Malfroid and Aidman both comment on the ending of the film, and discuss the different ways it could be viewed. From a feminist perspective, Malfroid points out “Pocahontas does not depend on a marriage for her happiness - because she rejects both Kocuom and John Smith”. She chooses a path other than romantic fulfilment. This would further illustrate the fact that she is less dependent on men than other Disney princesses. However, Aidman believes that Pocahontas’ decision not to go with John Smith is actually anti-feminist. She claims that “it can only be viewed … as a subtext that a strong woman cannot have it all,” that Pocahontas is punished for being a strong female character and therefore is denied her happily ever after with her Prince …show more content…
Aidman suggests that Pocahontas is an example of a film which portrays Native Americans as the stereotype of the ‘noble savage’. She quotes Stuart Hall to explain what this is, as he defines it as “the good side of the ‘native’” which is “portrayed in a certain primitive nobility and simple dignity” which is produced out of white ambivalence (Stuart Hall cited in Aidman). This may be an improvement from the depiction of Native Indians as ‘savages’ who shoot at the hero in western films. However, it is still a harmful stereotype as it creates a sense of othering and sets Native Americans apart as something exotic and different to Euro-Americans. Native Americans then tend to be represented in an almost two dimensional idea of what Euro-Americans think they should be like.
During the production of Pocahontas, several Native American historical advisors were brought in, including Shirley Custalow-McGowan. She, like Pocahontas was from the Powhatan Nation. However, McGowan became disheartened when she realised that Disney was not giving much thought to historical accuracy, and said that she wished her name was never associated with the
In the movie, Native Americans are often portrayed as spiritual, noble, and free this ideal image of Native Americans captured the world’s imagination at one point. It all began in late 1800s when Native Americans were among the first to shot silent by Thomas. One of the common attraction that made
Lindsay’s statement illustrates how racial formation greatly influenced the actions and mindset of the European-Americans and its effects on Native Americans. It reveals how disillusioned European-Americans were because of their belief of racial superiority and that it caused them to turn a blind-eye to the possibilities of peaceful coexistence with the Native people. The portrayal of Native Americans as savages shows how European-Americans used this to prove themselves as a higher race in the social hierarchy and to justify their entitlement to the land and resources that waited for them in the west.
The film “The Englishman’s boy” is a screen adaptation of Guy Vanderhaeghe’s book of the same name. Vanderhaeghe also wrote the screenplay for the film. The book was based on the true story of the Cypress Hills massacre in 1873. I will provide a summary of the film’s most important plot points, characters and background information. The movie covers the horrors that were witnessed in Cypress Hills and shows the inhumane way Native Americans have been treated since colonization, in 1873 and through to the 1920s. The movie explains how white men were hearkened as heroes for committing these atrocities which were largely excused because society at that time viewed natives as inhuman and therefore undeserving of human rights. The film was set with a background in both 1873 pioneer plains and 1920s Hollywood. This method was used to show a dualism within the two eras and that negative attitudes towards Native Americans had not been corrected as they should have been but only muffled. I will compare the film and its accuracy to the actual Cypress Hills massacre and determine what dramatics were used to make a point within the direction of the movie. This film and the subsequent essay is relevant to this class because I believe that even though the crimes committed against native Americans are less obviously racist, violent and vulgar today, there is still a derogatory indifference towards them and their cries for equality.
Many Indians in the early 19 century where looked as less or lower than the white man mainly because of the concepts of Indian in the early century stating" This concept of a separate Indian/white culture, or a "racial pluralism," was central to the films of American movie pioneer, David Wark (D. W.) Griffith. Angela Aleiss. Making the White Man's Indian: Native Americans and Hollywood Movies (Kindle Locations 161-162). Kindle Edition. " Author Angela Alesis in Making the White Man's Indian uses refences, clear writing style, and great author agenda in supporting her topic on how the early 19th century through today did not correctly model what an Indian represented.
In this depiction, the Native Americans lure the men away from their homes, savagely kill their families, and commit wrong. It is the white men who have to painstakingly hunt down the Indians to reinstate justice, righting the wrongs that have been done. Native Americans are depicted as a demonizing form of "the other," a force to which fear and repression can be the only responses. Costner's work almost inverts this.
