever made in Mexico.
When watching a documentary film, especially if it talks about nature, people expect the same videos of the environment going down, destroyed, and abused by people—clever, but rarely creating an impact to viewers. This, however, is a lot different than the clichés of the planet’s suffering. The graceful narration by Glenn Close of straightforward content that we all need to be able to grasp the whole point of the film, combined with the beautifully shot scenes which is mostly from above, basically made it quite remarkable and moving for us.
If we take the society as a given, and situate women within it, their perception would likely to reflect the dominant values. May we say that the apparent inconsistencies of our informants in their definition of power and agencies arise from the changes in the society? Each of the informants situates herself/himself within the sphere of her/his perceived structure of the society. Had there been no changes in the demography due to the increase of population, no international division of labor that absorbs three of the girls of the village, no governmental program in expanding education, or no supports of the NGOs, to what extent would it be possible for some of our informants to define power and agency other than their very traditional ways of viewing what they called the God-gifted power of giving birth and bearing pain? It appears that the power
Patriarchal societies around the world more often turn a blind eye to the abuses men face
A qualitative research design is well suited to answering this question, and may be built upon an intersection of contemporary empowerment and post-structural feminist theories, thereby enhancing a unique perspective of the mechanisms and dimensions of power. In order to generate participant
I believe that fear is sometimes a very good thing. Fear can keep you from doing things that hurt, or kill you. Many believe that fear is actually deep instinct that all humans possess. We are all born with it; it affects our lives more than we know.
Tractors, land corporations, and bankers reflect the alienation and corruptions that result when landownership and farming become a business. Migrants believe that the land belongs to those who work it and draw sustenance from it. This attitude is contrasted with that of landowners who allow their lands to lie dormant while others are hungry, and with absentee ownership that exists only to make a profit.
Women from all over the world spoke out in an NPR article, “Street Harassment Around the World: What’s Your Story?”, about what men in different countries would do to harass them as they are walking down the street. One of the shocking experiences was in in Cairo, Egypt. Malaka Gharib, the author of the article shares her story, “They pushed Ramy aside and grabbed at me, taunted me for wearing shorts, then ran away, laughing. I was frightened and humiliated. Though the incident lasted less than 30 seconds, it felt like forever.” Somebody might imagine that the incident isn’t the worst that can happen to a woman,
Sexual harassment occurs quite frequently in various workplaces and can consist of many different situations. In today's world though, females are not the only ones who have to deal with this problem, believe it or not, males do too. There are many ways of dealing with these situations, but getting the harassment to stop is not as easy. Dealing with sexual harassment today does not just include unwelcome sexual advances, but slurs, lewd remarks, and much more. Many laws have been set up to interact with these problems. Unfortunately, most of these laws are not followed
Or at least it should. One of the greatest weapons that a corporation can wield is silence, which leads to ignorance about its operating practices, allowing it to commit
Power is something societies find difficult to come to a conclusion on whether or not the male or female is capable of having, or whether they should be equal or not. In a patriarchy, it is known as an organized social structure where the men hold all the power. Which leaves out women and their ability to succeed and take control of their lives. Power can be shown in many forms but one major way that it can be brought to the surface is by many individuals in such activities considerably mass movements. These movements can be shown to be effective through strategies such as boycotts, civil disobedience, and media campaigns (Anderson, 2015).Not until the late 1800s were women ever outspoken