Limited Democracy Vs Athenian Democracy

In Athen, “Schools taught reading, writing, and mathematics, music, poetry, sport, and gymnastics”. In Sparta, “Boys were taken from parents at age seven and trained in the art of warfare. They were only given a cloak - no shoes or other clothes, and not enough food so they had to steal (to learn survival skills)”. Overall, I think Athens is better and safer to live in then Sparta.

Sparta was known in Greek as Sparti. The city lied at the southern end of the central Laconia plain, on the right bank of the Eurotas River. Its population was about 100,000 and it was located in the Laconia region. It had a fairly temperate but very dry climate. Sparta’s also depended on agriculture for their sustenance. They had a mandatory military service. Their system of leadership was Oligarchic and their descendants were mostly the descendants of the Dorian invaders. Athens, on the other hand, was the largest capital city of Greece. Its citizens were about 140,000. The region in which Athens was situated was Attica. The city of Athens had a Mediterranean climate. Athenians depended on trade and agriculture for survival. They did not have a military based system. They practiced Democracy and their descendants were mostly from Ionian descent. (Diffen, n.d).

Athenian democracy focuses on economic advancement, while Sparta oligarchy focuses on military force. Democracy is a system of government where the citizens have the right to vote, whereas the oligarchy is when a group of people is in control of the government and it’s only their opinion and decision that are taken to consideration. Implicating the thesis that people are better served by Athenian democracy than the Spartan oligarchy, which is supported by three evidence points. Firstly, the Athenian citizen's participation in government, by voting and taking part in the government position.Secondly, the Athenian men are provided with better education by being taught how to read and write, not only focused on military training. Lastly, the Athens advancement in military protection for the safety of its citizens.

If I were to choose between Athens or Sparta to live in, I would choose Sparta. Respect is something that is demanded strongly by most people, only to those holding the desire to be equal and is something that should be shared among all. The Spartan’s have that respect, they are raised to respect their elders, women, and warriors. Furthermore, the Spartans offer education to both boys and girls. While boys are taken from their parents at age 7 they are taught the ways of war, girls are taught the basic skills of reading, writing, and also the necessities to survive and protect their city. In addition, women are given better opportunities in Sparta over the Athens. Women are given the chance to receive an education, ability to participate in

Ancient Athens was not truly democratic because out of the 240,235 Total Population only 12% were able to vote. rule was exercised directly by the people, whereas democratic means government by representatives of the people. it was not democratic because in order to become a citizen a council of 500 voted on

The perception we have, it that Athens people was intellectual and devoted literature, arithmetics and the arts, giving us the most known philosophers of human history, such as Aristotle, Socrates, Plato, Xenophon. While Sparta gave us the most famous warriors including Lycurgus, the known founder of militaristic Sparta society and of course Leonidas, the brave, that lead an army of men to death against the Persians, in notorious Battle of the

People in Athens and Sparta like any other city-states, were participating in their own day to day activities of public life. Athenians had been followed democratic government and open culture compared to Sparta which had been followed a dictatorial government and warrior society.

Military, Women, Government, and Strength are just some of Sparta’s values. If given the choice to live in either Sparta or Athens, my choice would be Athens. Sparta has a better government, military, and take care of the Spartan women, unlike Athens.

In “Athens and Sparta” by Mr.Duckworth, he states,” Where they differed was while the Spartans had militaristic values, Athens was democratic.” This shows that Athens And Sparta were two very different places to live. Sparta would be the better place to live because your government would be ruled by smart people, the kings wouldn't be cruel, and women had a LOT more rights than other greek women.

In terms of geography, Athens and Sparta were both located in Greece, close to each other. They shared many similarities, however, there were also differences. The lifestyle in Sparta was very simple; they lived in the barracks or farms and they were not open to getting a good education. However, they were more focused on preserving military power by forcing their boys to join the army from a young age. In Athens, their boys continued schooling such as the arts or the sciences, but also had their father teaching them. When they were of age, they were given the right to vote and officially became a citizen. Furthermore, Athenian men were supposed

Athens people were dependent on trade to support their economy and Sparta led towards being dependent on the agriculture aspect. And these were there ways to bringing income. Both military armies were not well put for the two cities. Athens military was optional as for Sparta the military was completely a 360. The military was mandatory, as far the Sparta people it is known that as a young boy you were destine to

Each of mentioned types of forms of government in Ancient Greece has defiantly had its place and each had served its purpose, either by the mixture of assembly vote or one leader making decision for its city-state. It all depended on the size and complexity of the political influence and rivalry in a given place and time of Ancient

ancient Greece had many polis, the Athens and Sparta are two major polis of Greece. However,they took a different road, they are on the political ideology, economic development, cultural life and performance are different in many ways. Athens is a polis of democracy, it is democracy system of government, commerce and trade as the basis for statehood. Literary, artistic and scientific achievements, both of them are pioneer of Greek. However, Sparta was a Polis of Militarism,pursue militarism, founded on agriculture, emphasis on military training, the whole city is like a big camp.

During the early Classical era of Greece, Athens and Sparta harmonized peacefully until the middle of the 5th c. BCE. The political and cultural character of the two were immensely different. Sparta stood protected from external invasion and internal revolt of the helots by their powerful military. They were a closed society governed by an oligarchic government, where power effectively rests with a small number of people, and was led by two kings. Whereas Athens, had a Democratic government and flourished through commercial activities.

Athens and Sparta were both great city states one with power one with knowledge. however they have many differences and similarities. Spartans had the most powerful army in all of Greece at the time. Athens had the best schooling system in Greece. Sparta and Athens are both very similar and very different here's how.