Nazi Concentration Camps Vs Japanese Internment Camps Essay

Both of the camps violated people's rights as citizens. The Nazi and the Japanese camps were illegal and a complete violation of people’s freedom. Both the Jews and the Japanese people were forced out of their homes. Ronald Reagan addressed this when he said, “Over one hundred thousand persons of Japanese ancestry were removed from their homes…” Anne Frank also addressed this in her diary on November 19, 1942, when she stated, “They knock on every door, asking whether any Jews live there. If so, the whole family is immediately taken away.” The Japanese and the Jews were both considered “the enemy”. The Jews were the Nazi’s enemy and the Japanese were America’s enemy. These a good points but they are not strong enough. The camps were both illegal but one is more illegal than the other. The Japanese camps were more illegal because there is more freedom in the U.S. than there is in Germany. Just because the Japanese and the Jews were forcefully take out of their homes, they are not the same thing. This point makes them alike but not the same. The Jewish and the Japanese were the enemy but not of the same people. Despite their differences, the Nazi and the Japanese camps did have quite a bit in common but that does not make them the

The camps that the Japanese-Americans were taken to had the worse conditions imaginable. “More than 120,000 Americans of Japanese Ancestry were incarcerated in 10 camps scattered throughout the Western United States during World War II” (Children of the Camps Project 1). Detainees spent many years in these camps. They were locked behind barbed wire fences, and armed guards patrolled the camps. The conditions were comparable to the Jewish camps in Eastern Europe. Entire families lived in quarters that were poorly constructed and horribly cramped. These areas were also unbearably cramped and unclean. There was also no hot water for dishes or showers in the living quarters. In addition, lice was a huge problem in the internment camps. These camps and the laws that our government passed against the Japanese community were atrocious. The United States experienced a terrible tragedy when Pearl Harbor was attacked. However, the American government had no right to make these innocent Americans prisoners of war. During the 1940s and 1950s the Japanese

Both the Jewish and Japanese camps were discriminatory towards the Jewish and Japanese race. However the Japanese internment camps were put into place out of fear, because Japan dropped a bomb on the United States. While the Jewish concentration camp was put into place because the Jewish “caused” the Great depression. However the camps are similar because they were made for the same reason which was racial discrimination. Both the Jewish and Japanese camp homes were ransacked, and were forcefully put out their homes. Their business were also taken away. Therefore they were put in the camps against their will and were not happy with living there. In both America and Germany the government claimed innocent, when really they were the guilty ones. If it were not for the United States of Germany government the camps would have never been created. Which would have never led to racial discrimination towards the Jewish or Japanese. Many would think that America was just as guilty as Germany, for the only difference is the amount of people killed. Although some if these points are true, they are not strong enough. The Japanese were put into the camps out of fear while the Jews were put into camp for the feeling of ultimate power

Concentration camps and internment camps both wanted people to suffer, but overall, they weren’t all that similar. The Holocaust was 12 years long from 1933-1945. The Japanese-American Relocation was held for 4 years from 1942-1946. Many people think these camps are the same, but if these people dig deeper they are realize they are nowhere close. The Japanese internment camps and the Jewish concentration camps aren’t essentially the same for three main reasons: Jews were forced to work while Japanese had the option, Jews were put to death, but the internment camps no one was killed, and concentration camps were formed for different reason.

Another thing that was bad about the internment camp is that there was a lot of racism going on between the Americans and the Japanese. The anti-racism has been going in the United States since the 19th century. There were tensions between the Asian immigrant workers and the whites because they were force to compete for jobs and land. The United States Congress decided to discourage the Japanese immigrants and to prohibit the naturalization of Japanese immigrants. “The state of California banned the marriages between the whites and the people of Asian descent” (KIM). This is also racism also because the Japanese were the only race that was send to the camps. There were signs on street and billboard on stores

The Jewish concentration camps were way worse than the Japanese internment camps, “Then Jack would snap back to reality, his stomach turning inside out from hunger, his body infested in lice, men around him dying from hunger, disease and sorrow” (Warren 72). This shows the reader the Jews were living in the concentration

