preview

My Antonia Research Paper

Decent Essays

When we talk about books we know for sure that all of them try to teach us something, even the worst book also try for the same thing. However, in order to educate Pre- AP students effectively we can only choose five books because we want them to know what they need to know. Luckily, I have to read two books in my summer. One of them is “My Antonia” and another one is “The color purple”. Both of them are good, but the one should be included in our five books is My Antonia. My Antonia is the book that will be able to teach our student from literature to life. When we evaluate a book to see if it appropriates for our student or not we think about its grammar, its realistic, its difficulty and its interest. Two of the reasons My Antonia should be on the list and not the other one are its grammar and its realistic. One of the sentences in the book said: “While we snuggled down there …show more content…

The few strengths of My Antonia are it is real but new, it also teaches our student one thing is immigrating to America is not always the good thing, which is opposite of what our students usually learn. One of the phrases in the book reflects that is: “Grandmother had said: “Heavy field work’ll spoil that girl… She has lost them already.”(120) It shows us a new perspective of life that not many of our students have a chance to learn much about, which is a part of educating our students. However, it also has one weakness is that I is being use so much in the book. One of the major weaknesses about The color Purple is its language. One of the phrases in the book said: “What he beat you for? She ast. For being me and not you.” (75) The grammar is so wrong that a student will probably a bad habit after read the book. Plus, the words are so simple that will not prepare our students for all of the tests. My Antonia is not a perfect book, but at some points it will teach our students a lot, so we should let our students read

Get Access