In the United States, when a child is asked to think about Christopher Columbus, chances are the child will portray him as a courageous, heroic explorer who discovered America. However, when a child is asked about what they think of when they see an Indian, the child will most likely describe a half-naked human with a feather on his head. Any young American will unknowingly stereotype Indians as figures of the past. These cognitive constructs [stereotypes] are often created out of a kernel and then distorted beyond reality (Hoffmann, 1986). Without any doubt, these attributed characteristics are incorrect. Unfortunately, the majority of Americans regard Indians as “obstacles to white settlement.” However, historians, scientists, and researchers understand the fact that Indians were “one of the principle determinants of historical events.” So where does the tragic level of misinformed Americans come from?
Pocahontas was the most well-known woman in the first years of permanent British settlement on the Virginia Coast. There is a myth that she saved John Smith from murder by her tribe, but it is now thought that the tribe was trying to adopt Smith into the tribe, and the ritual was not life threatening. It is however, widely known that she was Chief Powhatan’s favorite daughter. Her high status allowed Pocahontas to serve as an intermediary between her people and the English settlers. She served as an interpreter and explained the different cultures of both sides. Without her, both her tribe and the English settlers would not have been able to talk to or trade with one another. At some point, the relationship between the settlers and the tribe
From the first mention of Native Americans in American history, they are characterized as “savages” and “less intelligent” human beings. This characterization has remained predominate throughout American history, however in colonial times, this characterization had a larger emphasis in how Americans view Indians. Although this the way in which Americans viewed Native Americans, Native Americans, on the other hand, viewed Americans as “white [racially superior]” (Svingen). In today’s modern day and age, we understand the complexity when it comes to stereotyping certain ethnic groups. In regards to Native Americans in a post-World War II setting, labeling and stereotyping such ethnic group emphasizes the importance to integrate individuals of
In this paper I will be addressing my thoughts and emotions while viewing the movie Dances with Wolves. This movie drastically changed my views not solely on the culture of the Indians but also on the way White settlers treated them and promptly took whatever they wanted.
Conflicts of the West Introduction There has been many conflicts in the West that have included whites, and Native Americans. The hardships, and conflicts that the Native Americans have had to go through are very substantial to the history that was made in the West. Exactly how did the Indians start out in the West? The conflicts in the West were very external like conflicts between the tribes, extinction of the buffalo, wars with whites, and being moved from homes onto reservations.
Hollywood’s early depictions of Natives consisted of tribesmen and noble savages who are in tune with Nature. Films such as The Silent Enemy portray these stereotypes on screen with actors like Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance being shown as tribesmen who are very noble Natives. Although these stereotypes are positive, they are still stereotypes nonetheless. These stereotypes have caused
Another de-humanizing example of Native Americans is the way they are depicted in movies and films, especially old Westerns. The way they are portrayed in these movies is the same way many people unaware of Native culture still view them. Their dress is one inaccurate portrayal of Native Americans. Every Native American in a movie is either wearing a full tribal headdress, or some other sort of feather attire. Basically it all amounts to all tribes being considered to dress the same, when they actually had different attire and forms of dress including forms of presentation, and different types of jewelry. Another stereotype used in these movies is the assumption that all Native Americans live in teepees. This again points to the fact that all Native cultures were grouped together and viewed as the same. Yet another example of
The well-known story of Pocahontas is fairly new to me. Only knowing her selflessness and her saving of John Smith, I knew my knowledge had holes. Between there and her death I knew scarcely anything. However, from what I did know, I believed it to be the truth like many other normal people. Her life and legend, upon further examination, may be quite different from the story we grew up with and were told to believe. Pocahontas is sometimes referred to as the mother of America and in her short life did many truly wonderful things, but her life has become a myth.
The Europeans looked down on the Native American culture because of the differences between their lifestyles. They also present them as people with no morals because the Native Americans were not Christians like they were. The word “savage”, one of the most popular terms used to stereotype Indians, was popularized by these seventeenth century settlers. This became the bases of people’s false assumptions about the Native American culture. America’s growing population increased the labels that Native Americans still deal with today.
Popular culture has shaped our understanding and perception of Native American culture. From Disney to literature has given the picture of the “blood thirsty savage” of the beginning colonialism in the new world to the “Noble Savage,” a trait painted by non-native the West (Landsman and Lewis 184) and this has influenced many non native perceptions. What many outsiders do not see is the struggle Native American have on day to day bases. Each generation of Native American is on a struggle to keep their traditions alive, but to function in school and ultimately graduate.