preview

Juvenile Court Case Study

Decent Essays
Open Document

In the Juvenile Case #1, the client suspected of burglarizing and murdering the elderly lady should be tried in a Juvenile Court rather Adult court which would be in the best interest of the child. To begin with, the client has no juvenile delinquent record and had minimal behavioral issues in the Juvenile Hall, which aids to their side since they have a clean history and this is the first record of criminal behavior. With this in mind, it is plausible for the minor to change to become a better civilian through rehabilitation which is made possible by the Juvenile court. The client has proved their ability to improve themselves by earning a high school diploma and attending voluntary treatment programs which shows the success of the juvenile …show more content…

The suspect was only 14 years old when placed into custody, where they are young enough to still be considered an adolescent and don’t know right from wrong. For a young client that was born addicted to meth and abandoned at birth, they must have a poor mental and emotional state that exists within them. Without having a biological mother or father figure in their life, they lack guidance in identifying what is wrong and what is right and what the consequences of their actions are due to the poor parental supervision they were exposed to while growing up. Alongside, the lack of parental support and supervision while growing up the minor is proven to suffer from psychological disorders such as ADHD, insomnia, and anti-social tendencies which affects their mental and emotional health. With the client having no gang ties or association, this greatly increases the likelihood that they will rehabilitate since they carry no ties with other gang members or criminals. Next, the minor did not originally have the intent to stab and murder the elderly lady before entering the home. As the client retrieved a deadly kitchen knife from inside the house, rather than bringing their own weapon shows how this was not a planned premeditated murder. This proves that a rather spontaneous and unpredicted action was committed by the juvenile that could have been triggered by their poor mental and emotional state. In the end, due to the minimal degree of criminal sophistication that exists in the minor they should be initiated under the juvenile court

Get Access