Literary critics frequently insinuate that Claudio’s love for Hero does not epitomize true Shakespearian love. Critics like Stephanie Chamberlain and Jennifer Low claim that his affection roots in societal aspirations and material desires. Claudio, however, is not bereft of genuine love for Hero; rather, his actions result from the insecurities that typically accompany deep affection. In her essay “The Duelist as a Hero,” Low criticizes Claudio’s feelings towards Hero for being as shallow as his pockets are deep. She remains unconvinced that Claudio truly loves Hero, saying “Beatrice and Benedick replace Hero and Claudio as the primary love interest” because of his “shortcomings…as the play’s romantic lead.” (Low 28) His shortcomings refer …show more content…
His rash and harsh behavior stems from an intense love for Hero. In scene 2.1, Claudio does not think to question Don Jon when he tells him that his best friend, Don Pedro, will marry Hero. Why then would Claudio miserably rush out of the ball the minute he hears this calumniation? This behavior does not exemplify the man described in Chamberlain and Low’s essays. This is a man whose intense affection for Hero caused him to make an impetuous decision. This is further exampled in the wedding scene when Claudio gives an incensed speech condemning Hero as an unchaste whore, without appropriately investigating yet another plan from the already untrustworthy Don John. Claudio doesn’t break into this excessive tirade because he wishes to save his potentially damaged reputation - for his actions at the wedding embarrass him enough. Claudio does this because of the immense heartbreak that, logically, ensues after allegedly seeing your love engage in coitus with …show more content…
He allows his male principals to be insecure, emotional, and sensitive, often allowing emotions to impair judgment and reason - qualities often allotted to women. In addition, one can find a rejection of masculinity without venturing outside of Much Ado about Nothing. In the latter half of the play, Benedick’s love for Beatrice alters his own cold, rational judgment. In scene 2.3 Benedick believes that “man is a fool when he dedicates his behaviors to love.” (2.3.8-9) However, in the very same scene, Benedict admits that he “will be horribly in love with her.” (2.3.235) The juxtaposition of his statements makes evident the capricious nature of Shakespearian love. Moreover, his love forces him to turn his back on fraternal companionship when, after much protest, he promises Beatrice that he will kill his friend, Claudio. In this regard, Benedick submits to the authority of a woman, rejecting notions of masculine dominance in favor of love. Therefore, it is easier to imagine that Claudio’s harsh actions stem from sincere love for Hero when considering the analogous nature of the two aforementioned
In this Shakespearean comedy ‘Much Ado about Nothing’ two similarly obstinate characters of Beatrice and Benedick are presented between the rather normal relationship of characters Hero and Claudio. Shakespeare presents Beatrice and Benedick’s obstinacy towards the rather obligatory act of marriage and also their particularly similar personalities that cause reason for their familiar act of squabbling; he does this whilst also presenting two characters that are completely interested in marriage and who are hardly intellectually capable of squabbling in a similar manner. As the play unfolds both characters remain combative with one another but as love becomes the better of them, they begin to reveal that somewhat secretive sensitivity
"By my own spirit; for I should flout him, if he writ to me; yea
Claudio and Hero’s relationship is not strong because Claudio does not trust anyone in the affairs of love. He says ‘friendship is constant in all other things, save in the office and affairs of love’. He also says ‘and trust no agent for beauty is a witch’.
The humiliation caused to Hero in the event would be inconceivable to an audience at the time, being accused of adultery would no doubt ruin a woman’s reputation and therefore create difficulty for her when finding a husband; especially for a woman of high status such as Hero. Claudio is being presented as a potential threat at this part in the play, contrasting with the gallant war hero we were first introduced to. This emphasizes how bitter and sinister Claudio has turned, consequently reminding the audience by irony that is he only interested in wealth and status when marrying Hero. Claudio’s shallow fickleness plays into the villain’s hands. Shakespeare uses the threat of Claudio to generate further anxiety in the audience and concern for Hero’s welfare. This scene shows the men of the play coinciding with each other in their response to the defamation of Hero. Don Pedro personally insults Hero during the commotion of this scene, “to link my dear friend to a common stale,” he suggests here that he believes her status has been lowered by what she has supposedly done and rendered her ‘common’. This personal attack on Hero which has come from someone who shouldn’t really be involved advocates the idea that she is isolated in a patriarchal society in which men group together to defend male interests. Hero’s reputation is being publicly ruined here, and at the time this would have ruined Hero’s life and her
Hero does not get a chance to mull over the idea of Claudio as a husband. Even the audience knows little about her going into the now famous “shaming scene.” Details about Hero’s virtues and personality are purposely left out, partially to satisfy the dominant male perspective in the play, but also to give more clout to the heinous claim that Claudio makes during the wedding. The reactions of Hero’s father and others indicate that a woman’s virtues are only as good as a man says they are.
