preview

Land Reform Dbq

Decent Essays

Source A is reliable but does not fully support the assertion. Source A, taken from a British-based research in 1997, intends to show how Mao’s preventive healthcare measures improved the peasants’ quality of life but “sparrowcide” had resulted in people having lesser grain as they were eaten by insects.

Source A states that Mao had implemented the measures such as “basic healthcare and preventive services”, closing brothels and running campaigns against opium use to bring diseases and vices under control. However, by eradicating the sparrows in the Four Pests Campaign, “the insects ... now devoured the grains instead”. Source A is reliable as it corroborates with my contextual knowledge. Mao’s health reforms taking place in the form of …show more content…

Source B is a primary source based on the observations of a Communist correspondent that objectively reported on the success of Mao’s land reform. From the source, we can infer that Mao’s land reform was not well-accepted among the people as they feared the plausible punishments of having successful crop production. .

Source B states that “peasants look with a suspicious eye” and they “have no desire to become well-to-do through production efforts”. These descriptions of the peasants’ behaviour and attitude towards Mao’s land reform illustrates how the peasants were wary and distrustful of the government’s motives. Source B is unreliable as it does not corroborate with contextual knowledge. The land reform was popular among peasants In their Mutual Aid teams, they would work on each other’s land, fertilising, killing pests or harvesting so that each family’s plot would become more productive. The government supplied extra fertiliser and tools to reward families who grew more food. Therefore, peasants were more inclined to adhere to the reform and produce more in order to reap the monetary benefits of doing so. Hence, Source B is unreliable and opposes the

Get Access