Naturalistic Setting: Article Analysis

In reviewing this article, this writer was able critique the study and the suitability that it can possess if applied to actual practice. An important factor on whether a study can be considered valuable is if it is transferable in other situation, that is, a study's results should also be reflective if duplicated on other samples (Polit & Beck, 2006). Thus, the statistical power, internal and external validity are important to observe and note (Polit & Beck). If this writer were to carry out this study, it would have to be reflective of how the researcher performed it originality.

Throughout this assignment, my perspective on the person I studied changed. I learned several things about their character and the behavior that they presented. This task showed me that by simply observing a person’s behavior, my perspective about them changes.

·  Based on your review of the statistics in the study, do you agree with the study’s conclusions? Why or why not?

The strengths of this article is that the author uses information from a survey that was

Naturalistic observation is a research technique involving the observation of people or objects in their natural environments to gather data. When performing a naturalistic observation, it is key for the researcher to remain unavowed to the subject, or the result of the data could be skewed. When conducting a naturalistic observation to study the exercise times of young adult males versus older adult males, a good place to make observations would be at a gym, a popular hiking trail, or in a populated city (ex: downtown Washington, D.C.) where there are large sidewalks and plenty of room for foot traffic. Next, determine the variables. The measurable variables would be determined by witnessing a subject perform some sort of exercise, or any act that raises the heart rate above its natural rhythm on purpose at different times of day (ex: bike riding, running or jogging, roller blading, weight lifting, swimming, etc.). A record is kept regarding the execution of the variables, and after spending a viable amount of time collecting data from the subjects, the results of the study can be concluded. A possible result of the study could be that it is more common for older adult males to exercise early in the morning, while it is more common for younger adult males to exercise late in the evening.

Chapter 4 explained the results obtained from analysis of the surveys. The results were analyzed and significant findings were discussed further.

INSTRUCTOR NOTE: You are being asked to comment on YOUR perceived value of this study. There is not really a right or wrong answer to these questions. This question is a simple way to uncover a basic understanding of the outcome measures. Outcome measures look at what is the value and applicability of the research in the real world. The author may or may not state the outcome measures in a clear manner. You can re-iterate the author’s view or draw your own conclusion. If the author does not state the outcome (which is often the case) state so and offer your own opinion.

In this report, I will explore the eight worry questions as used by Wild and Pfannkuch (1999) and the seven critical components known as the guidelines from Utts (2004) to evaluate the study and from this I will discuss the validity of the study and propose ways in which the article could be improved to truly represent and reflect the findings of the study. Utts (2014 p.18) argues that “the meaning we can attach to data, and to the resulting conclusions, depends on how well the information was acquired and summarised”, therefore it is important to evaluate how statistical

The authors state reliability and validity testing were not completed on the survey questions (Gordon et al., 2014, p.14), and include this as a

This study was limited due to the small sample size. Although the conclusions are valid, more research with a

This is a qualitative observation with at least three limitations effecting an otherwise excellent study. Firstly the groups are small. Secondly the groups are mismatched 25 to 14. this is a dramatic mismanagement. Thirdly self-reports are deficient in reliability in various

I feel that no research study is perfect, and this is no exception. The research

The strength of questionnaires is it can give an insight into respondent’s thoughts and opinions and also cost efficient as it is inexpensive.

The objective of this chapter is to describe the procedures used in the analysis of the data and present the main findings. It also presents the different tests performed to help choose the appropriate model for the study. The chapter concludes by providing thorough statistical interpretation of the findings.

The article supports its conclusion and claims by analysed data presented in tables and texts and literature from other studies, similarity with other studies.