preview

Japan 's New International History

Decent Essays

Louise Young in her introduction to the AHR forum, “Japan’s New International History,” identifies two waves of scholarship on Japanese imperial history, from the 1960s emphasis on the state’s role to the emergent socio-cultural turn in the recent two decades. The extension of the new paradigm also blurs the national and cultural boundaries in mapping out Japan’s modern history in a global frame. Susan Burns’ article, “Constructing the National Body: Public Health and the Nation in Nineteenth-Century Japan,” which looks at the tension between the state and the popular over the regulation of the body in the early Meiji period, can be considered the new scholarship that concerns less about the institutional explanation but more about …show more content…

The strengths of Burns’ study lie in that first, it has a crystal clear structure. She carefully crafts out her argument that the mass had different thoughts on the body as a national subject by presenting the state-level discourses and practices first. This naturally leads to the second part of the article, in which she questions with the assumption that the process of constructing the national body by the Meiji state received no resistance from the people. To further examine the local response to the state and the coherence between their visions of rendering individual bodies as public and national, Burns turns to two diseases which she thinks embedded popular discourses that intersected with not only nationalist one but also sexual and gender roles. This is where another strength lies. She is able to substantiate her arguments with abundant cultural sources like newspapers, memoirs, medicine journals, and fiction, and able to . By relating some historical events to the struggle of the position of the body, such as the Soma Incident, Burns indeed presents a diverse picture of the popular contestation in response to the state. However, there are problems as well. First, the title seems somewhat off the point in the sense

Get Access