preview

Is Venezuela a Democracy? Essay

Decent Essays

Opinions about the state of democratic governance in Venezuela during the government of President Hugo Chávez Frías have been polarized. Some critics come close to labeling it a dictatorship while others, his supporters, claim to be restoring a truly democratic regime to Venezuela. Venezuelan society is polarized along political lines and this climate does not help to consolidate liberal democracy. In such a context, it is easy to fall into simplistic, black and white views; however, it is important to seek a more gradual and balanced appreciation of the complex issues at play. There also should be an understanding of how Venezuelans themselves view the state of their democracy. Assessments of the functioning of democracy should also take …show more content…

While international monitors have endorsed the results of recent elections, they have also raised concerns over the lack of transparency of the electoral institutions, specifically of the National Electoral Council (CNE) (“Country Report: Venezuela”). In the events surrounding the controversial August 2004 recall referendum, the CNE came to conduct business along party lines, with pro-Chávez members consistently outvoting opposition-aligned members by three to two. Since then, the composition of the CNE has become even more pro-government, with Chávez supporters holding four of the five seats. This clear domination of a key electoral institution increases the chances that election rules will be made and interpreted in ways that favor Chávez and his allies at the expense of the opposition.
However, the elections have not been stolen; the international community has confirmed that no foul play has occurred in these controversial elections. The irregularities that have been denounced by the opposition have been viewed by international observers as indiscretions that have not affected outcomes. Indeed, the Carter Center and the OAS both deemed valid the results of the hotly contested August 2004 recall referendum, won by President Hugo Chávez Frías with 59 percent of the vote.
Participation rights are also a key component to ensuring the position of democracy. Groups should

Get Access