Is Guantanamo Bay Is A Political Catch 22?

This deontological perspective focuses primarily on the intention of our actions, rather than the consequence. Under the categorical imperative, one must follow formulations in order to make rational ethical decisions. The first formulation states that any act that you commit must become universal. If that act cannot become universal, then we must refrain from it. For example, in making a decision on whether or not to steal, one must ask if it would be acceptable to them if someone were to steal from them. In making an act universal, we must imagine a world in which the act is always permissible. The second formulation proclaims that you may not use any human being, including oneself, as a mere means. This explains that you cannot use any form of humanity as merely an object or tool, regardless of independent desires or passions. Kant also

The article “Why Guantanamo Bay must be closed for good” by Jonathan Russell denotes the existence of Guantanamo Bay, a maximum security prison off the coast of Cuba. Russell begins by saying that Guantanamo Bay is ineffective because it does not prevent terrorism in other parts of the world. In fact, the existence of Guantanamo Bay fuels terrorist to carry out more terrorist attacks as an act of defiance. Additionally, most people who go to the prison do not get the right to a fair trial as guaranteed by the fifth and sixth amendments. The prison is notorious for its torture of its prisoners. Prisoners face waterboarding, electric shocking, sexual humiliation and are even deprived of sleep. The torture is supposed to make prisoners reveal

In the beginning of the 21st century, or the early 2000’s, Guantanamo Bay was used to house suspected terrorists that were captured by US forces in Iraq and Afghanistan. The detainment of such prisoners aroused suspicions around the world regarding the constitutionality of the treatment of these prisoners. This was just the beginning of many allegations against the US on the subject.

Guantanamo Bay is a U.S. Military maximum security prison that is considered a detainee camp for unlawful enemy combatants. Guantanamo has become a worldwide focal point because of the reports of abuse, torture and the prolonged trials for detainees and its closure and release of its detainees has been called for by many. World leaders, media outlets and humanitarian organizations have requested the closure and release of these detention facilities and their detainees, but it remains vital that these detainees are tried and receive fair punishment for their acts of terrorism.

Throughout the last 15 years of operation, Guantanamo Bay has faced endless criticism from both international countries and the US. The biggest issue is the legal “black hole” that exists at Guantanamo Bay and the concern over interrogation techniques and torture. We are able to torture prisoners because of how George W Bush described the war. “Bush thought it was a new kind of war and that this meant the Americans didn’t need adhere the rules of the Geneva Convention,” explains Professor Honigsberg from the University of San Francisco. The convention says prisoners of war must be treated humanely during a war. “But Bush didn’t call them ‘prisoners of war’ but ‘enemy combatants’. This was how a

The issues that have had cause a lot of controversy since 2002.The closing of Guantanamo Bay has led to be the most reported prison that’s held prisoners against their own will. Due to against war on terror, but has yet most detainees havn’t been charged. We wonder in the closing of Guantanamo Bay who will it affect, what will happen, when will the closing of Guantanamo Bay takes place, and how will this play a role in the world today.

When the detainees weren’t spending days in isolation or sleeping on cement floors, they were most likely being tormented or harshly interrogated. Many of the methods used to try to gain information from the prisoners raised disapproval from human rights observers. Some reasons include the repeated instances of humiliation, beating, and coercion during the questioning of detainees. In addition, other reports have noted sexual assault, drowning simulations, exposure to extreme temperatures, and sleep deprivation. When their distress had become too much to bear, “prisoners attempted a mass suicide by hanging and engaged in hunger strikes.” If detainees refused to eat, they were sometimes force fed. The prisoners’ phobias are also used against them; for example, attack dogs are sometimes used to receive fear-driven confessions. The methods of torture used at GTMO are arguably necessary for a convicted terrorist, but what about for a man who doesn’t have any physical evidence against

Guantanamo Bay detention camp is a United States military prison located on the Guantanamo Bay Naval base in Cuba. The G-bay or GTMO prison camp was created in 2002 to detain extraordinarily dangerous people, to interrogate detainees at the greatest setting, and to litigate detainees for crimes they may have committed. After reading Guantanamo ‘Honor Bound to Defend Freedom’ my understanding of the ethics and efficacy of the Guantanamo detention center has changed tremendously. The book may be biased because all it talks about is the detainees that were mistreated, and doesn’t mention anything about the detainees that actually was doing very bad things, but the way Victoria Brittain and Gillian Slovo tell these sorrowful stories of these detainees that were treated wrongly you have no choice but to feel and question our Secretary of Defense. The book may be the story of the mistreated, but all take is one mistake for us to question our judicial and legislative

