Is Magellan Worth Defending?

The test was giving an indian beans to make a map of the islands of the Indies. He did this to see if they were intelligent, and to see how many islands there were. The king felt amazed, but mostly angry when He saw how many islands there were, and because he could of hired Columbus. I think He had the right to feel this way because He liked the idea of hiring Columbus in the first place, but his advisors didn’t like the idea, so he said no to giving columbus the boats.

The not singular but twice repeated mutiny shows the bad captainship of Magellan. In agreement, Document B describes that, “Many of the men—resentful of this cut and fearing that Magellan might lead them to their death—began to demand that the fleet return to Spain. Magellan refused, and the growing discontent eventually led to the mutiny...” (Document B) The act of mutiny shows extreme discontent with a captain, and is reasonable in this case. If the captain is this troublesome, it is not essential that he is saved. Accordingly, Document C submits to the notion that, “The trip through the strait took 38 days, during which time one of the ships, the San Antonio, deserted the fleet and returned to Spain.” (Document C) This excerpt show further discontent with the captain. If the captain’s value is questioned more than once, a decision to label his unworthiness is clear. Furthermore, Document A

Ferdinand Magellan, on April 27,1521, was he worth defending? Magellan was not worth defending on the Philippine Bay. Ever Since Magellan sailed out into the open sea, his crew was never with him, mutinies, deaths, cruelty all these were examples what happened on the sail with Magellan. What really led to his deathbed on April 27, was the Concern of his crew, Cruelty, and poor Navigational skills through the journey.

The year Columbus set out to sail was the historical beginning of a bad ending. This ending should be acknowledged by all as the choices and decisions of the Spanish King and Queen Ferdinand and Isabella. Without the royal’s greediness, there would have been a different ending to this story that wouldn’t have resulted in the complete obliteration of foreign human beings--genocide.

One of the sad lessons historians learn is that history’s influenced less by the facts as they happen than by the falsehoods men believe. Christopher Columbus, Admiral of the Seas and former Spanish Governor of Hispaniola, is one of these victims of large-scale ignorance to historical moral relativism. The crimes my client is accused of having committed have eclipsed the real Columbus and, judged by their effects, have outstripped him in importance. In truth, Columbus was a firm Christian of humble beginnings from Italy; Columbus was self-educated and learned Latin, Spanish, and Portuguese all on his own. He also suffered greatly in the year 1480, when his love, Filipa, died of fever shortly after delivering their first and only son.

Most people would agree that Christopher Columbus was a courageous man. He sailed across unknown seas on four different occasions, used extraordinary navigational skills, and opened up the western hemisphere to exploration that created what is known today as the modern world. He was considered the greatest navigator of his time and he trained other navy captains who sailed for Spain. He had a firm belief in god and with that belief enjoyed the beauty of the coastlines that he explored. Many people praised Columbus because he “carried Christian civilization across the ocean.” There was ample evidence to show Columbus’s heroic exploits. However, historians have a more complete story to tell about Christopher Columbus. His explorations caused millions of deaths, destroyed countless cultures, added to the spread of slavery and treated the subjects he conquered with violence and cruelty. As a result the negative outweighs the positive. Columbus was not a hero. He was a villain.

Was Magellan worth defending? There is a lot of controversy about Magellan. Some people believe Magellan should was not worth defending, while others believe he should have been defended. Magellan went to Spain to get his crew and get someone to fund his voyage. Magellan was a captain of five ships.

Even in small matters, the historical Columbus had a way of demonstrating his true character, which was quite different from that portrayed in this film or in popular culture in general. In the movie, Columbus did offer a bounty to the first sailor who sighted land, but in reality when he returned to Spain he claimed it for himself. Indeed, he wrote an entire book asserting that he was not

Magellan wanted to find the spices and the spices were more than gold. Is Magellan worth defending? Magellan was worth defending because as it states in document B he gave his crew a chance. In document B the crew did something wrong he gave them a chance. he had a little concern for his crew.

People did not believe he could do this. He left Portugal in 1519 with five ships and 250 sailors. The ships names were Trinidad, Victoria, San Antonio, Santiago, and Concepcion. When he left he was heading around southwest because he ended up at the very bottom of South America. There he found a water passageway that connected the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific Ocean which is now named after him. It is called the Strait of Magellan. This saved his sailors time, food, and other resources. It saved those things because if it took longer than the sailors would have to eat more which would lower the supply. While did save some of their lives, many of his crew did die to starvation. About three fourths his way around the globe more trouble begins. Ferdinand Magellan loses some of his ships and a lot of his crew. With the food supply gone he needs to stop, and then he sees some islands near. He decides to

Columbus was outraged and established a labor policy over the natives and forced them to rebuild the settlement and also explore for gold. This would be one of Columbus’s downfalls (Columbus, 2014). Despite these demands, not much gold was found and instead Columbus developed a bad reputation amongst the natives. Columbus further explored the Caribbean islands and was convinced he had found the islands of China. On Columbus's third voyage, he discovered the actual mainland in the Caribbean.

Ferdinand was in his mid-20s when he went on his first two voyages for Portugal. On his second, he acquired a Malaysian servant boy, Enrique. Once his voyages were done Magellan and Enrique moved to Spain in hopes of offering his talents to the Spanish. Magellan made a proposition to King Charles Ⅰ of Spain, he would find a westward sea route to the Spice Islands to avoid going through the eastern sea territories of Portugal. Charles Ⅰ gave Magellan his blessing and sent him off. He started with a total of 5 ships and 270 men, he first sailed to Brazil then down the coastline of South America to Patagonia. In Patagonia, an attempt at mutiny ended up destroying one of their ships. The continued on none the less with four ships. They then reached what is now called the Strait of Magellan, which is a passageway through the tip of South America. During this time, one of the ship masters left and traveled back to Spain. With only three ships left Magellan and his crew sailed on. In March of 1521, they dropped the anchor in Guam. Later in 1521, they reached the island of Homonhom, off the coast of the Philippines. Magellan at this point only had 150 of the original 270 men left. Magellan traded with the island king, Rajah Humabon. They had formed a bond. Soon after the Spanish became involved in a war between the people of Homonhon and a nearby island. In April of 1521 Magellan was killed in

In the letter that Christopher Columbus wrote to Luis de Santangel regarding the results of his first voyage in 1493 demonstrated several problems in Columbus’ breakthroughs, aside from his comprehension of what he uncovered. When interpreting the letter, I observed Columbus’ egotism. He appeared to be providing admiration to the King and Queen of Spain, but in actuality, he was only bragging about his own accomplishments. Columbus composes, “Since I know that you will be pleased at the great victory with which Our Lord has crowned my voyage, I write this to you, from which you will learn how in thirty-three days I passed from the Canary Islands to the Indies, with the fleet which the most illustrious king and queen, our sovereigns, gave to me. There I found very many islands, filled with people innumerable, and of them all I have taken possession for their highnesses, by proclamation made and with the royal standard unfurled, and no opposition was offered to me.” In this situation, Columbus tells of his outcomes from the expedition and communicates what it encompassed, and how it was proficient.

This leads to scrutiny amid accusations of Magellan packing his crew with Portuguese, but after some concessions from both sides the Armada is ready to

The Battle of Manila Bay was a singular demonstration of the daring and decisive application of sea power. In a few hours, Dewey had eliminated any threat that the Spanish Navy might pose to U.S. Far Eastern commerce and placed Spain's centuries-long rule of the Philippines in great jeopardy. A few days later, with the capture of Cavite arsenal, he also gained a repair and refueling base, essential for maintaining his squadron under wartime conditions thousands of miles from home.