Lord Of The Flies Jack Vs Ralph Essay

There are many standards that can demonstrate a good leader, such as integrity, accountability, respect, influence, and responsibility. Ralph demonstrates all of these qualities, while Jack does not demonstrate any of them. Because of this, Ralph is superior to Jack. Throughout the book Lord of the Flies, Ralph shows that he is superior countless times. The boys get stranded on an island during World War II and have to learn how to fend for themselves, since there are no adults.

By using their fear against the tribe, he makes them feel like Jack can protect them. Jack is very manipulative for that reason. Jack taunted Ralph into doing something with

He exploits the boys’ vulnerability by promising protection from the perceived threat, stating, “I'll keep the fire going and if I can't, there’ll be another thing. If I can't, I'll put some green branches on like that and then I'll light–” (Golding 92). Through such declarations, Jack creates a dependency on his leadership, fostering a false sense of refuge and control over the boys’. Jack asserts his authority by promising to maintain the fire, a symbol for safety and rescue stating, “I'll keep the fire going” (Golding 92).

Jack and Ralph were motivated for their actions in different ways. Ralph was motivated strictly by the hope of being rescued. Even though he called meetings and tried to organize the group of boys to do simple things like build huts or keep the fire going so they could be rescued or survive, the boys would go play or bathe. Ralph said to Jack ‘"And they keep running off, you remember the meeting? How everyone was going to work hard until the shelters were finished?" (51) The only person who would listen or work with Ralph was Simon. Unfortunately, the other boys continued to ignore Ralph's leadership throughout the novel and eventually all turned to Jack for leadership. Jack was motivated by hunting and killing. His obsession for this began when he was frustrated with himself for not killing the pig in the first chapter: ‘"He snatched his knife out of the sheath and slammed it into a tree trunk. Next time there would be no mercy" (29).There would actually be no mercy from Jack from that point on. Eventually all of the boys, except for Ralph and Piggy, turned to Jack's evil ways, even to the point of participating in the killing of Simon. Effectively, Ralph was motivated by the hope

This is why Ralph is a better leader because his priorities are better than Jacks also Jack only wants meat and Ralph wants to save them. On the other hand, Jack is a good leader because he makes people get things done and he is a good hunter. But Jack has anger issues and can't deal with his emotions and could lose his mind any time. Pg 20,chapter one, “Out of this face stared two light blue eyes, frustrated now and turning, or ready to turn to anger.’’ This sentence shows how jack is ready to blow up.

Ralph cares about everyone, not just some people or himself. Ralph was scared to go first on the ledge when the boy’s were searching for the beast. Jack was a hunter and he was scared to go on the ledge and Ralph knew, so Ralph decided to take over “I’m chief. I’ll go. Don’t argue” (p.155). Ralph knew that Jack was just as scared as he was, but he soon didn’t care what he himself was feeling. He knew that he could’ve made Jack go first, but he wanted to take the pressure off of him. When Jack and Roger captured Samneric, right after attempting to kill Ralph, Ralph still went back for them even if he was “Terrified that they would run and give the alarm (p.230).” Ralph wanted to make sure they were okay. Ralph was scared to go back for them, but he didn’t care. He just wanted to make sure they were alright even if it meant it might get him killed. Ralph symbolizes true civilization because he’s the only one who stayed civil, and he’s the only one left who wanted to actually get rescued and still had hope for

The novel " Lord of the Flies" focuses on the conflict that exists between two competing impulses that Golding, suggests exist within all humans; these being the instinct to follow the rules, act in a peaceful manner and comply to moral commands compared to the instinct to act violently in order to gain control over others and to satisfy our own greed and personal desires. The conflict exists within the novel in several forms; law and order vs. anarchy, civilization vs. savagery and the basic term of good vs. evil. Golding uses these themes consistently throughout the novel, clearly associating instinctive savagery with evil and the instinct of civilisation with good. The representation of this lies in Ralph and Jack, the two central

Are protagonistic and antagonistic characters considered to be juxtapositions, complimenting each other and highlighting the other’s flaws? Ralph and Jack are certainly protagonist and antagonist; Ralph as a strong, moral leader, and wither Jack representing savagery. Some may argue that while protagonists and antagonists may be opposites, that does not mean that they are complementary to each other. However, they are each so different from the other that their character traits are emphasized when around and interacting with one another. Golding uses symbols and diction to create a dramatic mood which conveys the idea that two opposite people will emphasize their best and worst character traits, impacting the world around them.

For the duration of Lord of the Flies, all the characters are faced with situations that require them to act in a civilized or savage way. The two characters that stick most with their way throughout the story are Ralph and Jack. Due to the fact that they are so different, these leaders that have a secluded rivalry. Every choice and movement represents which way of society Ralph and Jack stand for.

Jack wanted all the power to himself even from the beginning. He already had power of boys before the crash had happened. He didn’t want anyone to tell him he couldn’t do something or wasn’t allowed to. He always wanted to hunt without worrying about other responsibilities. “I was talking about smoke!

Jack is the opposite of Ralph. Instead of working toward good and helping each other out, the deserted island life gets to him and he becomes evil. He only wants to succeed and wants to wipe out anyone or anything that stands in his way. He reaches the level of complete insanity that he can’t even accept ideas other than his own in order to be rescued. Instead, he only fights with his personal goal in mind. Although he and Ralph are both determined people, they are each determined in very different ways. Jack is determined to not be a leader as much as to become a dictator, while Ralph wants to become a leader to keep the peace.

There are a few similarities and a number of differences between Jack and Ralph in the novel ‘Lord of the Flies’. First, the main similarity is the fact that both boys exhibit leadership qualities and become a leader on the island. Additionally, both of them are brave to try something new on this island. Like, hunting pig and using glasses to make a fire. On the other hand, there are some differences between them.

Anyone reading the end of the novel will generate a profound loathing for Jack who is totally paranoid and always feeds misinformation to his tribe, a typical practice of dictatorships to control the collective thinking by controlling the information that is disseminated. When Jack first loses in the voting of chief, “The circle of boys broke into applause. Even the choir applauded; and the freckles on Jack’s face disappeared under a blush of mortification” (Golding 19). His face falls and he feels ashamed, especially when he sees other boys are applauding and even his own choir is applauding. His endless desire for power is ignited at that moment.

Ralph and Jack are both powerful and meaningful characters in William Golding's novel, Lord of the Flies.  Ralph is an excellent leader; responsible, and stands for all that is good.  Jack is a destructive hunter, selfish, and represents evil.  These two main characters can be compared by the actions they take as leaders, their personalities, and what they symbolize in the story.

Ralph concentrates on being rescued and Jack goes along taking on the responsibility that he and his choir will mind the fire. “We’ll be responsible for keeping the fire going-”, (Page 38) but while Ralph remains focused on being rescued, Jack’s new-found interest in hunting leads him to forget about rescue. “Jack had to think for a moment before he could remember what rescue was. “Rescue? Yes, of course! All the same, I’d like to catch a pig first-.” (Page 58) This also starts to show that Jack has entered the realm of savagery.