preview

Mel Gibson's Tragic Depiction In The Passion Of The Christ

Decent Essays

There’s something fundamentally wrong with this world. Judeo-Christians blame sin and man's sinful nature. Because of man's imperfection, we get death, deceit, and destruction. Everyone would agree the effects are monstrous, and deliverance from the world’s depravity seems to be everyone’s pursuit, yet we all fail at achieving it. Which is why Jesus Christ came to die for our sins, “because the wages of sin is death;” to be a vicarious sacrifice, the death of Christ had to be and was a gruesome event. But, how gruesome? And is the film The Passion of the Christ a sagacious depiction? Film critics have charged Mel Gibson, the director of The Passion of The Christ, for being unnecessarily morbid depicting the crucifixion and left out the achievement that Christ’s offering brought to mankind. Others defend Gibson’s portrayal; by arguing one must understand his Catholic background so as to shed light on his macabre depiction. Steven Greydanus, from the National Catholic Register, is a defender of Gibson’s work. In his article “Understanding the Catholic Meaning of The Passion of the Christ,” he ultimately argues that interpreting …show more content…

Scott, from The New York Times, was one who felt disturbed by the film saying it “has the feel of a horror movie.” (Scott) This is because “The Passion of the Christ is so relentlessly focused on the savagery of Jesus’ final hours that this film seems to arise less from love than from wrath” (Ibid) As a rhetorical structure, A.O. Scott uses the motif of Christ’s sacrifice of love for humanity and Gibson’s depiction of the event as the perversion of the events that transpired. “A viewer, particularly one who accepts the theological import of the story, is thus caught in a sadomasochistic paradox” (Ibid). Gibson’s desire to make a realistic film about the passion is taken to account, but “the style and tone of The Passion are far from what is ordinarily meant by realism,” causing the film to have the “feel of a horror movie”

Get Access