preview

Lisle's False-Consciousness

Decent Essays

Lisle's False-Consciousness Are opinions really owned by the people or are they formed by society as a way to control the populace? In M. Rickert’s “Evidence of Love in a Case of Abandonment”, the protagonist Lisle's perception of herself and the theocratic society she lives in is heavily molded by the bureaucratic authority governing her country. As strong minded as Lisle is, her opinions simply reflect the false-consciousness interpellated in her community and this demonstrates the power of a bureaucratic government upon the ideals of individuals. Lisle's comprehension of her beliefs, self-worth and identity are all instilled in her by the ruling class. Throughout the narrative, Lisle's personal righteous beliefs are displayed in her observations …show more content…

This idea however is simply the ideals of the society which wants to restrict women by only allowing them to be wives and mothers. Furthermore, Lisle has a distorted sense of social involvement. When considering her absence at executions, she expresses that "it's important to stay active in your community" (42) as if participation has a form of benefit to the co-inhabitants of her town. In reality, the executions are a display and not attending for several years produced no repercussions. This sense of communal contribution is instead a way to ensure that the people are witnessing the punishment for abortion and to prevent further illicit actions. Criminalising these women enforces the stigma that they are performers of evil and this is evidently deep-seated in Lisle. When she sees the "gaping maul" of an executed woman's head she does not consider it as a dead human being, but the place where the "evil thought was first conceived to destroy the innocent life that grew inside her" (44). This concept dehumanises the criminalised women and alienates them since they go against what is considered socially moral. Lisle's perceives her own self-worth as strictly based on her relation to one of …show more content…

When her father suggests that she may have a chance "to be a breeder" (43), she is disheartened as this means that she will not be able to raise her own children and not being a wife devalues her. In response she says "I hate mom" (43), showing how she blames her mother directly for putting her in this position. Lisle's devaluation of herself is however also conjoined with her devaluation of other women. When Lisle's mother finds the list of "baby names [she] was considering for when [her] time came" (41) it is notable that they are all male names. Lisle only hopes to give birth to boys in the future because she believes that they are more important than girls and in this way she devalues herself for being a girl. This comes from the government's attempts to keep the society patriarchal by only allowing men to have jobs and positions of power. Lisle also degrades herself to the value of a tool when she reflects on when her mother brought her home from executions. She described how her mother "[pressed her] head tight against her shoulder...so hard that [Lisle] started crying, which, [Lisle] now [realizes], served her purpose" (44). In this she realised that her mother used her crying to make a point to people attending the executions that it was upsetting to children even if

Get Access