During our class discussion, we talked about one of the readings that were assigned that week. The reading was Letter to Madame Christina of Lorraine by Galileo. We were split into groups of three and we had to discuss part of the reading that we thought was interesting. Our group decided to pick the second paragraph, because it shows how if one is close minded and stuck in their beliefs, it would be very difficult to convince them of anything other than what their beliefs already are, even if there is concrete evidence to say otherwise. We believe that this is a great paragraph at explaining that there are different types of people in the world consisting of science, religion, or both, that will either accept an idea or would not consider
Galileo might be the most famous person in the development of astronomy. He is famous, not only because of the amazing work he did to advance Copernican theory of heliocentrism, but also because of the controversy that surrounded him. Using new methods and instruments, he provided compelling new evidence to support Copernican theory. He also contributed to the development of theories of physics that could account for the movements of bodies in new terms. His observations of the movements of objects in the heavens required different explanations than the old ideas about the heavens. It required him, and others, to begin to understand the reasons to explain these new observations. His efforts to publicize his findings was met by
There will always be a battle between religion and science, it is a truth universally acknowledged. Galileo attempted to make the two compatible by suggesting that the truth can only be sought out if the notion under consideration can be accurately tested and if the opposing view can be founded as false. Galileo’s goes into depth about the truth of scripture and the sciences, intertwined with the reason of man, in his letter to Christina of Lorraine, Grand Duchess of
Dava Sobel, an experienced science writer, has written many books about historical figures of science. She has been a New York Times science reporter and a contributor to many other magazines and publications. She has authored or co-authored multiple prize-winning books.
Furthermore, in discussing the conflict between the Church and scientists such as Galileo, it must be noted that both parties held themselves to be unquestionably correct in the argument, because they both based themselves in what they believed to be irrefutable truth. The Church viewed the holy
Well, it is really hard to our selves in the same situation as Galileo was in. First of all, we cannot even imagine, in today’s world of democracy, how it would be to be afraid to express your thoughts and ideas espiecially that the Earth is not flat! Sounds really apsurd if you think about it. If I knew that prior to me several people were killed because of this crazy idea and thought I would probably step away from it as well. On the other hand, I have never been that obsesed and intriged by anything to give my life away for it (family doesn’t count). Most likeliy, I would just leave a writing about it and try to spread it out that way so that there isn’t a straight link to me and my work. Galileo probably recanted because he was afraid of Chruch and what could happen to him. Back in those days Church wasn’t anything similar to what we are used to
“Men who were grounded in astronomical and physical science were persuaded as soon as they received my first message…” (30). Others took longer to come to terms with Galileo’s work due to how different it was from what they had come to believe. And, some were so stuck in their ways that they refused to look at the evidence and denied the truth at all cost.
Galileo was a coward Galileo was an Italian natural philosopher, astronomer, and mathematician, who made fundamental contributions to the sciences of motion, astronomy and strength of materials and to the development of the scientific method. His discoveries with the telescope changed astronomy and paved the way for the acceptance of the copernican Heliocentric system. Galileo, using his own telescope he discovered that the moon has mountains and creators. Galileo found a new position at the university of Padua, teaching geometry, mechanics, and astronomy.
New scientific discoveries not only enhanced man’s comfort in life but also his appreciation of human potential and reason. It was becoming increasingly evident that it was to man’s benefit to reason and understand. With this realization came the need to determine the proper place of human reasoning in man’s life. The philosophies of the early post-Reformation period dealt with this issue—how to relate and balance faith and reason. Gone was the blind, unquestioning faith of the medieval period. Men were now free to doubt and deny. Those who believed in Christ and His claims found themselves increasingly shifting to a defensive stance and trying to accommodate human reason.
In this chapter Dixon the author, explain how knowledge is aquire. According to the author, the rational behind Galileo case was to find out the clear knowledge of observing nature and what one beliefs in the scripture. The author in his opinion, stated that knowledge of nature is aquire from four sources; “our sense, our power of rational thought, others testimony and our memory.” He admitted that these four sources of knowledge are not reliable as it can deceive us. Unless these sources are back by evidence, series of reasonable experiments, observations of things from the outcome and devices used, they are not accepted. The author mention that some natural philosophers and scientific advocates,
In the seventeenth century, the idea that the world was geocentric, the idea that the planets and sun revolved around the earth, was being refuted by those who seeked to prove the heliocentric model, the idea that the sun was the center of the universe. In 1614, Galileo wrote a letter to Grand Duchess Christina where he explained that his idea that the earth was moving around the sun was not necessarily falsifying the Bible. About one year later, Cardinal Robert Bellarmine would also write a letter, his was to one of Galileo’s followers and it explained why the Church so heavily refuted Galileo’s idea. These letters gave the opinions of these esteemed men, one who wanted his idea to be understood and not as against the Church, and the other
Through the use of the two quotes by Galileo and Pope John Paul II, Postman proposes that the use of religion and science can provide the bases for morality and human improvement should one be free from dogmatic judgement towards religion or science. Postman further emphasizes this common theme present in the quotes by juxtaposing the two figures, Galileo being an important contributor to the fields of science and Pope John Paul II holding one of the highest positions in the Catholic Church, the two figures of which are almost antithetical to each other given their roles. Following the essay’s theme of religion and the new age of information being similar through the use of blind faith, this juxtaposition further accentuates the religion/science
Great film and very interesting. The 17th century falls into the early modern period of Europe, the beginning of modern science and philosophy, including Galileo's constributions. Galileo Galilei was an Italian astronomer who lived in the 17th century. He was a very intelligent man who is connected to many important discoveries. He discovered extraordinary facts about space and gravity. Galileo used modern technology to study the world around him. He searched for truth based on scientific methods of logic and observation.
The still-standing aqueducts, bathhouses, and other public works of both ancient republic and empire testify to the engineering and architectural skills of the Romans. The rebirth of science during the Renaissance brought the daring speculations of Leonardo da Vinci (including discoveries in anatomy, meteorology, geology, and hydrology, as well as a series of fascinating though ultimately impractical designs for a "flying machine"). The scientist Galilei Galileo also called as the first modern scientist. Galileo’s achievement includes improving the telescope, various astronomical observations, and initial formulation of the first and second laws of motion. Although Galileo is suppressed by the Catholic Church, but he was the founder of modern
Firstly, Galileo’s purpose of the letter was to discourage the church from accusing Copernicus’s De Revolutionbus in 1543 with heresy. The church, in desperation to defend itself from this new “science”, resorted to the Bible for protection (Moss, 1983). The church used literal interpretations of the bible such as the support of “earth-centered” system for selfish motives as demonstrated in the passage “They say that since theology is the queen of sciences, she need not bend in any way to accommodate herself to the teachings of the less worthy sciences” (Halsall, 1997, p. 8), as it was the duty of the church to ignore such speculations against theology.
for people to accept. But when the actual facts are looked at it is very easy