preview

Israel American Identity

Decent Essays

At first glance, it seems that the differences between Israel and the United States of America run deeper than water. Despite its size, Israel is constantly the target of hate and criticism. As a country with a strong Army, Israel has to constantly defend itself and justify its actions to the world. The USA, who has always been an ally to Israel, is at the top of the social food chain, reigning over the world. The two nations, although different, exhibit the same political and ideological shifts in views and beliefs. Films are a strong medium to explore and demonstrate the evolution of a society's identity. The films act as a sort of mirror through which a society can explore its mythologies, ideas, and identity. The mirror reflects the social …show more content…

Barns, who is, by all means, a bad man, has a distorted face. This face represents the Military journey that led him to what he is when he kills Elias. This event leaves the Taylor defenceless and fatherless, a common narrative in Israeli film. This renders that all soldiers are a pawn, a victim, in the game played by the commanders, each commander doing his best to win the next round, and loose as little players as he possibly can. The abandonment the soldiers experience in Israeli films is a common theme in the American films, as seen in Elia’s death. Furthermore, the American film Platoon draws a concise line between the feeling of abandonment and the moral choices the commanders make. If Barns had not tried to kill Elias, it is possible that the shift in Taylor’s perception of war would not be as seen in the film. The loss of a guiding hand in both American and Israeli cinema is also responsible for the soldiers taking responsibility and trying to grow in the limits they are given. It is imperative to remember that the commanders of the Army are executing plans rather than making them. The politicians who make the plans of action are seen in both American and Israeli film as narcissistic, irresponsible

Get Access