preview

Jehovah Witnesses And Abortion Analysis

Decent Essays
Open Document

Christianity has over 2 billion adherents and 6 million who are actively practising (BBC, 2014).
Philosophers Rene Descartes and St Augustine of Hippo would disapprove of abortion in the modern day and this will be discussed in relation to Jehovah Witnesses and that religion’s opposition to abortion. This assignment will explore how the Jehovah Witness religion views abortion with referral to divergent opinion, and how the philosophers would support Witnesses in their view to abortion.

Rene Descartes has become known as the “modern father of philosophy” (Thune, 2011). Descartes theorised ‘mind- body dualism,’ where the mind body impact each other. Descartes said “I think, therefore I am,” which means that if one can think and do, they are …show more content…

He philosophised original sin and about evil and free will. Original sin is the teaching that everyone is born sinful and with a desire to disobey God, as a consequence of Adam and Eve’s actions in the Garden of Eden (Genesis 3). The effect of original sin is damnation, where, until a person dies, that person will be distanced from God. There is possible redemption through baptism. According to Augustine, original sin explains the “presence of sin in human history” (genocide, war, cruelty, exploitation, abuse) (Class notes, August 8 2015). This means that evil has entered the world due to a disconnection with God. The reasons for evil according to Augustine is that God is not present in all things and that evil only happens because of God’s distance from material reality Class notes, August 8 2015). Augustine stated, “God is always trying to give good things to us, but our hands are too full to receive them.” This purports that humans are too distracted by the materialistic to fully accept God into their lives. Also, people have the free will to live ‘Godly’ lives, but individuals can also choose evil by giving into the pursuit of worldly pleasure, therefore, being less like God. Additionally, humans cannot take all the credit for when they do good, but take all the blame if they do evil. Augustine philosophised about original sin and its occurrence through evil being present in the world, this …show more content…

According to the Australian Government, abortion is “the termination (end) of a pregnancy” (2015). In Australia, each state and territory have different laws regarding abortion. In Queensland, under sections 224, 225 and 226 of legislation, abortion is illegal under the criminal code, however; it may be regarded as lawful if performed to prevent serious danger to the woman’s physical or mental health (does not include economic or social pressure) (CCAI, 2015). 65% of Australians are strongly opposed to abortion (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2013) on the basis that it is murder. Tere is much divergence of opinion surrounding the issue. Reproductive Choice Australia supports women’s choice of abortion as a “right to bodily and psychological integrity, which includes the right… to make decisions concerning reproduction” (RCA, 2015). This means that women should be and are able to make decisions surrounding their own body and needs. Additionally, they state that abortion is not murder as “"personhood" is an epiphenomenon of the human brain... it should be clear that if there is no fully functional brain, and then there is no personhood” (RCA, 2015). Implying that abortion cannot be viewed as murder because the foetus has no operative brain. Abortion is a debated topic throughout Australia and there is much divergence of opinion surrounding the

Get Access