preview

Meyers Vs. Commonwealth: Misuse Of Discretion

Decent Essays
Open Document

2. In Meyers v. Commonwealth, Meyers argued that the court misused its discretion by allowing his wife to testify. He said that his act of pointing a gun at his wife was a privileged conversation. The court did misuse its discretion based on the law, but the court’s decision to allow his wife to testify was a harmless error. The issues in Meyers v. Commonwealth are whether the gun possession charge is part of the same proceeding as the other charges and if not, whether his gun possession charge is a wrongful act against his wife. The misuse of discretion is whether the trial judge's decision was unreasonable or unfair by a legal basis. Because the court let his wife testify in violation of the spousal testimonial privilege, the court abused

Get Access