preview

Kevin Curran's 'Feeling Criminal In Macbeth'

Decent Essays

In the article “Feeling Criminal in Macbeth” by Kevin Curran, the author explains that the character Macbeth, from Macbeth by William Shakespeare that “Macbeth’s murderous thoughts are shaped by physical, sensual interaction with the objects of the material world” (Curran). The author is attempting to prove that the murder of King Duncan “was a sensible crime not because its practical or judicious (it’s neither), but because it’s born of the senses and experienced as sensation” (Curran). The character Macbeth in the play Macbeth gets a prophesy from three witches which state that Macbeth is “Thane of Cawdor” and “king here-after”. The prophesy sends Macbeth into a state that he feels the need that he has to try and fulfill these statements …show more content…

In either case, the dagger, to the extent that it exists at all, exists as and through sensation” (Curran). I do agree with this point in that his sense of sight is causing him to perceive the dagger but soon after this statement Currans says that the dagger is not a product of the mind but is a product of the eye perception I do not agree with that because the mind, body, and senses work together so it would have to be a combination of the three. “I see thee still, / And on thy blade and dudgeon, gouts of blood, / Which was not so before. / There is no such thing” (2.1 57-59) this quote shows the Macbeth was seeing the blood on the dagger and after a while is mind realized that there was no blood on the dagger he was just seeing …show more content…

His wife was also brought into the whole situation when he confided in her about killing Duncan, after the murder of Duncan, Lady Macbeth also went insane, Macbeth brought a doctor in to try and heal her, when the doctor told Macbeth the she could not be healing because it was mental, Macbeth did not believe him and wanted a physical way to cure her. His said, “Cure[her] of that. / Canst thou minister to a mind diseased…” (5.3 49-50) Macbeth is not sane in this part because he believes that she can be heal he doesn’t believe that her mind is ill. Curran talks about Lady Macbeth as that she was not involved in the actual murder but because she was told about it she also went mentally insane like Macbeth did. In the article “Feeling Criminal in Macbeth” by Kevin Curran his claim is that Macbeths crimes were sensible and were experienced sensations. Yes, I do agree that Macbeth experienced the sensations of seeing things and feeling thing I do not agree that Macbeth was aware of what he was doing. Curran states that Macbeth was feeling criminal which I take that means that he knows he was doing these action and that he was in the right state of mind but I do not agree with that I think after the witches told him the prophesy he went insane and was corrupted by the thought of

Get Access