preview

Langston Hughes Untold Truths About The American Revolution

Decent Essays

Langston Hughes wrote a story about his memory of getting saved during a revival service at his aunt’s church. Howard Zinn wrote about a much broader topic, the American Revolution. On the surface, these two readings don’t seem to have anything in common. However, both stories focus on the theme of bullying and have other similarities. The differences between the stories are more important than the similarities. Overall, Salvation is a more believable story of bullying, but Untold Truths About the American Revolution seems to be Zinn’s rewrite of events leading to the war.
Langston Hughes’s personal narrative and Howard Zinn’s essay are comparable in several ways. Since the bullies are more powerful than their victims in both stories, they …show more content…

The most obvious contrast is the point of view in which each story is told. Hughes’s story is written in first person while Zinn’s essay is written in third person. The reader can feel what Hughes experienced personally while reading the story whereas the anger Zinn is conveying in his article is about an issue he had no stake in. This difference is important because Hughes didn’t just choose to make up a story and tell it in first person. He went through what he wrote about, but Zinn wrote about something that happened over two hundred years ago. The bullies in Salvation were people who knew each other personally in contrast to the large groups of people in Untold Truths About the American Revolution. Hughes’s bullies were his aunt, the preacher, and other grownups, people he had been raised to trust. He wrote, “I had heard a great many old people say the same thing and it seemed to me they ought to know” (7). Zinn stereotypes all of the Founding Fathers and rich men as bullies. The victims in both stories also differ. Langston and the other children in his church were victims, so they had even less power than the poor men, slaves, and Indians who Zinn believes were the victims in Untold Truths About the American Revolution. The end results also vary from each other. On one hand Hughes did not believe in Jesus anymore, and he felt disappointed in himself; another result in Salvation could be that Langston might have become distrustful of religion and/or authority figures. While on the other hand Zinn thinks not everyone benefited from war, and we might have fought a war that did not need to be fought. Zinn even has several sections on how each group did not benefit from the war. A result of the Revolution that Zinn did not highlight was that the colonists definitely won their independence. Finally the blame in both stories is different. Even though the bullies made

Get Access