preview

Mirror Image

Decent Essays

Adapting to changes is one of the most difficult mental and physical challenges a person can face. The struggle to adapt to change makes a strong presence in both Alice in Lena Coakley’s “Mirror Image,” and Barry, from W.D. Valgardson’s “Saturday Climbing.” Alice is the protagonist in “Mirror Image” and the author illustrates the struggle of self-acceptance she faces after having a brain transplant. Barry is the protagonist of “Saturday Climbing” and he tries to cope with the fact that his daughter is not a child anymore and seeks independence. Both characters have many similarities regarding their struggle with adapting. Change is a very strong, opposing force that emphasizes the battle both characters face to achieve inner peace.

The internal …show more content…

Alice and Barry have family struggles where their loved ones are against them. Additionally, Barry and Alice are have conflicts with the media. However, Alice is the centre of attention for the media because she is the first person with a successful brain transplant, whereas Barry can be a used in the media as a representation of the conflicts a father faces in a typical father-daughter relationship. Barry has trust issues with his daughter, ever since she came home with the “sweet-sour smell of marijuana clung to her” (Coakley 23). Similarly, Alice’s twin sister, Jenny, has trouble trusting Alice when she wants to read her diary. Jenny denies her and replies that she “[has] to get to know [her] better” (Coakley 2), enforcing that she does not trust her. Despite these similarities, they have many differences in their struggles with the people around them. Alice has family issues where her mother and twin sister have trouble accepting Alice in her new body; it is jarring for them. Jenny is the most critical in her family, as she feels as if “[Alice] is dead” (Coakley 6). This shows that she thinks the Alice she knew is dead, even though Alice tries to prove that she is still alive. Despite Jenny feeling this way, Alice’s mother also feels uneasy and uncomfortable around her. Alice observes that her mother may think that she is not “the same daughter she knew before” (Coakley 6), and that she tries to avoid any eye contact with her. Another difference between Barry and Alice is that, Alice has a struggle with society and the donor’s family. People in her community have trouble recognizing her and they mistake her for Gail, Alice’s donor. The Jarreds, Gail’s family, also have a grudge against Alice; Mrs. Jarred feels helpless and desperate that she cannot see her “supposed” daughter. In contrast to Alice’s situation, Barry struggles to rekindle his relationship with his

Get Access