preview

Johnny Cade Research Paper

Decent Essays
Open Document

Johnny Cade did not kill unlawfully and also he can’t apply for a minor committing the crime because he’s 16, one year over the limit. According to Oklahoma law, first-degree murder is a person “unlawfully and with malice aforethought causes the death of another human being.” It is also not manslaughter because it is not a homicide committed without a design to effect death and in the heat of passion, but in a cruel and unusual manner, or by means of a dangerous weapon. Johnny did not have time to think and had to stab Bob to save Ponyboy’s life. Ponyboy was being drowned and to save him, Johnny had to commit the act of homicide. It lists that it was a justifiable homicide because it means that homicide is legal when committed in the lawful …show more content…

Johnny had to kill Bob to save Ponyboy because there was no other way around. He couldn’t have stopped them because they were drunk and looking for a fight. (pg 44 and 55) He couldn’t have fought them without a weapon because it would have been a one on five.(pg 55) He had to stab Bob to make them stop because they wouldn’t have run away. They would have drowned Ponyboy.(pg 56 and 57) To save himself and his friend, the defendant had to stab Bob. It made them scared and run away because they had the sole thought of harming both of them so Johnny had to act fast before he was going to be killed along with Ponyboy. Additionally, he did not commit first-degree homicide because he didn’t plan to kill Bob. When he saw Bob earlier, he didn’t attempt to kill rather, he tried to hide from him. (pg 44) He didn’t pull it out when the socs came to them originally. (pg 54 and 55) He chose to try to resolve it peacefully but that didn’t work because David grabbed Ponyboy.”(pg 55) They forced his hand and he had to stab Bob in order to save himself and Ponyboy otherwise Pony would have drowned in the fountain and Johnny would have been dead too. In conclusion, Johnny did not commit a first-degree

Get Access