In concentration camps, they slept on concrete bunk beds as well as wooden bunk beds that were meant to hold 52 horses, they had no heat, the ceilings were damp and leaky, the prisoners only got 1,300 calories a day, that’s 500 less calories than what the average human should have, they had to work about 10 hours each day. In internment camps, they were located in areas where there's harsh weather, they had schools and medical care in the camps, the japanese were payed to work at the camps, but many people did die from the poor amount of health care or the intenses stress they were put under while being in the camps. They had there own animal stalls that was almost like their home. The prisoners i n the camps were almost treated as slaves, making FDR and Hitler feel like they had more power.

Some people claim that the Internment camps were worse than Nazi camps but in reality, they were a bit alike but nothing really similar to them. Some of the hardships were bad food and very small living spaces but they were in there for national security, not for extermination. Over two-hundred voluntarily moved in.(Pipes) Families dined together at communal mess halls.(USHistory.org) Some of the internees had the option of serving in the army. One of the strongest units was the 442nd regiment, an all Japanese unit in Europe. So camps never reached the levels of Nazi camps.(USHistory.org)

In many times throughout history groups of people have been discriminated against based on race or religion. These people receive inferior rights because of the discrimination. In some cases they do not get citizenship, in others they are segregated from others, and physically harmed. Two groups of people that faced discrimination near World War II (WWII) were the Jewish people and Japanese Americans. Both groups faced very different types of discrimination by different oppressors with different motives yet their treatment was very similar and many events paralleled each other. The treatment of Japanese in WWII internment camps was as harsh as the Holocaust's treatment of the Jewish people.

Two months after Pearl Harbor, President Roosevelt authorized “Executive order 9066”. Which made More than 110,000 Japanese in the U.S to relocate to internment camps for reason of “national security”. The United States feared that they’re could have been Japanese spies inside America so the government relocated most Japanese immigrants to camps. It was one of the saddest moments in America that the government of America took actions on innocent people just because their heritage. America’s internment camps are similar yet different to Hitler’s concentrations camps.

There is a strong similarity between the German government who used concentration camps to imprison Jewish people and the U.S. government who interned Japanese Americans. For the Americans, it was thought that any and all Japanese citizens could be potential spies and attack the U.S. In the U.S., the U.S. created internment camps and held Japanese families captive. In Germany, it was believed that Germans were elite and the Jewish people caused

Many Americans didn’t like Americans with Japanese Descendancy. They were afraid that something terrible would happen to themselves and their family. According to the Article The Crisis, it states, “Color seems to be the only possible reason why thousands of American citizens of Japanese ancestry are in concentration camps.” This means that the only reason why Japanese people were being sent to camps is because of how they look. In reality,

To begin with, During world war II, Americans didn't put Germans or italians in internment camps, in the article JAPANESE-AMERICANS WAS AN UNNECESSARY AND RACIST ACT , paragraph 2 it states “ No such measure was taken against german or italian nationals”. I think that it wasn't fair to the Japanese-Americans because when the “German Americans” were going into war with germany, america didn't stop them even though that they’re were spies with germany in america and their

The second way the Japanese were treated unfairly because of their nationality was they had psychological trauma from being in the camps. To start things off, the first way that the Japanese had psychological trauma is there was an increase in heart disease and Japanese committing suicide, the numbers got bigger as the generations go on. This shows Japanese had psychotic trauma because they had suicidal thoughts. Next, the second way that the Japanese had psychological trauma is that the trauma that many Japanese Americans experienced from the internment camps stayed with them even after they left. According to http://www.pbs.org/childofcamp/history/index.html, “The mental and physical health impacts of the trauma of the internment experience

"I spent my boyhood behind the barbed wire fences of American internment camps and that part of my life is something that I wanted to share with more people," -George Takei. While the death-driven camps in Nazi Germany unleashed hatred to the Jewish population, the United States government used Japanese American Internment Camps to racially segregate, imprison, and punish Japanese Americans to eliminate the risk of a Japanese American doubling as a spy.