preview

Murder In Eirskine Caldwell's Daughter

Decent Essays

Is it possible to murder someone out of love? In the story “Daughter” by Eirskine Caldwell Jim murders his daughter because he can not care for her. He sees his daughter crying day after day, and he knows that he can’t do anything to help her. Jim believes he is doing the right thing by murdering her. He believes he is killing her out of love. Still Jim Carlisle should not be allowed to go free. He killed his own daughter, and however good his excuses are; he should have to pay the consequences.
Jim murders his daughter because he can’t care for her. He can’t feed her, and he knows that she will soon die from starvation. She complains to him about being hungry. “Daughter said she was hungry, and I just couldn’t stand it no longer.”(30) He couldn’t stand hearing her going hungry. He knew she was dieing and her agony was too much for him to bear. “I just couldn’t stand to hear her say it.”(30) Jim feels that he has failed as a father because he can’t provide for his family. …show more content…

When asked if the shooting was an accident he replies “no, … I picked up my shotgun and done it.” (36) He doesn’t feel bad about his actions because he believes that he had no other options. Jim believes that he killed her out of love. He could tell that his daughter was dying, and he felt her pain as she was slowly going hungry. He took it upon himself to put her out of her misery. “When she woke up this morning saying she was hungry, I just couldn’t stand it.“ (37) He repeats the phrase “I just couldn’t stand it“ several times. This shows Jim’s helplessness towards his daughters suffering. Rather than watch her suffer, he decides to kill

Get Access