preview

June Johnson Illegal Immigration Analysis

Good Essays

Immigration:
A Discussion with No End
The issue of illegal immigration has become a major debate for everyone. June Johnson wrote “Crossing Borders: Immigration” in her book Global Politics, Local Arguments to introduce the topic of undocumented immigrants in the U.S expanding and the measures that the government has taken to solve the problem. In Chapter 4, Johnson presented Victor Davis Hanson, who wrote “Illegal Immigration Is Immoral” to expose how the proposals to fix illegal immigration has lost all moral credibility. Krishnadev Calamur wrote “What Trump’s Executive Order on Immigration Does-and Doesn’t Do.” on Jan 30, 2017 in The Atlantic to expose the impact that Trump’s Executive Order 1187 to ban the citizens of seven Majority-Muslim …show more content…

Johnson has a sub header, Student Voice, in each chapter that gives a real-life example of what she is trying to get across, where she included “La Migra”, where Esperanza Borboa reflects on her work experience at a garment factory in California and with farm workers in Washington state. She observed the exploitation of undocumented immigrants, including employers making anonymous calls for immigration raids before pay day and even refusing to pay those who returned. Hanson gave his point of view from all different aspects-the entry-level labor, ethnic chauvinism, legal immigrants, the law, Mexico, poverty, moral racketeering, and politics. For example, the Political reason describes how a politician would handle immigration and the effect that it would have in their career if they were to communicate something and it comes out as offensive (158). Therefore, illegal immigration has an immense impact in America because various people have different views about the …show more content…

hoping to get a chance at a better life; others are refugees escaping persecution and civil wars in their home country. Krishnadev Calamur wrote about Donald Trump’s Executive Order 1187 and how Donald Trump had made it his goal to ban all Muslims from the start of his campaign and seeing that those countries were in Barack Obama’s visa-waiver program he took advantage and used it to ban all seven countries (5). The grand result of this ban ended in people coming together to protest at several airports across the country where people with valid documentation were detained. This ban had a great impact that a multitude of citizens, lawyers, demonstrators, and the media descended to witness the order’s impact, but Trump tried to dismiss the reality of the impact by tweeting, “Only 109 people out of 325,000 were detained and held for questioning.” (15), when it was a lot more than that. The S. 2458 introduced n Senate mentions, “To amend section 217(a) (12) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, relating to the restriction of the use of the Visa Waiver Program for aliens who travel to certain countries.” (3). This demonstrates what Hanson and Johnson have been trying to present; that there is no humane way of handling undocumented immigrants and that the day when government has made it possible to fix this problem is far from being created

Get Access