Is Lying Ever Justified Lying is one of the most common acts carried out by people that is seen as morally wrong. Lying is defined as “a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive; an intentional untruth; a falsehood.” (“Lie”) The three main type of lies: peacekeeping lies, protective lies, and trust keeping lies. The thought of whether or not to lie is a moral problem that everyone goes through. Most people would say that lying is always wrong. Lying usually does not end well and is morally wrong, but when the lie is being used to save lives it can be justified.
Protective lies are commonly used by someone who intentionally does not tell the truth because they believe it will benefit the person. "A little inaccuracy sometimes saves tons of explanation." (Truth About Deception) The person telling the lie truly believes it will help the person emotionally or physically if they do not know the whole truth.
…show more content…
“Lying can be giving some information while believing it to be untrue, intending to deceive by doing so.” (BBC - Ethics - Lying) A example of someone who had to tell a lie and deceive others to protect people she cared about was Harriet Tubman. Harriet Tubman had to lie and deceive many people to protect the people most important to her. She lied so she could bring groups of slaves out of Maryland on the underground railroad. If Harriet Tubman would have not lied the slaves would have never escaped and the other people trying to rescue them may have been caught. Harriet tubman lied, but she did it to save the lives of many families and groups from the life of a slave and by doing that also saved many lives. The type of lies the Harriet Tubman told are acceptable because they were told for the greater good and protection of others. If the lie can save lives or protect the safety of peoples it can be
Many may question whether Lying is a good or bad thing. While many believe that lying is used to protect someone, you might be actually do more harm than good. Everybody can lie but it can have a variety of outcomes. Allowing yourself to lie doesn't help anybody. Lying is unjustified because it would cause harm to someone than good and telling the truth can be beneficial and easier.
Lying can save you in severe situations such as life or death. Elie lied about his age and said he was eighteen instead of fifteen. “‘Your age?’ he asked, perhaps trying to sound paternal. ‘I'm eighteen.’ My voice was trembling.” (Wiesel 31). Not telling exact information to strangers about yourself can prevent bad things from happening. He told the doctor he was sick so he didn’t have to get his crown taken. His crown could buy him an extra ration of bread and soup, so he decided it’d be smart to keep it. He said he was a farmer because it could save him from being killed immediately. Lying is one of many ways that can help people survive in certain situations.
Lying can be described as the act of telling an untruth, but just when is it ok to lie? In the articles, “It’s the Truth: Americans Conflicted About Lying,” from Life on NBCNEWS.com, and “Brad Blanton: Honestly, Tell the Truth,” by Barbara Ballinger, it provides evidence that leads me to believe that lying is acceptable when you do it to protect a relationship or someone from a life or death situation.
Lying to protect someone or their feelings is sometimes justified, while the other types of lies are not. In the article, “It’s the Truth: Americans Conflicted About Lying” by Life on NBCNEWS.com, a noted ethics columnist, Randy
Do you believe lying is okay? Paul Gary, Priscilla Painton, and Elizabeth Rudolph wrote an article “The U.S. Political campaign; lies to protect” talking about their prospective on the situation. I agree with this article because sometimes we need to protect others from the truth about how we feel. Also just to keep the person as our friend.
Lying is justified when it can be used to protect and care for others . For example , paul gray says “ on rare occasions, lying to protect others can literally be a matter of life or death (2). Lying is also okay to tell because if someone tries to do something you would tell them lies so that way they stop . In addition , an example if someone was trying to kill you and others lied you
Joud zahran 10.5 Lies And Deception We all lie, we all have our secrets are reasons to why. Some people might define lying as good, a way to spare another from pain or themselves. Others may see it badly. As for the definition of lies from dictionary.com “a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive; an intentional untruth; a falsehood.”
Lying is a bad thing to do, most of the time. But are there cases in which lying is the right thing to do?
Lying, we all have done it more than once in our lives, whether it was a small white lie or a cold hard lie, we have done it. As Terry Goodrich said it in her article Lies are so Commonplace, They Almost Seem Like the Truth, We use lies to “avoid things that should be done, to get people to believe us, to get what we want, to buy time, to end conversations, to keep relationships going.” Or simply put it, we lied because we wants to do good, and the truth is not always good. Like in the movie “A few good men” when Kaffee (Tom Cruise) questioned Col. Jessep (Jack Nicholson) about the truth, Jack said that he can’t handle the truth. since the truth is that Col. Jessep had ordered to kill a man in order to preserve the honor of the marines
From a young age, we are taught that lying is bad and it’s a sign of immaturity. However, our parents tell us these things as they lie to our face, called “white lies.” There are many instances in our culture when lying would be deemed acceptable: saving a life, fraudulent reassurance, or preserving harmony. To understand lying more, focus on the repercussions or punishments for lying. People are more inclined to lie when they fear the punishment that entails. We are quick to call others liars and frauds while we don’t even have a firm grasp between our idea of lying and truth telling. Our society draws an unclear line about when it is okay to lie and when not to. Basing everything purely off justification.
Lying in omnipresent and most would argue that in many cases lying is better than telling the truth. From a consequentialist and utilitarian’s view, lying creates more harm than good. According to Mill, there is a high moral assumption facing lying, as lying makes one less honest and weakens trust. So, when is lying morally permissible? One might suggest that lying is the most intuitively moral and justified option
Lying, it’s everywhere. Almost 60% of most adults can’t go ten minutes without telling a lie. Some people lie to protect other people, while others lie to benefit themselves like maintaining the perfect image they care so much about. However, lying is completely unjustified unless you’re protecting yourself or someone else from danger. This idea can be further proven with evidence from a variety of articles.
Sometimes telling a lie seems to be so necessary to spare our loved ones to be hurt. “Not only is Lying justified, it is sometimes a moral duty.” The above, evidence implies that by telling lies we can prevent future arguments from happening. Lying yields positive results rather than negative ones because you did lie to protect others and not to be hurt.
Need a guide to lying? Don't know what to say to get your way? Well then you're in the wrong place reading the wrong paper. Don't understand lying and don't know when to lie? The answer is here! “ All our lives we've been taught to lie.”(Blanton), but is it what we should do? Think of why you've lied before. To spare someone's feelings, or to get out of troubled. We lie for ourselves most of the time, but that occasion comes when you lie for others. Is it ok to lie to do something bad? Is it ok to lie to save someone? What do you think.
For the sake of others or themselves? While some lie to simply protect others, others lie to selfishly protect themselves. Regardless of the good will or selfish intention behind the lie, one will always confront consequences when telling a lie. These consequences have the ability to easily surpass the benefits. “Hurt me with the truth, but never comfort me with a lie.”