Like many of Shakespeare's other heroes, Benedick has a comic and serious side. I think he combines everything Shakespeare seems to like in a character; he is amusing (his witty banter with Beatrice is where most of the humour in this play revolves around) and he is also able to laugh at himself- he takes in good humour like the teasing of his friends about his cynicism about matrimony. He is loving too, (an example of this is his poem to Beatrice) and also deadly serious is his love for her- he renounces his male comradeship to "kill Claudio" as she demands- he is prepared to give up his current, enjoyable way of life for her. He is also loyal to the prince, in that he despises Don John, but he is most loyal to the one he loves, something the majority of Shakespearean heroes personify (even those who go astray eventually return to their love- Romeo never wavers from his purpose in loving Juliet). His relationship with Beatrice is another ideal held up to us by the playwright. Beatrice chooses Benedick, she pleases herself, not her family, and as a result, their relationship is much more equal and evenly balanced. It is this relationship, and not the other, quite stereotypical romance, which Shakespeare makes the main thread of this drama.
Benedick’s attitude to love & marriage in ‘‘Much Ado About Nothing’’ In the play ‘‘Much Ado About Nothing’’ by William Shakespeare, the character of Benedick shows mixed emotions towards loves and marriage throughout. In the two extracts we studied, Benedick shows a large contrast of opinions: In Act 1 Scene 1, Benedick portrays strong feelings of contempt towards love and marriage, whereas by Act 2 Scene 3, Benedick has completely changed his views and he is prepared to make the commitment and marry Beatrice, a woman he appeared to dislike in the beginning of the play and who seemed to have mutual feelings towards Benedick. Act 1 Scene 1 portrays that Benedick has a very negative attitude towards love and marriage. When conversing with
In the play of Much Ado About Nothing, the characters of Benedick and Beatrice have a love-hate relationship. On the surface, it appears that their relationship is built on a war of wits and insults. However, in Benedick’s soliloquy, the reader discovers that at the core of their insults actually lie the true feelings of love. It is also apparent that Benedick even sees loving each other as a competition, in that he wants to love her to a point of outdoing her love for him. Not only is Benedick constantly warring with Beatrice, but he is also undergoing an internal struggle, which is made quite apparent in Benedick’s soliloquy in Act 2 Scene 3.
During the two gulling scenes, namely Act 2 Scene 3 and Act 3 Scene 1,
Shakespeare uses both Claudio and Leonato to represent the males of the time and the honor code they were held to. Claudio is in no way held to the same pre-marital expectations as Hero, which, at the time, was the case for all men. For instance, when Hero is accused of being with a man prior to her marriage, no one questions what man and, quite frankly, no one cares what man. Shakespeare also shows how men are judged and given honor based on how their women act. When Leonato learns of the accusations his daughter receives on her wedding day he scolds her and says,
Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet – popularly considered by many to be the quintessential love story of all time – is a play that we are all familiar with in one way or another. Whether it be through the plethora of portrayals, adaptations and performances that exist or through your own reading of the play, chances are you have been acquainted with this tale of “tragic love” at some point in your life. Through this universal familiarity an odd occurrence can be noted, one of almost canonical reverence for the themes commonly believed to be central to the plot. The most widely believed theme of Romeo and Juliet is that of the ideal love unable to exist under the harsh social and political strains of this world. Out of this idea emerge two
the rest of his life rather than marry a woman. Beatrice in a way is
Beatrice and Benedick are interesting due to Shakespeare’s use of language. Confusion is created as to whether they love or hate each other owing to their snide comments, such as Beatrice’s response “A bird of my tongue is better than a beast of yours” (1.1.104), notably continuing the reference to animals, after Benedick
Beatrice and Benedick, however, in much contrast to Hero and Claudio are the ideal couple who are both equal in the relationship. Beatrice is an opinionated and stubborn woman who will have no one if she doesn't have the one she wants, which she makes clear throughout the play by refusing to marry lightly and by the conversation in Act One between her and Pedro. She chooses
Throughout the play, Benedick's relationship with Beatrice is an important mark of his character. In the first scene