Lincoln versus Douglas: One Man's Fall is Another Man's Rise Essay example

2094 Words9 Pages
Two men stepped onto a platform in front of hundreds of people; prepared for a battle of dialect, rhetoric and moral justification. The two adversaries differed in partisanship, political success, height, methods of Government action, and most of all morality of what is right. Although the candidates presented polar opposites visions for America, they were similar in their dynamic display of debating. Both men possessed eloquence in their speeches and disposition. The debates consisted of seven encounters throughout Illinois. After one-hundred and fifty years, the historical significance of the debates continues to provoke further debate amongst modern scholars to this day, in turn, solidifying their importance in American History. As I…show more content…
Jaffa refers to revisionist James Randall’s theories of Abraham Lincoln and Stephen Douglas, and then Drugmand, 2 presents a formulated and concrete argument to question Randall’s theories. Randall suggests a variety of baffling concepts concerning Abraham Lincoln’s incentives for the debates and radical views of extinguishing slavery . Allen Guelzo supports Jaffa’s perception of the debates as well as presents his own insight. In order to interpret the debates and gain better understanding the Davis and Wilson translation facilitates my comprehension of their intensity. Stephen Douglas entered politics as a strong Jacksonian Nationalist that supported the Union. Douglas joined the Democratic Party and quickly elevated his political position. One of his achievements occurred when he assisted Henry Clay in passing the Missouri Compromise of 1850. After four years and continuous rise in political standing, Douglas devised the Kansas-Nebraska Bill. The Bill opened further territory in the West for expansion. Able to benefit from expanding railroad transportation, he devised the Bill in a way that promoted Popular Sovereignty. He argued that slavery should be decided by local territory or state, and congress did not possess the right to mandate what is right for individual states. Within the Kansas-Nebraska Bill, his Popular Sovereignty allowed the new territories that lay

More about Lincoln versus Douglas: One Man's Fall is Another Man's Rise Essay example

Open Document