Is The Community In The Giver A Dystopia?

The community in The Giver is also not a utopia because without choice you can not have goals and therefore have nothing to strive for, and life can become very boring. In The Giver the people that live in the community have no choices. They cannot choose their own jobs and they cannot see color which limits their choices. Without such choices the

The Giver is considered as a dystopian society because everyone is under the illusion that there is freedom. An example of this is when the text states, “you're ready for the pills, that's all. That’s the treatment for the stirrings.” They can't even have independent thoughts. Medication is given to prevent

Dystopia. A place where everything is imperfect and unpleasant.That's exactly where the main character of the book, The Giver by Lois Lowry, lives. Jonas grows up in a locked community. There is no freedom and the rules are completely insane. Since Jonas is the Receiver Of Memory, he can notice how badly the residents of the community are getting treated. In the book The Giver, the world is a plain dystopia. From extremely strict rules to life of sameness, Jonas lives life through it all.

The book The Giver is a neat book. We all know some of us cry when reading or watching The Giver. The Giver takes place in a little society with so many rules. I mean who goes and killed babies and old people (evil). The Giver utopia or dystopia? In my opinion I think the giver is a dystopia because you will have no choices, you will go through pain and if you become a nurturer you will kill babies.

The reasons The Giver is a dystopian society is due to, them getting their memories erased, them all being equal, also them all getting assigned jobs when they are only 12. The reasons this makes it a dystopian society is that 18 years old can barely handle their own jobs, how to 12-year-olds do the same, or better. Being equal makes everyone in their society have limits to things that they want to do. In The Giver, you have no memories, which makes it limitless like having everyone being equal. The Giver is a good choice of a book for the sixth graders to read because we know the world can never be a

What is a utopia? A utopia is a perfect place or true paradise, but is it even possible? Lois Lowry’s novel The Giver introduces a Utopian community, a place with no war and no pain. However, as the novel progresses, it is shown that the community actually has many downsides. For instance, the citizens of the community are unaware of what actually goes on around them since things are kept from them by the community leaders. Jonas and many others do not know that “release” means euthanasia which shows that the people are kept in the dark, which is not a characteristic of a utopian society. The community described in The Giver is not a utopia, but a dystopian society because citizens have no rights, there is no individuality and citizens can

Everybody has a different opinion on a utopian and dystopian society, Jonas’s has a little of both.However, some things are alike some are also different.While modern society is similar in some ways to Jonas’s society, the differences in birthdays, jobs, and mourning death reveal how different people have differences preferences for a dystopian and utopian society.

Wouldn’t it be great to live somewhere where everything is perfect? Well that's what Jonas’s community in The Giver wants to be. Many people believe it is a utopia, but it is quite the opposite. The community is a dystopia because they slaughter all of the citizens, restrict knowledge, and constantly watch them through surveillance cameras.

In the novel The Giver, based on the paragraphs we already read, we can already get the main picture that the book portrayed the community as a society that plans out how someone’s life is going to start and end and what they will do as a profession and when they will do it. There are good reasons to argue about assigning a job for everyone based on what they already excel on and what they are good at because many people wouldn’t prefer getting a chosen job that suits them for their strengths and weaknesses.

The book the Giver, by Lois Lowry, is about a community that has no feelings, does not experience pain, and doesn’t know anything about the outside world. The community that this book takes place in is a Utopia. I think this for three main reasons. Those reasons are: everyone in the community shares their feelings, they don’t have to pick their own jobs, and they don’t feel pain.

What would you do if you didn’t have any choices? To never feel what it is like to love, or to have freedom? In The Giver a boy named Jonas lives in a futuristic community, and faces this everyday. But living in his community was never that bad until… at the ceremony of Twelves, he gets his assignment as the new Receiver and his life changes drastically. He meets this man who he calls the Giver transmits memories--of things that have been and happened in the past-- to Jonas, learning extraordinary things he would have never dreamed of, but also very frightening things, especially about his community. Some things that may have made The Giver community more positive is being less controlling, having choices, and love.

As George Orwell said “Until they become conscious they will never rebel, and until after they have rebelled they cannot be conscious.” In the book The Giver everything is different, they are controlled, and have no emotions. In the modern day you can choose who you love, and choose what you do. The society in The Giver has very few similarities compared to our society today; however, there are many more differences that set them apart.

The Dystopian Society Does the book The Giver by Lois Lowry sound familiar? This story is about a society that enforces many strict rules based on the traces of what happened before the rules even existed. Another reason strict rules apply in the community is because they prefer to be utopian. However, the society in the Giver is dystopian because they release new born children for no reason, they erase all memories, and rules are secretly broken.

The community in the giver is a utopia because there is no weapons,no violence,and people are nurtured.

The citizens of the community live every moment of their lives monitored by the government. Their grades in school, what they do in their spare time, even what they do in their own “homes.” All of it is carefully monitored and documented. All of this makes sense though, at least for a totalitarian government. In order to maintain the dystopian society in which they have built, they must monitor each and everybody’s lives.