As Nelson Mandela once said, “To deny people their human rights is to challenge their very humanity.” Guantánamo bay, Cuba is the home of the oldest U.S naval station base out of the continental U.S. The United States invaded Guantánamo bay and established a base during the Spanish-American war (“Guantanamo...” 2008, par. 2). After the attack on the twin towers on September 11, 2001, the base’s mission expanded to include the Detainee Mission of the War of Terror (“Guantanamo…” 2008, par. 5). Many issues have risen because of this detention facility. The detainees held at the facility have to and had to face many challenges. The government took away their human rights and treats these detainees very harshly. Currently, there are still detainees held at Guantánamo bay. However, some actions have occurred to stop these inhumane actions, but there have not been enough to close the facility down.

today Guantanamo Bay has been a big topic in today’s society. On his campaign trail, President Obama pledged, “I will close Guantanamo bay detention center within a year of being elected”. My main argument has to be the amount of money were wasting on this prison. To be specific according to democratic lawmakers it has skyrocketed to $2.7 million per inmate. Guantanamo has been dubbed the most expensive prison on earth.

Guantanamo Bay, though started with good intentions, only highlights America’s negative side. Marine Major General Michael Lehnert, who played a significant role in the opening of Guantanamo, has drastically changed his opinion and said that it, “Validates every negative perception of the U.S.” (Sutton 1). One example of this occurred in 2006, when President Bush justified the use of “physical coercion” (torture) during interrogations (Fetini 1). Some of these torture methods include isolation, beatings, sleep deprivation, and general abuse. Other tactics such as disrespect for Islamic symbols or sexual provocation are used to encourage stress in detainees (Bloche 1). These immoral methods led to an international outcry. It was later remarked that the Cuban territory upon which Guantanamo is located is being used as a “concentration camp” of sorts (Fetini 1). Guantanamo and its unethical values are being recognized by nations around the world, displaying America in a bad light.

Guantanamo Bay is a United States military prison located in Cuba. It has been considered one of the “top priorities for normalization.” (Brodzins and Watts). Guantanamo was first established in 1898 at the end of the Spanish American War. Guantanamo continued to remain after the Cuban Revolution. There have been rumors of torture at Guantanamo Bay. An interview took place written by CBS news having Col. Patrick Harris, head of human intelligence gathering at the Pentagon’s Defense center talk about Guantanamo Bay. “Yeah,” says Lang. “I think its torture.” Sgt. Erik Saar, a solider who worked in the interrogation rooms at Guantanamo Bay was also interviewed. He spoke about the amount he believes are really terrorists. “At best I’d say a few dozen,” says Saar. “A few dozen [out of 600].” Saar also talks about how the interrogators treat the prisoners during interrogation. “She wanted to create a barrier between this detainee and his faith, and if she could somehow sexually entice him, he would feel unclean in an Islamic way, he would not be able to pray and go before his God and gain that strength, so the next day, maybe he would be able to start cooperating, start talking to her.”(Leung). Even though many rumors of torture exist, but the Embassy of the United States claims that "Categorically that any maltreatment of any detainees by U.S. Forces or Coalition forces is

Deontological ethics is concerned with what people do, not with the consequences of their actions. Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) is credited for laying the foundations of deontology. Under this form of ethics, good consequences do not necessarily justify an action. Kant´s duty-based ethics was based on what he called the ´categorical imperative´ [4].

The ethical philosophy of Immanuel Kant regards moral actions as right or wrong regardless of context or circumstance. This approach to ethics is known as deontological as it considers the actions themselves as opposed to the consequences; what one should do in practice should be thought of as substantive concepts. Along with our fundamental ability to recognise this, Kant strongly believed that it is our duty as individuals to utilize our ability to wield reason and rationality as morally autonomous beings. These obligations manifest to Kant in two distinctive forms: those that are Hypothetical Imperatives and those that are Categorical Imperatives.

2. Kantian deontology describes a human being as an agent that voluntarily acts with a specific goal or end in mind. Acting with the reason of achieving a goal or end as the hypothetical imperative and this is led by desire. Deontology however explains that for an action to be truly