preview

Kwame Appiah's Analysis

Decent Essays

“…those differences that most deeply affect us in our dealings with each other-are not to any significant degree biologically determined.” (Appiah 35). Kwame Appiah makes it crystal clear in this chapter that he does consider biological explanations of race as a legitimate explanation. He is very critical of the way that W.E.B DuBois viewed race. He spends the entire chapter laying out DuBois’ views on race just to illustrate how and why he disagrees with DuBois’ perspective. Through critiquing DuBois’ arguments, Appiah slowly showcases his perspective of race, which is that it has no biological or sociohistorical foundation. Kwame Appiah compares the classification of people into racial groups to the classification of books using the Dewy Decimal System. He illustrates that where a book is placed in a library tells you very little about the book. Will the book interesting? Does it contain reliable sources? Did scholars write the book? The Dewy Decimal System doesn’t answer any of those questions. By using this metaphor, he showcases how ridiculous using arbitrary observable characteristic such as skin color, hair length, eye color, are in forcing …show more content…

DuBois claimed that race is essentially a vast family of people with common blood and a common historical experience (29). DuBois himself professed to disagree with the scientific notion of race, but Appiah notes that his sociohistorical view of race actually embraces the scientific notion. Appiah goes on to say that science has proven that the chances are higher of two people from different races being genetically similar than it is for two people of the same race (35). Here Appiah makes it clear that he does not believe race has anything to do with biology and that humans need to transcend the concept of race in order to advance society as a

Get Access